Clicky

Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop

Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop Small bakery in Loveland, Colorado Disclaimer: Some of our products are produced in a home kitchen under cottage food laws not subject to State licensure or inspection and that may also process common food allergens such as tree nuts, peanuts, eggs, soy, wheat and milk.

Our products are not intended for resale.

Payment Options:   Cash

Operating as usual

Sunday Funday!Today’s menu:Full size pies:AppleCherryLemon meringueSalted honeyChocolate chess (with pecans)ButtermilkCo...
04/03/2022

Sunday Funday!

Today’s menu:

Full size pies:
Apple
Cherry
Lemon meringue
Salted honey
Chocolate chess (with pecans)
Buttermilk
Coconut cream

5 inch pies:
Cherry
Blueberry
Chocolate chess
Buttermilk

German chocolate cupcakes
Fresh strawberry cupcakes

Cherry strudel

Brownies
Chocolate chip pecan cookies

Biscotti

Cake balls

And one 8 inch lemon blueberry cake

First new pie for Spring:  Salted Honey😁🥧🥰🍯🐝
04/02/2022

First new pie for Spring: Salted Honey😁🥧🥰🍯🐝

It’s the weekend!  What are your Saturday plans???  They should include pie!Available today:Pies - 9 inch and 5 inchChoc...
04/02/2022

It’s the weekend! What are your Saturday plans??? They should include pie!

Available today:
Pies - 9 inch and 5 inch
Chocolate chess
Buttermilk
Salted Honey
Apple
Cherry
Buttermilk
Lemon Meringue
Coconut cream

German chocolate cupcakes
Fresh strawberry cupcakes

Brownies, cookies

Cherry strudel

Don’t forget to place your Easter orders!

Happy Friday!!!Today’s Menu:Pies:AppleCherry BlueberryStrawberries & CreamCoconut creamLemon meringue (later this aftern...
04/01/2022

Happy Friday!!!

Today’s Menu:

Pies:
Apple
Cherry
Blueberry
Strawberries & Cream
Coconut cream
Lemon meringue

(later this afternoon)
Salted Honey
Chocolate chess

Cherry Strudel

German chocolate cupcakes

Cookies, brownies, cake balls, biscotti

And rolling out Easter sugar cookies this afternoon!

Company coming for Easter?  No time to cook?  Check out our brunch options!Easter brunch torte:  layers of spinach, red ...
03/30/2022

Company coming for Easter? No time to cook? Check out our brunch options!

Easter brunch torte: layers of spinach, red bell peppers, mushrooms, ham, eggs, and cheese in a flake pastry shell

Heirloom tomato tart: Herbed crust filled with heirloom tomatoes, fresh basil, mozzarella and farmer’s cheese

Scones, muffins, strudels and hot cross buns

Order on the website or DM with questions.

Lots of yummy Easter treats - get your orders in now!Featured for Easter:Layer cakes:24K Carrot cakeLemon-blueberry cake...
03/29/2022

Lots of yummy Easter treats - get your orders in now!

Featured for Easter:

Layer cakes:
24K Carrot cake
Lemon-blueberry cake
Strawberries & Cream layer cake

Lemon curd cheesecake
Strawberry cheesecake

Blueberry-lemon curd Strudel
Strawberry Strudel

Hot cross buns - traditional or dried cherry

Decorated sugar cookies, cake balls, chocolate bunnies and more!

Brunch features:
Easter brunch torte
Asparagus tart
Tomato tart
Roasted asparagus salad
Deviled eggs

DM with any questions 🐰🐣🌷

Happy Sunday!!!Today’s menu:Full size pies:CherryAppleLemon MeringueButtermilk5” pies:ButtermilkCherryLemon MeringueAppl...
03/27/2022

Happy Sunday!!!

Today’s menu:
Full size pies:
Cherry
Apple
Lemon Meringue
Buttermilk

5” pies:
Buttermilk
Cherry
Lemon Meringue
Apple
Blueberry

Cherry or blueberry strudel

Carrot cake cupcakes

Cookies, brownies and cake balls

Banana bread tea loaves

Come see us today!  We have From the Heart and Jade Penguin set up outside so come shop and freshen up your spring wardr...
03/27/2022

Come see us today! We have From the Heart and Jade Penguin set up outside so come shop and freshen up your spring wardrobe!

Inside are the usual goodies and I have some complimentary snacks, tea, coffee and mimosas, so come do a little shopping, have a snack and let me tell you about our tea parties!

300 person wedding cake this afternoon, I love how it turned out and love the sparkly tablecloth the bride chose!
03/26/2022

300 person wedding cake this afternoon, I love how it turned out and love the sparkly tablecloth the bride chose!

Don’t forget - tomorrow, Sunday, March 27th from 10:00-3:00 - come see all the new designs from some great local vendors...
03/26/2022

Don’t forget - tomorrow, Sunday, March 27th from 10:00-3:00 - come see all the new designs from some great local vendors and freshen up your Spring wardrobe while supporting local!!!

Happy Friday!!!!Today’s menu:Whole pies:Coconut creamLemon meringueAppleCherryButtermilkChocolate chessSalted honey5” pi...
03/25/2022

Happy Friday!!!!

Today’s menu:

Whole pies:
Coconut cream
Lemon meringue
Apple
Cherry
Buttermilk
Chocolate chess
Salted honey

5” pies:
Apple
Cherry
Buttermilk
Pecan
Lemon meringue
Coconut cream

Blueberry strudel

Oatmeal raisin cookies
Chocolate chip pecan cookies
Cake balls
Brownies

Any requests for the weekend??? It’s going to be beautiful weather so get out of the house and come get some pie!

Thursday menu:Whole pies:Apple cherryCoconut creamLemon meringue5 inch pies:BlueberryAppleCherryKey LimeBlueberry strude...
03/24/2022

Thursday menu:

Whole pies:
Apple cherry
Coconut cream
Lemon meringue

5 inch pies:
Blueberry
Apple
Cherry
Key Lime

Blueberry strudel

Oatmeal raisin cookies
Chocolate chip cookies
Brownies
Cake balls
Biscotti

Can you believe that Easter is just a few weeks away????  Featured Easter goodies are live on the website so get your or...
03/19/2022

Can you believe that Easter is just a few weeks away????

Featured Easter goodies are live on the website so get your orders in soon!

I have 22 of the Paint-your-own Easter egg sets available, not sure if I will be able to get more containers, so get them while they last!

Saturday’s menu:Whole pies:Lemon meringueChocolate custardCoconut creamAppleCherry5” piesPecanBlueberryCherryLemon merin...
03/19/2022

Saturday’s menu:

Whole pies:
Lemon meringue
Chocolate custard
Coconut cream
Apple
Cherry

5” pies
Pecan
Blueberry
Cherry
Lemon meringue

7” key lime

Cherry strudel

Cranberry-pistachio-white chocolate cookies

Milk chocolate brownies

Cake balls

Biscotti

Looks like a beautiful day (a beautiful day for pie!)

Happy Friday!!!Available today:Full size pies:AppleCherryBlueberryCoconut cream5” pies:CherryBlueberryPecan7” key lime p...
03/18/2022

Happy Friday!!!

Available today:
Full size pies:
Apple
Cherry
Blueberry
Coconut cream

5” pies:
Cherry
Blueberry
Pecan

7” key lime pie

Cranberry-pistachio- white chocolate chip cookies

Brownies

Cake balls

Biscotti

Come see me!

HAPPY PI DAY!!!!!I am usually closed on Mondays, but in honor of Pi Day I will be open 10:00-4:00 today!  If you are in ...
03/14/2022

HAPPY PI DAY!!!!!

I am usually closed on Mondays, but in honor of Pi Day I will be open 10:00-4:00 today!

If you are in Fort Collins, I will be Maxline Brewing tonight 5:30-7:30!

PI Day - Monday - 3.14!!!!Whole pies - 5 inch pies - and mini pies - oh my!
03/13/2022

PI Day - Monday - 3.14!!!!

Whole pies - 5 inch pies - and mini pies - oh my!

Just a little reminder…  Tomorrow is PI Day!  I will be open 10:00-4:00 for this very special day!  I will have full siz...
03/13/2022

Just a little reminder… Tomorrow is PI Day! I will be open 10:00-4:00 for this very special day! I will have full size, 5” and mini pies available -(orders appreciated - you know - so you get the flavor you want!)

Good morning!  How’s everyone adjusting to the time change?  Today I have:Whole pies:CherryAppleLemon meringueChocolate ...
03/13/2022

Good morning! How’s everyone adjusting to the time change?

Today I have:

Whole pies:
Cherry
Apple
Lemon meringue
Chocolate chess
Buttermilk

5” pies:
Lemon meringue X2

Blueberry strudel

Cookies
Brownies
Cake balls
Biscotti

Cake pictured is my 24K Carrot cake for a special order - did you know I make over 40 flavors of cake????

Saturday’s menu:Pies: Full SizeLemon meringueAppleCherryPecanPies-5 inchLemon meringueCherryBlueberry(pecan and caramel ...
03/12/2022

Saturday’s menu:

Pies: Full Size
Lemon meringue
Apple
Cherry
Pecan

Pies-5 inch
Lemon meringue
Cherry
Blueberry
(pecan and caramel apple available later this afternoon)

Cherry strudel

Creme brûlée cupcakes

Banana bread
Pumpkin cream bread

Cookies and brownies

Cake balls

Biscotti

Decorated sugar cookies for St. Patrick’s Day - come and get ‘em!
03/12/2022

Decorated sugar cookies for St. Patrick’s Day - come and get ‘em!

Spookley Pumpkin smash cake to kick off the weekend😁🎃
03/12/2022

Spookley Pumpkin smash cake to kick off the weekend😁🎃

Happy Friday!!!Today’s menu:Pies:AppleCherryCaramel applePecanLemon meringueCoconut creamStrudel:CherryCookies and brown...
03/11/2022

Happy Friday!!!

Today’s menu:

Pies:
Apple
Cherry
Caramel apple
Pecan
Lemon meringue
Coconut cream

Strudel:
Cherry

Cookies and brownies
Biscotti
Cake balls

Monday is 3.14 Pi Day!!!! Get your orders in now! If you would like a smaller pie, I will do 5” or a six pack of 3” by request - I will be open Monday for pickups. Shoot me a message or text - I don’t always see it if you just comment

Wedding season has begun!  Just delivered this cake and cupcake set and love the cupcake stands the bride found!
03/10/2022

Wedding season has begun! Just delivered this cake and cupcake set and love the cupcake stands the bride found!

Wednesday’s menu:Pies:PecanLemon meringueCherryCaramel appleAppleBlueberryStrudel:CherryChocolate chip pecan cookiesCara...
03/09/2022

Wednesday’s menu:

Pies:
Pecan
Lemon meringue
Cherry
Caramel apple
Apple
Blueberry

Strudel:
Cherry

Chocolate chip pecan cookies
Caramel toffee pecan cookies
Chocolate espresso cookies
Brownies

Cake balls

Biscotti

What a delicious day!  And it is coming up soon!  Get your pie orders in now for pickup Sunday or Monday and celebrate I...
03/08/2022

What a delicious day! And it is coming up soon! Get your pie orders in now for pickup Sunday or Monday and celebrate International PI Day!!!

Chocolate-Salted-Caramel cake for a customer today - chocolate fudge cake layers with cocoa buttercream and homemade sal...
03/05/2022

Chocolate-Salted-Caramel cake for a customer today - chocolate fudge cake layers with cocoa buttercream and homemade salted caramel (I have jarred up the rest of the batch of caramel if anyone needs a yummy ice cream topping today!)

I’ll just leave this right here….

It’s the weekend!!!  Happy Saturday!Today’s menu:Pies:Caramel appleLemon blueberryCherryBlueberryPecanChocolate chip pec...
03/05/2022

It’s the weekend!!! Happy Saturday!

Today’s menu:

Pies:
Caramel apple
Lemon blueberry
Cherry
Blueberry
Pecan

Chocolate chip pecan cookies
Brownies

Biscotti is restocked!
Pecan pie biscotti
Pumpkin
Cherry almond
Cranberry pistachio

Any special requests?

Back by popular demand!  I have 1 lemon-blueberry ready to go…who wants it?
03/04/2022

Back by popular demand! I have 1 lemon-blueberry ready to go…who wants it?

Happy Friday!  Today I have:Pies:AppleCherryCaramel appleBlueberryPecanLemon meringueCoconut creamStrudel:AppleCherryCoo...
03/04/2022

Happy Friday!

Today I have:

Pies:
Apple
Cherry
Caramel apple
Blueberry
Pecan
Lemon meringue
Coconut cream

Strudel:
Apple
Cherry

Cookies
Brownies
Biscotti

And 1 Guinness Beef Pot pie

Thursday’s menu:Pies:CherryApplePecanLemon meringueChicken pot pieGuinness beef pot pieStrudel:AppleBlueberryChocolate c...
03/03/2022

Thursday’s menu:

Pies:
Cherry
Apple
Pecan
Lemon meringue

Chicken pot pie
Guinness beef pot pie

Strudel:
Apple
Blueberry

Chocolate chip pecan cookies
Brownies
Cake balls
Biscotti
Blood orange bars

Lemon-blueberry pie - I have 1 up for grabs😁😁😁SOLD!
03/02/2022

Lemon-blueberry pie - I have 1 up for grabs😁😁😁

SOLD!

Another cold snap coming this weekend!  Get your pot pie orders in now for pickup this weekend!!!Today’s menu:Pies:Cherr...
03/02/2022

Another cold snap coming this weekend! Get your pot pie orders in now for pickup this weekend!!!

Today’s menu:
Pies:
Cherry
Apple
Pecan
Buttermilk custard

Strudel:
Blueberry

Chocolate chip pecan cookies

Brownies

Lemon bars

Cake balls

Cocoa bombs

St. Patrick’s Day menu - available from now until March 17th.  Decorated sugar cookies (of course)Cake ball 4 pack - Cho...
03/02/2022

St. Patrick’s Day menu - available from now until March 17th.

Decorated sugar cookies (of course)

Cake ball 4 pack - Chocolate stout, Irish cream, Chocolate Irish whiskey, chocolate mint

Guinness beer bread

Irish car bomb cupcakes - chocolate Guinness cupcake filled with Jameson whiskey ganache and topped with Bailey’s Irish Cream buttercream

Pies:
Irish Apple Amber
Grasshopper
Irish whiskey brownie pie
Irish cream pie

Guinness beef pot pies
Shepherds pie

Guinness savory bread pudding

Order on the website or DM me😁

Address

Loveland, CO
80537

Opening Hours

Wednesday 10am - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 6pm
Saturday 10am - 6pm
Sunday 10am - 6pm

Telephone

+17202296494

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop:

Category

Nearby bakeries


Other Bakeries in Loveland

Show All