Clicky

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Nostalgic Southern dessert shop specializing in handmade small and large pies. We are a down home pie shop with scratch made small and regular sized pies, ice cream, biscuits and such.

We believe in using just a few natural ingredients and a little southern know how to create desserts that would make grandma proud!

Operating as usual

We are all about the pie puns! What's the best one you can think of? ❤️
05/09/2022

We are all about the pie puns! What's the best one you can think of? ❤️

Happy Mother’s Day to everyone, including our wonderful owner- Lee! She is not just a boss, but also a second momma to u...
05/08/2022

Happy Mother’s Day to everyone, including our wonderful owner- Lee! She is not just a boss, but also a second momma to us all 🤍 We hope you’ve enjoyed today and spent it with family and friends!
See y’all in shop this week.

05/07/2022

Your mom called, and she wants a pie! BUT WE’RE ONLY OPEN FOR 2 MORE HOURS 😱

Run down to Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop to get your mom the best gift ever before it’s too late!

📍3135 People’s Street, Suite 300, Johnson City, TN
📞 423-491-8163

05/07/2022

Pie isn’t your thing? We’ve got cookies too 🍪
+ shortbread thumbprint cookies
+ chocolate shortbread thumbprint cookies
+ NEW cloud cookies
with vanilla, chocolate and strawberry icing to choose from!

We’re open until 4pm!!

📍3135 People’s Street Suite 300, Johnson City, TN
📞 423-491-8163

Pie isn’t your thing? We’ve got cookies too 🍪 + shortbread thumbprint cookies+ chocolate shortbread thumbprint cookies+ ...
05/07/2022

Pie isn’t your thing? We’ve got cookies too 🍪
+ shortbread thumbprint cookies
+ chocolate shortbread thumbprint cookies
+ NEW cloud cookies
with vanilla, chocolate and strawberry icing to choose from!

We’re open until 4pm!!

📍3135 People’s Street Suite 300, Johnson City, TN
📞 423-491-8163

FRESH PIES UNTIL 4PM! We’re open 10-4 with fresh pies for Mother’s Day weekend. Pick mom up a coconut cream, key lime or...
05/07/2022

FRESH PIES UNTIL 4PM! We’re open 10-4 with fresh pies for Mother’s Day weekend. Pick mom up a coconut cream, key lime or strawberry pie to make her feel loved 🤍

Mother’s Day is almost here! Don’t forget to order your pie - We are open until 7pm today and until 4pm tomorrow!! p.s. ...
05/06/2022

Mother’s Day is almost here! Don’t forget to order your pie - We are open until 7pm today and until 4pm tomorrow!! p.s. we have really cute mother’s day cards too 😉

📞423-491-8163
📍3135 People’s Street, Suite 300 Johnson City, TN

Mother's Day is right around the corner. Celebrate with some of her favorite sweet treats. We recommend the I40, an appl...
05/06/2022

Mother's Day is right around the corner. Celebrate with some of her favorite sweet treats. We recommend the I40, an apple pie and our seasonal strawberry. And if you're lucky, maybe she'll share.

05/06/2022

Still struggling to find the perfect Mother's Day gift? Or, are you attending ETSU graduation and want to celebrate a grad? Look no further than Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop. We recommend the blackberry custard pie so that you can support BK!

There is only one more day left in teacher appreciation week, and we have the perfect gifts for the occasion! Choose fro...
05/05/2022

There is only one more day left in teacher appreciation week, and we have the perfect gifts for the occasion! Choose from 4” and 9” pie flavors, our thumbprint cookies, or our NEW cloud cookies! 🍎🥧🍪

Because who doesn’t want a sweet treat as a gift?

Stop in or call to order!
📍 3135 People’s Street Suite 300, Johnson City, TN
📞423-491-8163

Pour some sugar on me... What better way to get over the hump?*serving suggestion
05/04/2022

Pour some sugar on me... What better way to get over the hump?
*serving suggestion

Now Accepting Pre-Orders for this weekend! Mother’s Day and Graduation are the perfect reason to celebrate with pie 😍 Ch...
05/02/2022

Now Accepting Pre-Orders for this weekend! Mother’s Day and Graduation are the perfect reason to celebrate with pie 😍 Choose from our delicious selection of daily flavors OR our seasonal strawberry pie 🍓

Call now or visit our website to place your order. Pickup is available until 4pm on Saturday May 7th!


#sharepiesharelove #SharePieShareLove #mothersdayspecial #mothersdaydessert #graduation2022 #graduationday #shopsmallbusinesses #shoplocalbusiness #madefromscratch #madefromscratchwithlove

A year of pie...oh my! One of our favorite ways to celebrate the ones we love is through the gift of pie! This card is r...
04/29/2022

A year of pie...oh my!

One of our favorite ways to celebrate the ones we love is through the gift of pie!

This card is redeemable for (1) 9" or 4" pie for each month of the year. Perfect gift for the pie-lover in your life! Shop online or visit the pie shop near you.

Trending! Looking for ways to make your wedding unique? Try offering your guests a pie bar with all your Buttermilk Sky ...
04/27/2022

Trending! Looking for ways to make your wedding unique? Try offering your guests a pie bar with all your Buttermilk Sky Pie favorites. Let them eat pie! (Isn't that how the saying goes?!).

Photo: @chasingluxphoto

H A P P Y  T U E S D A Y!! Tomorrow is National tell your story day, in honor of our story we’re running a deal for you!...
04/26/2022

H A P P Y T U E S D A Y!! Tomorrow is National tell your story day, in honor of our story we’re running a deal for you! Buy any two pies and get one I-40, Pecan, Chewy Chocolate Chip or Granny’s Apple pie FREE! While you’re in store, be sure to check out our story wall or ask one of our employees!

This deal runs through Wednesday, April 27th!

📍3135 People’s Street, Suite 300, Johnson City, TN

Photos from Good Samaritan Ministries - Johnson City, TN's post
04/25/2022

Photos from Good Samaritan Ministries - Johnson City, TN's post

Send to the first person you thought of... :)
04/25/2022

Send to the first person you thought of... :)

Pie Fans!!! From 4:00 - 7:00 today, come in and buy 2 4” pies and get one FREE while supplies last. 🥧🎉❤️ Run don’t walk ...
04/23/2022

Pie Fans!!! From 4:00 - 7:00 today, come in and buy 2 4” pies and get one FREE while supplies last. 🥧🎉❤️
Run don’t walk to 3135 Peoples Street!!

This Southern favorite is only available for a few more days. Calling all Lemon Ice Box fans... grab them while you stil...
04/22/2022

This Southern favorite is only available for a few more days. Calling all Lemon Ice Box fans... grab them while you still can.

Need something to do this weekend??  Hillbilly Days in Pikeville KY is the place to be!! The festival is through Sat 10:...
04/21/2022

Need something to do this weekend?? Hillbilly Days in Pikeville KY is the place to be!! The festival is through Sat 10:00AM- 8:00PM. We are located in the parking garage.

If you were wondering, you never need a reason to celebrate with a warm slice of pie. The pie is reason enough. Drop a ❤...
04/20/2022

If you were wondering, you never need a reason to celebrate with a warm slice of pie. The pie is reason enough. Drop a ❤️ if you agree.

The perfect party companion! Our Swizzle Sticks are sweet as pie.
04/18/2022

The perfect party companion! Our Swizzle Sticks are sweet as pie.

Have you picked up your Easter dessert for tomorrow?? Lemon Icebox is always a good choice!  We are open until 7 PM.  42...
04/16/2022

Have you picked up your Easter dessert for tomorrow?? Lemon Icebox is always a good choice! We are open until 7 PM.

423-491-8163

It’s Easter Weekend! This is your last chance to come out for your Thumbprint cookies and Pies. We are here from 10-7 to...
04/16/2022

It’s Easter Weekend! This is your last chance to come out for your Thumbprint cookies and Pies. We are here from 10-7 today April 16th. Give us a call at 423-491-8163 to reserve some Thumbprints for your Easter Egg Hunts! 🐰🌼

Tag someone who would love this to be in their Easter basket.We have gift certificates available... in case you can't fi...
04/15/2022

Tag someone who would love this to be in their Easter basket.

We have gift certificates available... in case you can't fit the whole pie in the basket ;) Swing by one of our locations to grab one or a variety of other Easter basket fillers.

We are celebrating Autism Awareness Month at our shop- this topic is very near and dear to our hearts❤️.  Did you know t...
04/14/2022

We are celebrating Autism Awareness Month at our shop- this topic is very near and dear to our hearts❤️. Did you know that 1 in 44 kids is diagnosed with autism??

We are spreading awareness with our Spiced Apple Custard aka Appalachian Apple Butter Pie. Be sure to add one on to your Easter order and help us spread the word!

423-491-8163
#autism
#sharepiesharelove

Easter is this weekend! Be sure to scoop up your favorite festive sweets before Sunday.
04/13/2022

Easter is this weekend! Be sure to scoop up your favorite festive sweets before Sunday.

Certain foods and smells bring memories rushing back to us, reminding our hearts and souls of precious moments with the ...
04/11/2022

Certain foods and smells bring memories rushing back to us, reminding our hearts and souls of precious moments with the ones we love the most. So, it's time to vote:
What fruit pie wins? Raspberry, Blueberry or Apple?

Easter is right around the corner. Want to add one of our pies or cookies to your Easter dinner? You can order now and s...
04/08/2022

Easter is right around the corner. Want to add one of our pies or cookies to your Easter dinner? You can order now and schedule a pick-up closer to the date so you're sure to have what you want, when you want it.

Did you know we also carry a variety of jams and butters? What goes better with a warm buttery biscuit than a sweet blac...
04/04/2022

Did you know we also carry a variety of jams and butters? What goes better with a warm buttery biscuit than a sweet blackberry jam? Or start your day by stirring our apple butter into a bowl of oatmeal. Available in our shops or online. Click the link to shop--> https://www.buttermilkskypie.com/order/

Address

3135 People's Street, Suite 300
Johnson City, TN
37064

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 7pm
Tuesday 10am - 7pm
Wednesday 10am - 7pm
Thursday 10am - 7pm
Friday 10am - 7pm
Saturday 10am - 7pm

Telephone

(423) 491-8163

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop:

Videos

Category

Our Story

We are a down home pie shop with scratch made small and regular sized pies, ice cream and thumbprint cookies. We believe in using just a few natural ingredients and a little southern know how to create desserts that would make grandma proud!

Nearby bakeries


Other Bakeries in Johnson City

Show All

Comments

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop has a cool mug…curious who’s coffee they’re serving. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
Please join us in support of Noah and the local (& delicious!) Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop! Thank you for dedicating your Pie it Forward Campaign to Childhood Cancer Awareness Month. We are so grateful for you help bringing attention to this cause. #childhoodcancer #WhereHopeRises
We are so happy and GRATEFUL to our sweet patient, Lance R., for bringing our entire team "sweet treats" from Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop. We feel so blessed to have such thoughtful patients! We love the individual serving sizes. 🙂 🎉#SophisticatedSmiles #JohnsonCityTN
Best of luck to our volunteer, Julia Gilmore. She is the 2021 Miss Teen Tennessee International competing this weekend for Miss Teen International. Julia brought some sweet treats today from Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop for our families to enjoy.
We are teaming up with Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop to do an awesome giveaway for Father’s Day! Jump over to their page and comment on the post to enter!
My son & I came in today for his birthday. He had an original buttermilk & I got a strawberry....which was sooo good!!!! I wish you still had banana one, maybe it will come back soon!! I wish I knew about free pie for birthday...he would have had 2 🤣
#PieItForward this April with Buttermilk Sky Pie Shops! Enjoy special flavors and support great local organizations. 🥧 Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Banana Cream sales are benefitting the Nave Autism Center at East Tennessee State University 🥧 Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Blackberry Custard sales are benefitting Reel Life International 🥧 Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop & Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Banana Cream sales are benefitting Tennessee Coalition to End Domestic and Sexual Violence 🥧 Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Lemon Meringue sales are benefitting The Logos Theatre 🥧 Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Chocolate Meringue sales are benefitting Poetry Community Christian School and the Senior Mission Team
Our Buttermilk Sky Pie contest winner is @srgarber!!! You can pick up your pies at our Spring Market April 23-25! Thanks to Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop for partnering with us and to all those who participated! This giveaway was certainly popular....we love our pies in the Model City! Be watching our social pages for a new giveaway next week! • • • • #antiques #antiquemarket #antiqueshow #artsandcrafts #fleamarket #fleamarketfind #kingsport #kingsporttn #kingsportantiques #kingsportantiqueshow #kingsportantiquemarket #kingsportvendorshow #kingsportvendormarket #kingsportfleamarket #mcantiqueandflea #smallbusinesslove #smallbusinessowners #smallbusinesssupport #tricitiesantiques #tricitiesantiqueshow #tricitiesantiquemarket #vendorevent #vendorshow #vendorswanted #vintage #vintageevents #vintagemarketplace
The I-40 Pie--So so Good!
https://www.32auctions.com/organizations/68834/auctions/86718/auction_items/2393664 Thank you, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop, for donating a pie a month for a year (!) to Kari's Heart Foundation's "Karing Through Covid" online auction! We appreciate you!
🌟GIVEAWAY TIME! 🌟 We are extra THANKFUL for your loyalty in the midst of these times so we are doing a giveaway for TWO lucky winners! ✅FREE Oil change at our shop ✅ TWO four inch pies of your choice from Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop RULES: 1.) In order to enter the giveaway you must make sure you have liked our page. 2.) Like this post. 3.) Share this post. 4.) Comment when done! ❤️🎉Winners will be announced November 24th! 🎉❤️ #HtekAuto #JohnsonCity #GrayAutoRepair #SupportLocalBusinesses #AutoCare #SettingTheStandardInExellence #FallSeason #HappyFall #ThanksgivingEdition #Giveaway #ButtermilkSkyPies #Thankful
Wish I could make pie crusts as quick as I saw you in that video ..wow.