Caleigh’s Crumb Co.

  • Home
  • Caleigh’s Crumb Co.
Call Contact the business

Caleigh’s Crumb Co. Formerly known as The Cottage Shoppes
Custom sugar cookies and small batch sweets
Cottage bakery in St. Marys, Ohio

05/10/2026

The winners are in!

After all of your votes, the winning designs for our Build Your Own Cookie Set are officially here!

The winning designs are:
-Top View of a pumpkin
-Best Season Ever
-Boo
-Truck with a pumpkin
-Jack Skellington
-Autumn Leaf

And now for the part you’ve all been waiting for…

Congratulations to our THREE lucky winners!

Becky Anderson
Kelly Maurer
Melinda Finke Slife

Each winner will be receiving 1/2 dozen sugar cookies featuring the winning designs in my cookie nip flavor!

Cookie Nip is my take on a snickerdoodle-style sugar cookie, with delicious notes of caramel and cinnamon throughout! Think warm, cozy, fall flavors… but in cookie form!

Winners- please message me what day works best for pickup of your cookies (October 17 or 18 at the earliest!)

A HUGE thank you to everyone who participated, voted, commented, shared, and followed along throughout this giveaway! Your support means so much to my little baking business.

I can’t wait to make these cookie sets for our winners, and honestly, I think the winning design lineup turned out SO GOOD!

Congratulations Becky, Kelly, and Melinda!!

Locally Grown baby shower cookie set!There’s something extra sweet about celebrating a new little one with a theme that ...
03/10/2026

Locally Grown baby shower cookie set!

There’s something extra sweet about celebrating a new little one with a theme that feels this wholesome!

This “Locally Grown” baby shower set features adorable distressed overalls, carrots, tomato rattles, corn on the cob, personalized “Tate” cookies, and a custom “Baby” plaque to tie it all together!

I absolutely loved bringing this cookie set to life, and those corn on the cob cookies may be my favorite detailed cookies!

Don’t forget about the free cookie contest, where 3 lucky winners will receive 1/2 dozen of my Cookie Nip sugar cookies in the designs YOU vote for!

We are officially 5/6 cookies into creating your cookie set!

This means we are SO close to the finished set! If you haven’t been following along, head over to my page and vote on the polls to help decide what cookies make it into the final set!

Remember, your interaction matters!
-Vote on the polls
-Comment your favorites
-Share the polls so others can participate too
-Like/Follow Caleigh’s Crumb Co.

The more you participate, the better your chances of being one of the lucky winners when the contest comes to end (AKA 1 MORE POLL!)

So, if you’ve been meaning to participate, now is the time!

Head over to my page, Caleigh’s Crumb Co., and make sure you’ve cast your votes!

All votes will be finalized TOMORROW (Sunday October 4, 2026 and winners will be announced later this coming week!)

30/09/2026

Build your OWN fall cookie set!

Okay… now I can tell you what I’ve been up to!

I’m putting together a special fall/Halloween sugar cookie set, but YOU are going to help me design what’s in it!

Over the next few days, I’ll be showing you different options for designs.

(Yesterday: 👻 or 🍁, Monday: 🎃or Top-view Pumpkin)

You vote on your favorites, and the winning designs will become Caleigh’s Crumb Co. 2026 Fall Cookie Set!

But here’s the best part!

THREE PEOPLE will win a half-dozen (6) of the Fall Set completely FREE! (Pickup October 17/18)!

The cookies will be in my Cookie Nip Flavor- my take on a classic snickerdoodle sugar cookie, it has notes of caramel and cinnamon and is absolutely DELICIOUS! (Those who have had it, please let everyone know how delicious they are!)

To enter:
1) Follow/like Caleigh’s Crumb Co.
2) Participate in the polls!
3) Comment/Share/Like this post!

The more you participate, the more fun this gets!

So, are you ready to build our cookie box? 😃😄

A little wedding cake + a LOT of cupcakes!I had the pleasure of creating this small vanilla wedding cake and 13 dozen cu...
28/09/2026

A little wedding cake + a LOT of cupcakes!

I had the pleasure of creating this small vanilla wedding cake and 13 dozen cupcakes, that’s 156 cupcakes, for a beautiful celebration!

The cake was kept simple and elegant with a smooth buttercream finish and a gorgeous arrangement of flowers on top in coordinating wedding colors! The cupcakes were vanilla, chocolate, and coffee with espresso buttercream!

There is just something so special about getting to be a small part of someone’s wedding day, and I’m so grateful to every couple who trusts me with such an important part of their celebration!

From an intimate cake to over 150 cupcakes, I love bringing your vision to life- one sweet treat at a time!

Congratulations to the happy couple!!

And if you’re planning a wedding, shower, birthday, or other celebration, I’d love to create something sweet for you!

Caleigh’s Crumb Co. - local pickup in St. Marys, Ohio
Message me today to get on my books before I take my sabbatical welcoming baby Slife to our family in December!

Address

314 Market Street
OH
45885

Telephone

+14193039273

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Caleigh’s Crumb Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Caleigh’s Crumb Co.:

Shortcuts

  • Want your business to be the top-listed bakery?

Share