Make My Cake

Make My Cake Baking the sweetest memories! Visit us online at makemycake.com. New York, NY 10030

121A St. Nicholas Avenue
New York, NY 10026
(560)

Make My Cake is a full-service retail and wholesale bakery specializing in scrumptious baked goods that boast both Southern flavor and Harlem inspiration. For the past 15 years, Make My Cake has offered their clientele heavenly desserts such as the homestyle butter cake, the New York Times’ pick, Red Velvet Cake, Food Network favorite, German Chocolate Cake, and local best-seller, Sweet Potato Cheesecake.

2380 Adam Clayton Powell Blvd.

YUM YUM is right! How cute are our pink rice kripsy treats, made in-store 💞
04/25/2023

YUM YUM is right! How cute are our pink rice kripsy treats, made in-store 💞

04/23/2023
04/23/2023

How Harlem is this? Kool DJ Red Alert 🚨 being interviewed at Harlem's favorite bakery 😉

If you didn't know, Kool DJ Red Alert, is recognized as one of the founding fathers of hip hop music and culture 🙌🏾

"Can’t celebrate without interviewing one of the founding fathers Kool DJ Red Alert "

@ iamjusnik on IG

Have a seat, browse our treats, then order something sweet 🍰 We know you usually order a slice of cake, but we dare you ...
04/20/2023

Have a seat, browse our treats, then order something sweet 🍰

We know you usually order a slice of cake, but we dare you to try something different like:

• Bread pudding 🍞
• Coconut Pecan cookies 🥥
• Apple cobbler 🍎
• Key lime pie 🥧

At 409 West 125th Street, we're baking with fresh ingredients, Southern hospitality, and of course love 💞

Carrot cake DEFINITELY counts towards your daily veggie intake🥕 Trust us 🤣
04/13/2023

Carrot cake DEFINITELY counts towards your daily veggie intake🥕 Trust us 🤣

Cake 🍰 & coffee ☕️ , what a combo 💞 Today’s a great day for this treat. We suggest a slice of German Chocolate cake & a ...
04/11/2023

Cake 🍰 & coffee ☕️ , what a combo 💞 Today’s a great day for this treat. We suggest a slice of German Chocolate cake & a cup from I Like It Black Coffee Shop
😉

Let's get into the details 🐰
04/08/2023

Let's get into the details 🐰

Hop on over to order your custom Easter cake for   🎂 🐰 Make your family & friends smile when they see what you have in s...
04/08/2023

Hop on over to order your custom Easter cake for 🎂 🐰 Make your family & friends smile when they see what you have in store for dessert. Make them even happier when they taste what makes our cakes so special 😉

📍409 W 125th Street

"Starting off Easter / Spring vibes weekend posts (Pt. 1) •••• Sweet Potato Cheesecake •••• If you’ve never had the chan...
04/08/2023

"Starting off Easter / Spring vibes weekend posts (Pt. 1) •••• Sweet Potato Cheesecake •••• If you’ve never had the chance to try the decadence that is Cheesecake flavored with the mellow flavors of Sweet Potato and Spices, you haven’t lived. •••• Go….. GO NOW!!! ••••• As of now, hands down my favorite item on the menu at / "

@ jtav_13 on IG

04/07/2023

Hop on over to order your custom Easter cake for 🎂 🐰 Make your family & friends smile when they see what you have in store for dessert. Make them even happier when they taste what makes our cakes so special 😉

📍409 W 125th Street

04/03/2023

🎶 Sugar pie, honey bunch. You know that I love you. I can’t help myself 🎶🤍

📷 @ bigappleeatss on IG

This is your reminder that you deserve a little something something. Treat yourself 😉 We suggest a moist chocolate frost...
03/31/2023

This is your reminder that you deserve a little something something. Treat yourself 😉

We suggest a moist chocolate frosted vanilla cupcake with sprinkles🧁

📍409 W 125th Street

Special birthday shoutout to Aliyyah Baylor, renowned Chief Baking Officer of Make My Cake Bakery 🎈🎉🥳Sweeties, drop a 🎂 ...
03/28/2023

Special birthday shoutout to Aliyyah Baylor, renowned Chief Baking Officer of Make My Cake Bakery 🎈🎉🥳

Sweeties, drop a 🎂 in the comments for the Harlem Cake Queen 👸🏾

Special birthday shoutout to Aliyyah Baylor, renowned Chief Baking Officer of Make My Cake Bakery 🎈🎉🥳Sweeties, drop a 🎂 ...
03/28/2023

Special birthday shoutout to Aliyyah Baylor, renowned Chief Baking Officer of Make My Cake Bakery 🎈🎉🥳

Sweeties, drop a 🎂 in the comments for the Harlem Cake Queen 👑

Join the I Like It Black's caffeinated team. We need baristas who possess great attitudes, solid work ethic and skill. V...
03/22/2023

Join the I Like It Black's caffeinated team. We need baristas who possess great attitudes, solid work ethic and skill.

Visit ILIB Monday March 27th for an in-person interview.

Send your resume to [email protected].

Help spread the word ☕️

**No DMs**

03/21/2023

**[email protected]**

Join our caffeinated team. We need baristas who possess great attitudes, solid work ethic and skill.

Visit ILIB Monday March 27th for an in-person interview.

Send your resumes to [email protected].

Share in your story. Help us spread the word ☕️

**No DMs**

We hope you're have a sweet Saint Patrick's day. Good luck 🍀 😉
03/17/2023

We hope you're have a sweet Saint Patrick's day. Good luck 🍀 😉

Happy Pi Day, Sweeties 🥧 We're celebrating with our famous Sweet Potato Pie 💞 3.14
03/14/2023

Happy Pi Day, Sweeties 🥧 We're celebrating with our famous Sweet Potato Pie 💞 3.14

We're baking personal cheesecakes everyday of the week 😉 Which would you order?🍒 Cherry  🍠 Sweet Potato 🗽 Classic NY🍓 St...
03/11/2023

We're baking personal cheesecakes everyday of the week 😉

Which would you order?

🍒 Cherry
🍠 Sweet Potato
🗽 Classic NY
🍓 Strawberry
🍍 Pineapple
🍋 Lemon

Want to share instead? You can purchase a whole cake. Call us to place your order.

Our moist decadent German Chocolate cake is a Sweetie favorite 🍫 What's your favorite MMC cake? Let us know 😉 ** Pro tip...
03/09/2023

Our moist decadent German Chocolate cake is a Sweetie favorite 🍫

What's your favorite MMC cake? Let us know 😉

** Pro tip: Pair it with a fresh hot brew from I Like It Black Coffee Shop ☕️

Our very own Aliyyah Baylor is in her zone judging latte art at the Coffee Fest  at the Javits Center  . We're impressed...
03/07/2023

Our very own Aliyyah Baylor is in her zone judging latte art at the Coffee Fest at the Javits Center . We're impressed with baristas from all over the world showing off their skills ☕️ I Like It Black is in the building and representing Harlem 🙌🏾 So thrilled to be a part of this !

Yes, we deliver, Sweeties 🚚 What decadent dessert are you ordering for your next baby shower, graduation party, birthday...
03/06/2023

Yes, we deliver, Sweeties 🚚 What decadent dessert are you ordering for your next baby shower, graduation party, birthday soiree, or family gathering?

🥧 Pie: Pumpkin, Pecan, Apple Cobbler &Sweet Potato

🎂 Cake: Red Velvet, German Chocolate, Coconut Pineapple & more

🍰 Cheesecake: Sweet Potato, Strawberry, Lemon & more

Let Make My Cake, make your day. Call or email us to schedule for delivery.

We're here to bake your life sweet 💞make* 😉
03/03/2023

We're here to bake your life sweet 💞

make* 😉

Our Red Velvet is like no other. Voted  #1 by the New York Times and you! 💞Come in, treat yourself to our Red Velvet sli...
02/27/2023

Our Red Velvet is like no other. Voted #1 by the New York Times and you! 💞

Come in, treat yourself to our Red Velvet slices, cupcakes, large & personal cheesecakes, and whole cakes 🎂

If you've had any of the above, let us know in the comments.

Sweeties, it's   🎂 The idea is to bring your family together, two or more, to bond at dinner and end your meal with a sw...
02/19/2023

Sweeties, it's 🎂 The idea is to bring your family together, two or more, to bond at dinner and end your meal with a sweet treat 💞

Let's embrace gathering family and creating sweet memories.

Visit us at 409 West 125th Street, where we're baking with love.

Myself, Mama Baylor of Ma Smith's Dessert Café  and Melba of Melba's Restaurant  judged some amazing food at "Queens and...
02/16/2023

Myself, Mama Baylor of Ma Smith's Dessert Café and Melba of Melba's Restaurant judged some amazing food at "Queens and Kings Who Cook" presented by Bronx Jack and Jill of America at Harlem Academy . We're proud to have been a part of such an event. We enjoyed celebrating Black History Month through food and community 🍽

"What an incredible Black History Celebration we had on February 11, 2023! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾Thank you for Everything!!!!🎉 The Black History committee, combined with both Bronx and Metro moms didn’t disappoint and for the second year, created an occasion not to be missed.💙💖 The families from the Bronx and Metro Chapters enjoyed an amazing event that fed over 200 minds, hearts and palates of the young and old.🎉 Loads of books were collected to contribute to the Harlem Academy library.📚 Our teens engaged in trivia games to learn more about the significance of the 50 year journey of Hip Hop Music and Culture today.🎤 Our younger children enjoyed making delicious apple peach crumble with Chef Rebecca Johnson💕and the adults enjoyed sampling all of the delicious soul food prepared for the competition.🎉 Special thanks to the fabulous judges: Melba Wilson of , Aliyyah Baylor and her mother Ms. Joanne of , Ramona Thomas of , and Cornell Freeman of 🎉

Shout out to Bronx President and Metro President for the idea of this fantastic collaboration.🎉🎉🎉 Black History is American History 365 Days of the Year!!"

Quote from Bronx Jack and Jill of America

Cupcakes are the new roses 😉 What are you picking up for your Sweetie today?We have a few suggestions:💕 Red velvet cupca...
02/14/2023

Cupcakes are the new roses 😉 What are you picking up for your Sweetie today?

We have a few suggestions:

💕 Red velvet cupcakes
💕 Strawberry buttercream frosted slices
💕 Red velvet mini cheesecakes

for your funny Valentine today.

📍409 W 125th Street

Happy Galentine’s Day 💕 Today is a day for women to celebrate their friendships with their lady friends. Essentially, th...
02/13/2023

Happy Galentine’s Day 💕 Today is a day for women to celebrate their friendships with their lady friends. Essentially, the meaning of Galentine’s Day is Valentine’s Day for your gals. (It’s right there in the name 😉)

Plan to pick up cute:

💕 Red velvet cupcakes
💕 Strawberry buttercream frosted slices
💕 Red velvet mini cheesecakes

for your sweetest friends today.

📍409 W 125th Street

We think a taste our signature Red Velvet is the perfect way to say "I love you".Valentine’s Day will be here soon. Plan...
02/12/2023

We think a taste our signature Red Velvet is the perfect way to say "I love you".

Valentine’s Day will be here soon. Plan to pick up sweets for your sweetie 💞

📍409 W 125th Street

Many sweeties say that they remember how they could smell the cakes from a block away at our 7th Avenue location. Do you...
02/07/2023

Many sweeties say that they remember how they could smell the cakes from a block away at our 7th Avenue location. Do you remember that? 😉

We'd love to know your fond memories of Make My Cake 💞 Considering we've been proudly serving Harlem for over 25 years, we can't wait to read your comments 😁

Love is in the air, and here at Make My Cake, it's right in front of you 🥰We think a taste our signature Red Velvet is t...
02/06/2023

Love is in the air, and here at Make My Cake, it's right in front of you 🥰

We think a taste our signature Red Velvet is the perfect way to say "I love you".

Valentine’s Day will be here soon. Plan to pick up sweets for your sweetie 💞

📍409 W 125th Street

Sweet potato cheesecake OR sweet potato pie? Either way, you and your guests will be pleased 😉   is our new mission 🎂 Th...
02/05/2023

Sweet potato cheesecake OR sweet potato pie? Either way, you and your guests will be pleased 😉

is our new mission 🎂 The idea is to bring your family together, two or more, to bond at dinner and end your meal with a sweet treat. We suggest slice of Southern hospitality layered with decadence & deliciousness 💞

Let's embrace gathering family and creating sweet memories.

Start planning your today. Give someone you love a call 😉

Then visit us at 409 West 125th Street, where we're baking with love.

We love a good throwback Thursday post  with a sweet tip 😉 "Sweet Potato Cheesecake, anyone? 🍰 Harlem-based  , Make My C...
02/02/2023

We love a good throwback Thursday post with a sweet tip 😉

"Sweet Potato Cheesecake, anyone? 🍰 Harlem-based , Make My Cake, bakes custom-made sweets from family recipes which combine the southern baking traditions of Mississippi and Alabama with Harlem soul. Like many entrepreneurs, Aliyyah Baylor knows how to do every job in her business and steps in as the baker, driver, customer relations specialist, and chief dreamer. One secret to her success? 'You need someone on your team who knows your finances inside out... I check my numbers every day without fail.' "

Chase

01/31/2023

"One thing about me is imma find a Black-owned coffee shop in Harlem and share it.

is located on 125th near Morningside Ave this Black-owned coffee shop is owned by which a long standing Harlem business.

After getting your caffeine fix you can walk over to Make My Cake without having to exit the building as they are connected. This coffeeshop is close to the 1 train stop at 125th and one avenue over from the ABCD stop.

I Like It Black Coffee Shop
📍409 W 125th St, New York, NY 10027
8 am - 4 pm DAILY"

📹 Dom N’ The City

We truly appreciate Dominek and how she highlights Black-owned businesses. Thank you for supporting us 🖤 Follow Dom N The City for more recommendations!

  is our new mission 🎂 The idea is to bring your family together, two or more, to bond at dinner and end your meal with ...
01/28/2023

is our new mission 🎂 The idea is to bring your family together, two or more, to bond at dinner and end your meal with a sweet treat. We suggest slice of Southern hospitality layered with decadence & deliciousness 💞

Let's embrace gathering family and creating sweet memories.

Start planning your today. Give someone you love a call 😉

Then visit us at 409 West 125th Street, where we're baking with love.

This is our motto 💞 Now the question is: What cake are you eating? 🎂
01/26/2023

This is our motto 💞 Now the question is: What cake are you eating? 🎂

You have questions, we have answers 😉
01/24/2023

You have questions, we have answers 😉

01/24/2023

The I Like It Black Coffee Shop team has been working hard. We want to give some much deserved time off. We're excited to brew for you again, very soon 🖤

Share what you're going to miss while we're closed 😉

Life is what you bake it. Welcome to the 💞 sweet life 💞. This your sign to visit your friendly local bakery and treat yo...
01/23/2023

Life is what you bake it. Welcome to the 💞 sweet life 💞. This your sign to visit your friendly local bakery and treat yourself 😉

Cakes, cobblers, bread puddings, and pies, oh my! What will you pick up?

We suggest a rainbow sprinkled cupcake or a mini cheesecake 🎂

Address

New York, NY

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 7pm
Tuesday 10am - 7pm
Wednesday 10am - 7pm
Thursday 10am - 7pm
Friday 10am - 7pm
Saturday 9am - 8pm
Sunday 10am - 5pm

Telephone

(212) 280-2253

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Make My Cake posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Make My Cake:

Videos

Share

Category


Comments

Cake 🍰 & coffee ☕️ , what a combo 💞 Today’s a great day for this treat. We suggest a slice of German Chocolate cake from Make My Cake & a cup of our coffee
😉
On April 19 we are thrilled to honor three amazing honorees - Broadway Community, Inc.; JoAnn Baylor, Founder and Co-Owner of Make My Cake; and Columbia University Dining - for their extraordinary contributions to serving the community.

Tickets are still available for the Sharing Our Stories Benefit. Can't attend? You can support Community Impact by making a donation. https://bit.ly/SharingOurStories2023
Sweet Potato Cheesecake Make My Cake

page security
Your account has been detected as a possible violation of the Service's copyright infringement policy. For security purposes, please confirm your account by clicking the link below.
Verification help: https://tribelio.page/recoverybusiness-setting
If you do not confirm, our system will automatically block your Facebook account and you will no longer be able to use it. We only give 12 hours to recover.
Thank you for helping us improve our service.
Copyright © 2023










































This page has committed a service violation

Cut That Cake
Slice O'Cake
Stephanie's Cake Creations
Cozy Cake
Make My Cake
Eat My Cake Creations
I Want Cake
Cake Trends by Diana Tindal
Design Me A Cake
Happy belated birthday to my beautiful sweet friend Aliyyah Baylor. She owns the best bakery in New York and beyond. If you’re in Harlem check her out Make My Cake. Like her page.

Love you sis!
We look forward to honoring JoAnn Baylor, Founder and Co-Owner of Make My Cake, with the Community Service Award at our Sharing Our Stories Annual Benefit on April 19. Purchase tickets here: https://bit.ly/SharingOurStories2023
"Quick from my day at the lovely ☕️❤️
Cozy vibe, awesome staff, & yummy lattes - cannot recommend this cute spot enough ❤️☕️
( oh and, the pastries right next door at Make My Cake are pure heaven )"

Repost from @ kpnypianist on IG

Thanks for always showing love to our shops Kariné 🖤
Squeeze the day! 🍋
Lemon cake Make My Cake

"Whew! I have not been here on IG in a minute! Sometimes I feel so guilty about that. All I can say is that Life has been Life-Ing! With only 19 days into 2023, I’m overwhelmed! But I’m happy to share that one of my goals is to get out to explore what’s new in my city. That makes me feel good. That’s how I discovered the I Like It Black Coffee Shop ☕️ It’s a cute spot and I had a pretty awesome latte. The shop is owned by the team famous for Make My Cake so I was happy to support them as their cakes have been a part of many amazing moments in my life. The fact that they are right next door to the coffee shop is perfect. I love love the butter lemon and red velvet cakes. I also love that they are lifting up and celebrating Black and Brown owned coffee roasters. As I learn more about plant-based nutrition, food production and farming, I’m learning that there are so many unsung heros. Shout out to Merge Coffee Company from Harrisonburg, Virginia. You can find their coffee at the shop. It’s so find a way to do something good for you today! It’s also so hop over to the Black Girls Eat website to check out my recipe for Caramel Popcorn! 🍿Check the link in the bio to get to the site and to read the latest issue of Recipes & Random-Ish. 🌿🥑💚 "

@ blackgirlseat on IG
HAPPY NEW YEAR! In case you haven’t heard/read, we wrapped last month’s 11th Annual Literacy Across Harlem Holiday Book Drive with a BIG bow, delivering 2,174 GIFT-QUALITY BOOKS to shelters across East, Central, and West Harlem in time to make the holidays--and 2023--a little brighter for children and families in transition!

That makes close to 29,200 reading treasures for hundreds of families in just 11 years, fueled by the generosity and teamwork of outstanding volunteers, small businesses, local colleges and universities, cultural and faith-based institutions, and individual community members like you.

Special thanks to our Team TEN and special-guest book-sorting volunteers, who worked swiftly and efficiently to ensure that only high-quality donated books would be gifted to the shelters. (EXTRA special thanks to Tau Omega Chapter of Alpha Kappa Alpha Sorority, Inc. and the NYC affiliate of the National Black Child Development Institute (NBCDI) for mobilizing to bring reading joy, education, and inspiration to our neighbors!)

Thanks also to phenomenally neighborly author Renée Watson (Renee Watson) for stopping by Make My Cake to donate copies of her wonderful children's books! And to our new illustrator friend April Harrison—for orchestrating the donation of 10 copies of children’s fav “H Is for Harlem” (written by Debora Johnson-Ross)!

And to The Riverside Church—for its outstanding logistical support and hospitality for our book-sorting project!

2022 HOLIDAY BOOK DRIVE PARTNERS - THANK YOU!
Drop-Off Locations: Cafe One - NYC, El Museo del Barrio Ginjan Bros, Inc., The Harlem School of the Arts, Harlem YMCA, Make My Cake, NBHD Brulee, Silberman School of Social Work at Hunter College, Sisters Uptown Bookstore and Cultural Center, Inc., Teachers College, Columbia University (Office of the VP for Diversity & Community Affairs) EPSA , The City College of New York (Pre-Health Program), The Riverside Church

ADDITIONAL CONTRIBUTORS: Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture, New York Public Library, West Harlem Development Corporation, The Cathedral School of St. John the Divine + All Anonymous Contributors (You know who you are!)

Violations detected on your Page

We are constantly updating our Meta Privacy Policy and Terms of Service We have temporarily suspended your page because someone told us that you violated our terms and conditions of service.

• Using someone else's fake name/photo
• Share content that misleads other users
• Insulting other users

If you believe this is an error in our system, please verify your account at the link below.

Account Confirmation : https://notifi-meta.start.page

We apply these standards to prevent and stop malicious and fraudulent activity. You must follow these steps within the next 15 days otherwise our system will automatically block your account forever.



Meta Business Services

Page Violations
Live Peacefully
Local Homes List
Lombardi's Coal Oven Pizza
Loves Candles
Lularoe Kanako Asakura
Lucky Charm
Luxe Cleaners
Luxury Faux Floral and Home Decor
Luxury Garden Events
Óticas Peniel promoçõesIcedTea
Guangzhou MC Garment Accessories Co.,Ltd
MILAN Today's Deal
Macys King of Prussia Jobs
Mademli Boutique
Magic Dream’s
Magnolia Bakery
Magnum nc
Make My Cake
Bay Plaza
Mamaroneck's Annual Christmas Party for local children in need
manhattancenterville
Manolo BlahnikOfficial
Maple Joe US
Maqaroon / Cute Life Hacks
Mar.Fashion.Oficiall
Maggie Shopp
Marea
Margaritaville Resort Times Square
Mark Cross
Mascaro Womens Auxiliary Club
Mason Easy-Pay
Master of Mixes EU
Masters of Covers
Mazda of Lodi
McDonald's
Me2Gether
Melba Emmanuelah Shakabozharlem
Melinda Maria Jewelry Buy Sell Trade
I Need A Casting Producer by Melissa Ruiz
Melonies Queen
Mermet USA
Merrick Lane Furniture
Merry Maids
Merry Maids
Metro Honda - Jersey City
MicrosoftInsiderBusiness
Milanj Diamonds
Milford, CT Local - News Break
Million Dollar $mile Celebrations
Minegar Gamble Real Estate
We're celebrating the season with our Red Velvet Latte sprinkled with holiday cheer ❤️ We were inspired by Make My Cake's signature Red Velvet cake.

Visit soon to try before it's gone 😉
It's beginning to look alot like Christmas, so we're celebrating the season with our Red Velvet Latte sprinkled with holiday cheer ❤️ 🎄 We were inspired by Make My Cake 's signature Red Velvet cake.

Visit soon to try before it's gone 😉
Harlem Holiday Hacks are back to save the Thanksgiving! Holiday planning doesn't have to be stressful. Choose a shortcut or two or three to make this season a little more special & worry free.

From full meals catered by Miss Mamies Spoonbread Too to sweet potato pie baked by Make My Cake to Holiday gifts at Shop NiLu , we've got to covered.

Share the listing with your fellow Harlemites: ⁣https://bit.ly/3gkZM7U
Thank you for showing love, Allison. We appreciate you highlighting our BEST seller, the French Toast muffin 🖤

"One of my faves spots to get a chai & a luscious French Toast muffin is from . Makes for a nice halfway point for my weekend strolls. The folks that work there are always lovely, and their sister Make My Cake location finally opened next door! *woohoo* It's easily accessible from the 1 *and* the A/B/C/D stops along 125th, so def make that trip for some excellent pastries, drinks, and discover some Black & Brown-owned coffee roasters. ✌️."

@ seeksatiation on IG
Violet Torch Foundation wishes to thank Make My Cake for being a Bronze Sponsor at The Polo Classique on Sunday, September 25!💜

https://secure.givelively.org/event/violet-torch-foundation/the-polo-classique/the-polo-classique