Make My Cake

Make My Cake Baking the sweetest memories! Visit us online at makemycake.com. New York, NY 10030

121A St. Nicholas Avenue
New York, NY 10026
(1083)

Make My Cake is a full-service retail and wholesale bakery specializing in scrumptious baked goods that boast both Southern flavor and Harlem inspiration. For the past 15 years, Make My Cake has offered their clientele heavenly desserts such as the homestyle butter cake, the New York Times’ pick, Red Velvet Cake, Food Network favorite, German Chocolate Cake, and local best-seller, Sweet Potato Cheesecake.

2380 Adam Clayton Powell Blvd.

Sweet Season of Goodness! Place your order today in time to pick up for holiday celebrations. www.makemycake.com 409 wes...
12/19/2025

Sweet Season of Goodness! Place your order today in time to pick up for holiday celebrations. www.makemycake.com
409 west 125th street off Morningside Ave
212-932-0833

All 10” Sweet Potato, Peach and Apple Pie $30 Today
11/28/2025

All 10” Sweet Potato, Peach and Apple Pie $30 Today

11/27/2025

OUR LOCATION 409 WEST 125TH STREET IS OPEN 9-4 TODAY!!
LOCATION AT 2380 ADAM CLAYTON POWELL JR BLVD
OPEN 10-2

Pretty and Pink ..We Are Located 409 west 125th street off Morningside Ave next to I Like It Black Coffeeshop!
11/26/2025

Pretty and Pink ..We Are Located 409 west 125th street off Morningside Ave next to I Like It Black Coffeeshop!

11/24/2025

Showcase is always sweet!

Classy and elegant
11/24/2025

Classy and elegant

How sweet retirement is?!
04/06/2025

How sweet retirement is?!

Good morning
12/13/2024

Good morning

https://gofund.me/1cc1c118 in
10/14/2024

https://gofund.me/1cc1c118 in

Over the years we have been resilient to sudden relocating to finally findin… aliyyah baylor needs your support for Save Harlem Beloved Bakery Make My Cake

https://gofund.me/1cc1c118
10/14/2024

https://gofund.me/1cc1c118

Over the years we have been resilient to sudden relocating to finally findin… aliyyah baylor needs your support for Save Harlem Beloved Bakery Make My Cake

Address

409 West 125th
New York, NY

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 7pm
Tuesday 10am - 7pm
Wednesday 10am - 7pm
Thursday 10am - 7pm
Friday 10am - 7pm
Saturday 9am - 8pm
Sunday 10am - 5pm

Telephone

(212) 280-2253

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Make My Cake posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Make My Cake:

Shortcuts

Share

Category