Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels

Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels Small, dense, and chewy bagels are made on-site daily with one goal: bringing bagels back to their original glory.

Everything you need on this rainy Friday is here! Don’t wanna go out? We deliver! Link in bio.
05/10/2024

Everything you need on this rainy Friday is here! Don’t wanna go out? We deliver! Link in bio.

A cold brew and a bacon egg and cheese - the perfect way to start the day!
05/08/2024

A cold brew and a bacon egg and cheese - the perfect way to start the day!

A little delight before work. Our delicious veggie cream cheese on a poppy bagel 🥯❤️
05/07/2024

A little delight before work. Our delicious veggie cream cheese on a poppy bagel 🥯❤️

Mondays are rough. Bagels make them better!
05/06/2024

Mondays are rough. Bagels make them better!

Happy St. Patty’s Day!
03/17/2024

Happy St. Patty’s Day!

It’s Always Jewish Christmas   … that’s not only a factual statement, but it’s also the name of this bagel sandoSichuan ...
03/13/2024

It’s Always Jewish Christmas … that’s not only a factual statement, but it’s also the name of this bagel sando
Sichuan peppercorn bagel made with single-plantation hua jiao (Sichuan peppercorns) from topped with chili crisp cream cheese, cucumber, and cilantro.
Ya know. Jews and Chinese food!

It’s a sausage, egg, and cheese kinda day!
03/12/2024

It’s a sausage, egg, and cheese kinda day!

True story… my Nana was from Hamburg, Germany. I have fond memories of her eating cervelat with butter on bread. This sa...
02/17/2024

True story… my Nana was from Hamburg, Germany. I have fond memories of her eating cervelat with butter on bread.
This sandwich is a tribute to her!
A pretzel bagel topped with butter, cervelat, and thinly-sliced red onions. So so so good!

I mean… just look at this Valentine’s abomination! A red bagel!  Stop in to celebrate Valentine’s Day with a Jersey pork...
02/14/2024

I mean… just look at this Valentine’s abomination! A red bagel! Stop in to celebrate Valentine’s Day with a Jersey pork roll, egg, and cheese!

Not a member of the tribe? It’s cool. You can still eat like one!The member of the tribe with tomatoes, onions, and cape...
02/13/2024

Not a member of the tribe? It’s cool. You can still eat like one!
The member of the tribe with tomatoes, onions, and capers.

Hey all. We will be closed today unfortunately. We’re working on getting it back on for tomorrow. Fingers crossed!
12/13/2023

Hey all. We will be closed today unfortunately. We’re working on getting it back on for tomorrow. Fingers crossed!

We will be closed today due to flood clean-up from flooding that occurred yesterday. We will reopen tomorrow. But, we wi...
08/26/2023

We will be closed today due to flood clean-up from flooding that occurred yesterday. We will reopen tomorrow. But, we will be closed next week from Monday through Labor Day to give our hard-working staff a well-deserved vacation. We will reopen on Tuesday after Labor Day.

When I was in 8th grade, this was my regular breakfast. A sesame bagel with cream cheese and bacon. In fact, I built it ...
07/29/2023

When I was in 8th grade, this was my regular breakfast. A sesame bagel with cream cheese and bacon. In fact, I built it up in my head, that I, Peter Shelsky, invented this sandwich. I was told recently that this glorious thing existed long before I ever “invented” it. So, maybe I “invented” it in the same way Columbus “discovered” America. Regardless, it’s still an insanely great breakfast sandwich. Especially when you enjoy a cup of next to it
Sesame bagel - cream cheese - bacon
Link to order in bio

Today is a great day for a chopped cheese!
07/25/2023

Today is a great day for a chopped cheese!

Friends… Shelsky’s Brooklyn Bagels will be closed from Monday, May 22nd through Sunday, May 29th. We will reopen on Mond...
05/19/2023

Friends… Shelsky’s Brooklyn Bagels will be closed from Monday, May 22nd through Sunday, May 29th. We will reopen on Monday, May 29th
We’re excited to announce that we’re getting a new fancy schmancy oven that will give us the ability to bake even better bagels super efficiently!
We appreciate your understanding.

Bialys are awesome… I grew up in a bialy household. We always had bialys and rarely had bagels. What’s good on a bagel, ...
05/16/2023

Bialys are awesome… I grew up in a bialy household. We always had bialys and rarely had bagels. What’s good on a bagel, is, IMHO, better on a bialy! Toast it dark, scallion cream cheese, nova (or belly lox if you dig the salty stuff!)… that’s just my jam!

We’re so excited to announce that we’re now carrying these awesome gluten free bagels from  For the gluten-free among us...
04/26/2023

We’re so excited to announce that we’re now carrying these awesome gluten free bagels from
For the gluten-free among us, these bagels beautifully mimic the taste, chewy mouthfeel, and crust that you’ve come to expect from

Tangy cream cheese, kinda oozy and messy because the hot, smoky bacon gently warms it up… foiled by a crusty, chewy, sou...
04/13/2023

Tangy cream cheese, kinda oozy and messy because the hot, smoky bacon gently warms it up… foiled by a crusty, chewy, sourdough bagel…
It’s the stuff that dreams are made of
Link to order is in bio

We will be closed today due to an oven issue. We will reopen tomorrow
04/11/2023

We will be closed today due to an oven issue. We will reopen tomorrow

Mondays suck. Reubens make them manageable.
03/27/2023

Mondays suck. Reubens make them manageable.

02/23/2023
Yeah, our bagels are the illest. But, have you had our Reuben? It’s the perfect freezing cold weekend to put yourself in...
02/03/2023

Yeah, our bagels are the illest. But, have you had our Reuben? It’s the perfect freezing cold weekend to put yourself in a food coma with one of these steaming beauties!

Bagels, baby…YEAH!
02/01/2023

Bagels, baby…YEAH!

After a day with the kiddos of waking, and walking, and walking, and more walking, and sweating, and sweating, and more ...
08/17/2022

After a day with the kiddos of waking, and walking, and walking, and more walking, and sweating, and sweating, and more sweating, we opted for simple. That pizza closest to the bottom of the photo is stuffed with porchetta. And I’m stuffed with it. Good thing we walked like 20k steps today in unrelenting heat.
Holy s**t that pizza was good.

Sunday is Father’s Day! Dad should eat what Dad wants!  And, Dad wants bagels! Not just any bagels, though.. 3-day, slow...
06/14/2022

Sunday is Father’s Day! Dad should eat what Dad wants! And, Dad wants bagels! Not just any bagels, though.. 3-day, slowly fermented, AWESOME bagels from
Order today! Links in bio

There’s a cure to   aka the Monday blues. And it’s a nap at your desk. Induce that nap by diving into Shelsky’s chopped ...
10/18/2021

There’s a cure to aka the Monday blues. And it’s a nap at your desk. Induce that nap by diving into Shelsky’s chopped cheese!
2 burger patties, seared hard with onion, chopped up with gooey American cheese, and pressed on a seeded hero with sliced tomato, fresh sliced onion, lettuce, ketchup, and mayo. Like I said, nap-inducing.
Not eating meat these days? Don’t fret. We’ve got an version as well that hits all the same notes and will definitely induce an equally therapeutic nap.
Thank you to for perfectly capturing all the oozy goodness of this masterpiece in this photo! Appreciate the love!
Order online for in-store pick up or local delivery. Link is in bio

We think it’s a great day to get a little messy with some runny yolk and maple syrup!Scrapple, egg, cheddar, and maple s...
10/16/2021

We think it’s a great day to get a little messy with some runny yolk and maple syrup!
Scrapple, egg, cheddar, and maple syrup!
Thank you for this glorious shot and shout out.

We fold explosively tingly Sichuan peppercorns from  into the dough of our Sichuan peppercorn bagels. Stop by and get on...
10/14/2021

We fold explosively tingly Sichuan peppercorns from into the dough of our Sichuan peppercorn bagels.
Stop by and get one of these unique bagels with chili crisp cream cheese, cilantro, and sliced cucumber. We call it the Jewish Christmas. It’s basically a party in your mouth!

Growing up, I ate way more bialys than bagels. My Grandma Yetta lived around the corner from  and it was a semi-weekly r...
10/12/2021

Growing up, I ate way more bialys than bagels. My Grandma Yetta lived around the corner from and it was a semi-weekly ritual. We’d buy a dozen or so fresh-out-of-the oven bialys and put ‘em in the trunk of my Dad’s burgundy 1978 Buick Electra Limited (it had burgundy velour seats). But that heart warming fragrance wafted into the car, and invariably, we’d pull over and eat a couple fresh and hot out of the bag. That’s a really fond memory.
Now, my Dad proudly eats Shelsky’s bialys… he’s biased, but he says they’re the best he’s ever had. And Seymour knows his bialys.

A chopped cheese (or an  chopped cheese) and a nap. This is the perfect Sunday! Stop on by. Order online. Link is in bio...
10/10/2021

A chopped cheese (or an chopped cheese) and a nap. This is the perfect Sunday! Stop on by. Order online.
Link is in bio.
>

Address

453 4th Avenue
New York, NY
11215

Opening Hours

Monday 6:30am - 7pm
Tuesday 6:30am - 7pm
Wednesday 6:30am - 7pm
Thursday 6:30am - 7pm
Friday 6:30am - 7pm
Saturday 7am - 4pm
Sunday 7am - 4pm

Telephone

+17188558817

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels:

Videos

Share

Category


Other Bagel Shops in New York

Show All