Custom Cookies by Erin

Custom Cookies by Erin Cottage food registered home & hobby cookier
South Metro Twin Cities, MN

05/27/2026

Which animal is your favorite?! I’m loving the little monkey. 🐒

🍃 A little wild one is on the way! 🤎 Mom’s favorite are elephants and dad’s favorite are sloths, so we obviously had to ...
05/26/2026

🍃 A little wild one is on the way! 🤎 Mom’s favorite are elephants and dad’s favorite are sloths, so we obviously had to incorporate both!

Those credentials though! 👏🤩 Kaelen’s sweet friends got her cookies to celebrate her graduation! She is officially a Doc...
05/11/2026

Those credentials though! 👏🤩 Kaelen’s sweet friends got her cookies to celebrate her graduation! She is officially a Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP) and a Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetist (CRNA)! What important and impressive roles to take on!

A slow push of propofol, a little laryngoscope action, and you’ll be asleep before you know it. Sweet dreams, courtesy of Dr. Dunn. 😴

What better way to celebrate your 2nd birthday than with cow and horse cookies! 🐮🐴I was going to make a separate post, b...
05/04/2026

What better way to celebrate your 2nd birthday than with cow and horse cookies! 🐮🐴

I was going to make a separate post, but since we’re on the topic of cows—Custom Cookies by Erin are now made with Irish butter from grass-fed cows!

You all know I’m always looking for ways to make my cookies and presentation even better. I decided to try Irish butter on a whim, not thinking it’d do much, but ohmygosh.. The flavor? Deep and rich. The texture? Melt-in-your-mouth perfection.

This is the beauty of supporting a small business. We don’t take short cuts, we don’t cut corners. There is constant tweaking, testing, and improving because the quality of what we offer is personal.

I can’t wait for you to taste the difference!

💛🩷🐶💜💙
04/30/2026

💛🩷🐶💜💙

04/27/2026

PUP PUP HOORAY! IT’S VADA’S BIRTHDAY!

GOOD NEWS—I HAVE FULL WEEKEND AVAILABILITY AGAIN! If you’ve checked out my online shop in the last few months, you may h...
04/23/2026

GOOD NEWS—I HAVE FULL WEEKEND AVAILABILITY AGAIN! If you’ve checked out my online shop in the last few months, you may have noticed that I had very limited openings. My work schedule changed and it took me some time to figure out if I could still fulfill orders for Friday and Saturday pick up or delivery.

I’m happy to say my Friday-Sunday schedule is back open! I look forward to your orders!

04/22/2026

What do you get when you mix a baby shower, golf, and Schitt’s Creek? A par-tee fit for Bébé Thalberg! ⛳️

What do you get when you mix a baby shower, golf, and Schitt’s Creek? A par-tee fit for Bébé Thalberg! ⛳️Even though thi...
04/20/2026

What do you get when you mix a baby shower, golf, and Schitt’s Creek? A par-tee fit for Bébé Thalberg! ⛳️

Even though this is her third baby, Ashley’s friends insisted on celebrating, so she asked me to make cookies to surprise them, complete with some Schitt’s Creek sprinkle jokes. IYKYK.

And of course, I had to throw in a “bébé” reference too because Catherine O’Hara. Period. 👑

Congrats, Thalberg fam!!!!

We can BEAR-ly wait! 🧸
04/13/2026

We can BEAR-ly wait! 🧸

I LOVE when you ask me to help with your surprises! Joe and Sue planned an Alaskan cruise with their kids and grandkids ...
04/08/2026

I LOVE when you ask me to help with your surprises!

Joe and Sue planned an Alaskan cruise with their kids and grandkids and wanted a fun way to reveal it to them. Cue the cookies!

I ordered some windowless boxes to keep it a true surprise until they opened it. To add to the anticipation, I created a post card in Canva that hinted at the trip but didn’t give it away. Joe and Sue were free to add a personal message on the back, a little keepsake when all the cookies are gone. 😊

Many people ask me how long it takes me to make cookies and my answer is usually 8-12 hours from dough to done, but sometimes it’s more. For this order of 36 cookies I spent over 9 hours decorating them. Yep, just decorating. 👀

Why so long? Most of these designs were done on plaque shapes, meaning each cookie needed a fully flooded and crusted over background before I could ice my design. Add in airbrushing, a lot of painting details, and bit of trial and error (those ocean waves 😅), and the time adds up quickly. That 9 hours doesn’t include planning, making dough, cutting and baking, making icing and mixing colors, taking photos, or packaging.

When I say custom decorated treats are a labor of love, I mean it!

If you missed my reel of these be sure to check it out!

Address

Rosemount, MN

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Custom Cookies by Erin posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category