Perfectly Parnell Pastries

Website

Perfectly Parnell Pastries We’re a local bakery dedicated to creating unique, handcrafted pastries that bring people together.

Founded by Nick Parnell, a passionate baker, our treats are perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth and making any occasion special.

A Bittersweet AnnouncementAfter a lot of conversations, reflection, and more than a few emotions, we’ve made the difficu...
09/24/2026

A Bittersweet Announcement

After a lot of conversations, reflection, and more than a few emotions, we’ve made the difficult decision to close Perfectly Parnell Pastries.

What started as a love of baking became so much more than we ever expected. It became late nights in the kitchen, early mornings at markets, custom orders we were honored to be part of, new friendships, lessons learned, and so many memories our family will carry with us.

Most importantly, it became a community.

Every person who ordered a birthday cake, picked up a dozen cookies, stopped by our booth, shared one of our posts, recommended us to a friend, or simply cheered us on helped make this little business possible. We will never be able to adequately say thank you.

This decision isn’t because we stopped loving what we built. Quite the opposite. We’re incredibly proud of Perfectly Parnell Pastries.

But life has changed, our family has grown, and we’ve realized that this season of our lives needs something different from us. Right now, choosing our family and the time we have together is the right choice.

So, with incredibly grateful hearts, it’s time to hang up the apron.

Thank you for trusting us with your celebrations.
Thank you for letting us bake for your families.
Thank you for supporting ours.

And thank you for making Perfectly Parnell Pastries something worth being sad to say goodbye to.

From our family to yours, truly — thank you for everything.

— The Parnells

LAST CALL!Today is your final day to place a Perfectly Parnell preorder for this weekend.Cookies, cupcakes, cheesecake b...
09/09/2026

LAST CALL!

Today is your final day to place a Perfectly Parnell preorder for this weekend.

Cookies, cupcakes, cheesecake bites, cookie cakes — whatever you’ve had your eye on, now’s the time to claim it!

Orders close TODAY.

Pickup:
Saturday, 2–4 PM
Tony D’s

Order here:
https://forms.gle/JrBzEkT8UGR61gDr7

Don’t make Saturday-you wish Wednesday-you had ordered dessert.

Sometimes a regular cookie just isn’t enough.Enter: the cookie cake.Soft, chocolate-chippy, topped with chocolate frosti...
09/08/2026

Sometimes a regular cookie just isn’t enough.

Enter: the cookie cake.

Soft, chocolate-chippy, topped with chocolate frosting, and absolutely acceptable to eat without a special occasion.

Our chocolate chip cookie cake is available on this week’s preorder menu — but you only have until TOMORROW to order!

Orders close Wednesday.

Pickup:
Saturday, 2–4 PM
Tony D’s

Order yours here:
https://forms.gle/JrBzEkT8UGR61gDr7

Because “I wanted cookie cake” sounds like a perfectly good reason to us.

Okay, we have an important question…What are you picking first?Cookies? Cupcakes? Cheesecake bites? Or are you going str...
09/07/2026

Okay, we have an important question…

What are you picking first?

Cookies? Cupcakes? Cheesecake bites? Or are you going straight for the cookie cake?

This week’s Perfectly Parnell preorder is open, and we want to know which treat has your vote.

Tell us your pick in the comments — then make sure you actually claim yours!

Orders close Wednesday.

Pickup:
Saturday, 2–4 PM
Tony D’s

Order here:
https://forms.gle/JrBzEkT8UGR61gDr7

This week’s Perfectly Parnell preorder is OPEN!Need something sweet to look forward to this weekend? We’ve got you cover...
09/06/2026

This week’s Perfectly Parnell preorder is OPEN!

Need something sweet to look forward to this weekend? We’ve got you covered.

Choose your favorites from this week’s preorder menu, place your order ahead of time, and we’ll have everything freshly made and ready for you.

Orders close Wednesday!

Pickup:
Saturday, 2–4 PM
Tony D’s

Place your order here:
https://forms.gle/JrBzEkT8UGR61gDr7

Thank you for supporting Perfectly Parnell Pastries!

We want to hear from YOU!What would you love to see on a future Perfectly Parnell preorder menu?Maybe it’s a favorite co...
09/03/2026

We want to hear from YOU!

What would you love to see on a future Perfectly Parnell preorder menu?

Maybe it’s a favorite cookie flavor, a cupcake you’ve been craving, a cheesecake combination you’d love to try, brownies, or something completely different.

No wrong answers — we want to know what would make you stop scrolling and say, “Yep. I need that.”

Drop your dream dessert in the comments!

You might just see it on an upcoming preorder menu.

Last call for something sweet this weekend!Today is the LAST DAY to place your Perfectly Parnell preorder.Whether you’ve...
09/02/2026

Last call for something sweet this weekend!

Today is the LAST DAY to place your Perfectly Parnell preorder.

Whether you’ve been eyeing the cookies, cupcakes, cheesecake bites, or cookie cake, now’s the time to get your order in.

Orders close TODAY!

Pickup:
Saturday, 2–4 PM
Tony D’s

Place your order here:
https://forms.gle/9aQ1wiaaamVKhAyx8

A little cheesecake is always a good idea.Our cheesecake bites are the perfect size when you want something rich, creamy...
09/01/2026

A little cheesecake is always a good idea.

Our cheesecake bites are the perfect size when you want something rich, creamy, and just a little indulgent — although we won’t judge if you don’t stop at one.

Get 6 cheesecake bites for $15 on this week’s preorder menu.

Orders close Wednesday!

Pickup:
Saturday, 2–4 PM
Tony D’s

Place your order here:
https://forms.gle/9aQ1wiaaamVKhAyx8

This week’s preorder is officially OPEN!Need a little something sweet to look forward to? We’ve got you covered.This wee...
08/30/2026

This week’s preorder is officially OPEN!

Need a little something sweet to look forward to? We’ve got you covered.

This week’s Perfectly Parnell preorder is back with cookies, cupcakes, cheesecake bites and more — all made fresh and ready for pickup.

Orders close Wednesday, so get yours in while you can!

Place your order here:
https://forms.gle/9aQ1wiaaamVKhAyx8

LAST CALL!Perfectly Parnell Weekend Preorders close TONIGHT.If you’ve been meaning to order, now’s the time to make sure...
08/26/2026

LAST CALL!

Perfectly Parnell Weekend Preorders close TONIGHT.

If you’ve been meaning to order, now’s the time to make sure your Saturday treats are waiting for you.

This week’s menu:

Chocolate Chip Cookies — 12 for $9
Snickerdoodles — 12 for $9
Lemon Blueberry Cupcakes — 6 for $9
Cookies & Cream Cheesecake Bites — 6 for $15
Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake Bites — 6 for $15
Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake — $25

Orders close tonight!

Saturday Pickup: 2–4 PM
Tony D’s in New Palestine

Place your order here:
https://forms.gle/qTmEj3ttpchB2dWM6

Get your order in before it’s too late. We can’t wait to bake for you!

Address

New Palestine, IN

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Perfectly Parnell Pastries posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category