Clicky

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Nostalgic Southern dessert shop specializing in handmade small and large pies. We are a down home pie shop with scratch made small and regular sized pies, ice cream, biscuits and such.

We believe in using just a few natural ingredients and a little southern know how to create desserts that would make grandma proud!

Operating as usual

Calling all pie people!! It’s the last stretch to get your 9” pies for thanksgiving! We’re only open until 7:00 and have...
11/23/2022

Calling all pie people!! It’s the last stretch to get your 9” pies for thanksgiving! We’re only open until 7:00 and have plenty of 9” available!

A toast to family traditions. Thanks for making us a part of yours!
11/23/2022

A toast to family traditions. Thanks for making us a part of yours!

A toast to family traditions. Thanks for making us a part of yours!
11/23/2022

A toast to family traditions. Thanks for making us a part of yours!

11/23/2022

LAST DAY TO GET YOUR THANKSGIVING PIES! Remember only a limited menu of 9” pies are available. we can’t wait to serve you!

Not all heroes wear capes…some of us wear oven mitts 🥧
11/22/2022

Not all heroes wear capes…some of us wear oven mitts 🥧

11/22/2022

Happy Thanksgiving Week! We are doing our best to make sure that if you come in this week and didn’t preorder pies, that there will be 9” pies available for you to purchase. We are experiencing an extremely high call volume, so please refrain from calling unless you absolutely need to! We are keeping as many flavors as possible available in 9” pies, but will drop to a limited menu as the day progresses (no 4” pies will be available for walk-ins). Thank you to everyone who placed preorders and who continues to support us through walk-ins! We’re open 10:00-7:00 today and tomorrow and look forward to serving you!

🎃 LAST CALL FOR SPICED PUMPKIN 🎃Get your Spiced Pumpkin fix this week before it's gone! The final day to enjoy this seas...
11/21/2022

🎃 LAST CALL FOR SPICED PUMPKIN 🎃

Get your Spiced Pumpkin fix this week before it's gone! The final day to enjoy this seasonal favorite (until 2023, of course) is November 26th. The season of Spiced Pumpkin may be coming to an end, but that means the season of Candy Canes has only just begun. Stay tuned.

🎃 LAST CALL FOR SPICED PUMPKIN 🎃Get your Spiced Pumpkin fix this week before it's gone! The final day to enjoy this seas...
11/21/2022

🎃 LAST CALL FOR SPICED PUMPKIN 🎃

Get your Spiced Pumpkin fix this week before it's gone! The final day to enjoy this seasonal favorite (until 2023, of course) is November 26th. The season of Spiced Pumpkin may be coming to an end, but that means the season of Candy Canes has only just begun. Stay tuned.

11/20/2022

PLACE THOSE PREORDERS!! Only 2 hours left to order your 9” pies for thanksgiving…you can order online using the link in our bio!

Congratulations to Allison Rogers for winning free pie!! Thank you for placing your Thanksgiving order before November 1...
11/19/2022

Congratulations to Allison Rogers for winning free pie!! Thank you for placing your Thanksgiving order before November 15th 🎉🎉 and participating in our giveaway!!

You’ve asked and we’re answering! As a thank you for your continued support we’ve decided to extend the deadline to orde...
11/19/2022

You’ve asked and we’re answering! As a thank you for your continued support we’ve decided to extend the deadline to order Thanksgiving pies until 5:00pm on Sunday, November 20th!

You can order by calling us at 423-491-8163 or by going online! We will have walk-in pies available next week but on a limited menu and only while supplies last.

Hoping to bring a Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Pie to Thanksgiving next week? Well you’ve got until the end of today to place...
11/18/2022

Hoping to bring a Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Pie to Thanksgiving next week? Well you’ve got until the end of today to place your order! Call us now or go online using the link in our bio.

Reminder: Walk-in pies will be available on a limited menu and only in 9” sizing!

Pro tip: Never show up empty handed. 📦Hostess gifts are one area of gifting where it truly is the thought that counts. B...
11/18/2022

Pro tip: Never show up empty handed. 📦

Hostess gifts are one area of gifting where it truly is the thought that counts. Bring a taste of southern tradition to your next event this holiday season.

Pro tip: Never show up empty handed. 📦Hostess gifts are one area of gifting where it truly is the thought that counts. B...
11/18/2022

Pro tip: Never show up empty handed. 📦

Hostess gifts are one area of gifting where it truly is the thought that counts. Bring a taste of southern tradition to your next event this holiday season.

2 DAYS LEFT TO PREORDER!! You don’t want to miss out on preordering this Thanksgiving! Phone orders shut off tomorrow at...
11/17/2022

2 DAYS LEFT TO PREORDER!! You don’t want to miss out on preordering this Thanksgiving! Phone orders shut off tomorrow at 7:00pm, and online orders shut off at 11:59pm.

What’s the benefit?
1. You have full selection of our menu, and can order any size pie! Once Preorders close, it’s walk-ins only with a limited 9” menu.
2. It ensures we have the flavor and quantity of pies you want!
3. You don’t have to wait in a long line of walk-ins, preorders move much more quickly during the holiday season!
4. It helps us to be more prepared, and takes stress off of our team!

Call us today or go online to place your order!
☎️423-491-8163

IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT ‼️‼️This week is your last chance to get an apple pie for Thanksgiving! Due to a high volume of a...
11/16/2022

IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT ‼️‼️

This week is your last chance to get an apple pie for Thanksgiving! Due to a high volume of apple pie orders we will NOT be able to offer apple pies for walk-in.

You’re able to order this pie until Friday, November 18th! Call us or go online to place your order.

☎️(423)491-8163


Go back to the basics this Thanksgiving.  Our Nanny's pecan pie is the one that put us on the map and speaks to traditio...
11/16/2022

Go back to the basics this Thanksgiving. Our Nanny's pecan pie is the one that put us on the map and speaks to tradition.

Share pie & share love this holiday season.

Go back to the basics this Thanksgiving.  Our Nanny's pecan pie is the one that put us on the map and speaks to traditio...
11/16/2022

Go back to the basics this Thanksgiving. Our Nanny's pecan pie is the one that put us on the map and speaks to tradition.

Share pie & share love this holiday season.

Today is the FINAL day to order your Thanksgiving pies and get entered to win FREE PIE!! 🥧 The winner will be announced ...
11/15/2022

Today is the FINAL day to order your Thanksgiving pies and get entered to win FREE PIE!! 🥧 The winner will be announced tomorrow, don’t you want that to be you???

Call us or go online to place your order!
☎️423-491-8163

We are thankful to be a part of your family traditions.
11/14/2022

We are thankful to be a part of your family traditions.

We are thankful to be a part of your family traditions.
11/14/2022

We are thankful to be a part of your family traditions.

5 DAYS LEFT TO PREORDER!! You don’t want to miss out on preordering this Thanksgiving! What’s the benefit? 1. You have f...
11/14/2022

5 DAYS LEFT TO PREORDER!! You don’t want to miss out on preordering this Thanksgiving!

What’s the benefit?
1. You have full selection of our menu, and can order any size pie! Once Preorders close, it’s walk-ins only with a limited 9” menu.
2. It ensures we have the flavor and quantity of pies you want!
3. You don’t have to wait in a long line of walk-ins, preorders move much more quickly during the holiday season!
4. It helps us to be more prepared, and takes stress off of our team!

Call us today or go online to place your order!
☎️423-491-8163

Our chocolate cream pie is a menu favorite. Have you tried it yet?
11/13/2022

Our chocolate cream pie is a menu favorite. Have you tried it yet?

Have I mentioned that everything in our shop is made from scratch? Making and pressing enough dough for the holidays tak...
11/12/2022

Have I mentioned that everything in our shop is made from scratch? Making and pressing enough dough for the holidays takes a lot of time, but we enjoy every minute of it (well almost every minute haha)

But we take pride in knowing that we’re giving you the freshest pies from the best ingredients!! Be sure to visit us in store this weekend to see the baking happen, we’re open 10:00-7:00!

We only have pies for you. 👀 Check out this perfect mini pie spread photo from ! 🍏 Granny's Apple Pie🎃 Spiced Pumpkin🍫 C...
11/11/2022

We only have pies for you. 👀 Check out this perfect mini pie spread photo from !

🍏 Granny's Apple Pie
🎃 Spiced Pumpkin
🍫 Chewy Chocolate Chip
🥜 Nanny's Pecan

We only have pies for you. 👀 Check out this perfect mini pie spread photo from Instagram user ! 🍏 Granny's Apple Pie🎃 Sp...
11/11/2022

We only have pies for you. 👀 Check out this perfect mini pie spread photo from Instagram user !

🍏 Granny's Apple Pie
🎃 Spiced Pumpkin
🍫 Chewy Chocolate Chip
🥜 Nanny's Pecan

It’s not too late to order client gifts! We’ve got easy, hassle free options like these vouchers as well as Buttermilk b...
11/11/2022

It’s not too late to order client gifts! We’ve got easy, hassle free options like these vouchers as well as Buttermilk bundles and Pie for a Year cards.

These vouchers are perfect to slip into holiday cards or they can be sent alone! They allow the recipient to come in and choose whichever pie they’d like and we only bill you for the number of pies picked up! Pretty easy right 😌 Let us be a part of your holiday experience!

Call us today at 423-491-8163 for more information! 📞

On Veteran’s Day, and every day, we are THANKFUL to those who have served our country. ❤️🤍💙
11/11/2022

On Veteran’s Day, and every day, we are THANKFUL to those who have served our country. ❤️🤍💙

Come see us Saturday at The Traveling Bazaar in Limestone!
11/11/2022

Come see us Saturday at The Traveling Bazaar in Limestone!

It’s exactly two weeks til Thanksgiving! Who’s excited? 🙋🏻‍♀️ Who’s ordered their pies? Don’t worry we’re still  accepti...
11/10/2022

It’s exactly two weeks til Thanksgiving! Who’s excited? 🙋🏻‍♀️ Who’s ordered their pies?

Don’t worry we’re still accepting orders until next Friday! But the last day to get pie is Wednesday, November 23 and only limited flavors will be available for walk-ins! 🥧

Visiting any little cutie pies for Thanksgiving? We’ve got the sweetest onesies!                                 **check...
11/10/2022

Visiting any little cutie pies for Thanksgiving? We’ve got the sweetest onesies! **check with your local shop for availability **

Our traditional pumpkin pie takes the cake 😉 and it’s the perfect addition to this beautiful fall weather! Come treat yo...
11/09/2022

Our traditional pumpkin pie takes the cake 😉 and it’s the perfect addition to this beautiful fall weather! Come treat yourself with a personal pie or order a large pie for Thanksgiving festivities!

📞423-491-8163

Friendly reminder to pre-order your Thanksgiving pies! Order ahead, and we'll have your pies ready and waiting for you t...
11/09/2022

Friendly reminder to pre-order your Thanksgiving pies! Order ahead, and we'll have your pies ready and waiting for you to pick them up.

Visit http://buttermilkskypie.com/order/ & pick your location to place your pick-up order.

Friendly reminder to pre-order your Thanksgiving pies! Order ahead, and we'll have your pies ready and waiting for you t...
11/09/2022

Friendly reminder to pre-order your Thanksgiving pies! Order ahead, and we'll have your pies ready and waiting for you to pick them up.

Visit http://buttermilkskypie.com/order/ & pick your location to place your pick-up order.

Life is short. Take your morning coffee with a side of our Thumbprint Cookies. ☕️
11/07/2022

Life is short. Take your morning coffee with a side of our Thumbprint Cookies. ☕️

Life is short. Take your morning coffee with a side of our Thumbprint Cookies. ☕️
11/07/2022

Life is short. Take your morning coffee with a side of our Thumbprint Cookies. ☕️

11/06/2022

COUNTING DOWN THE DAYS TIL THANKSGIVING!! Place your preorders for this holiday season now- we offer online ordering and call ahead ordering during normal business hours!

Thanksgiving preorders cut off Friday, November 18th at 7:00 pm!

AND if you order before the 15th- get entered to win a FREE PIE!! 🥧

11/04/2022

Mistletoe Market is in full swing! We love taking part in this event every year in Abingdon, VA 🤍🎅🏻 Come out this weekend to take advantage of all of the amazing vendors!

Friday 9:00-6:00
Saturday 9:00-6:00
Sunday 11:00-4:00

Give the gift of pie this holiday season! Let our homemade desserts make gift-giving easy, memorable, and delicious with...
11/04/2022

Give the gift of pie this holiday season! Let our homemade desserts make gift-giving easy, memorable, and delicious with a gift card for your friends and family.

Give the gift of pie this holiday season! Let our homemade desserts make gift-giving easy, memorable, and delicious with...
11/04/2022

Give the gift of pie this holiday season! Let our homemade desserts make gift-giving easy, memorable, and delicious with a gift card for your friends and family.

Nancy is hard at work making thumbprint cookies tonight! Did you know we offer multiple different cookie options? Cloud ...
11/03/2022

Nancy is hard at work making thumbprint cookies tonight! Did you know we offer multiple different cookie options? Cloud cookies, thumbprint cookies and more to make the perfect addition to your holiday spread! 🍪🧑🏻‍🍳Call us for more information or place an order online today!

On cloud 9 with our Cloud Cookies. ☁️ These pecan shortbread cookies are lovingly handmade and finished with a generous ...
11/02/2022

On cloud 9 with our Cloud Cookies. ☁️ These pecan shortbread cookies are lovingly handmade and finished with a generous amount of powdered sugar. Packaged in a delicate layer of two dozen cookies per box, these treats are sure to please!

On cloud 9 with our Cloud Cookies. ☁️ These pecan shortbread cookies are lovingly handmade and finished with a generous ...
11/02/2022

On cloud 9 with our Cloud Cookies. ☁️ These pecan shortbread cookies are lovingly handmade and finished with a generous amount of powdered sugar. Packaged in a delicate layer of two dozen cookies per box, these treats are sure to please!

Don’t forget about our GIVEAWAY! Place your Thanksgiving order NOW and get entered to win a FREE 9” pie! 😄😄 How sweet is...
11/01/2022

Don’t forget about our GIVEAWAY! Place your Thanksgiving order NOW and get entered to win a FREE 9” pie! 😄😄 How sweet is that?

Use the link in our bio or call us at 423-491-8163

Sarah and Addison are hard at work today! Here at Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop everything is made from scratch including our ...
10/31/2022

Sarah and Addison are hard at work today! Here at Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop everything is made from scratch including our crust, and our night crew stays on top of making sure we have the freshest ingredients to bake your pies with!

Come visit us in store or order online for a taste of homemade pie 🥧

No tricks over here, just treats! Here's to fun, festivities and FALL!🍁🥧
10/31/2022

No tricks over here, just treats! Here's to fun, festivities and FALL!🍁🥧

No tricks over here, just treats! Here's to fun, festivities and FALL!🍁🥧
10/31/2022

No tricks over here, just treats! Here's to fun, festivities and FALL!🍁🥧

Our NEW San Antonio pie shop hosted a Firefighter’s Pie eating contest as part of their Grand Opening celebration today....
10/29/2022

Our NEW San Antonio pie shop hosted a Firefighter’s Pie eating contest as part of their Grand Opening celebration today. Stakes were high with a year of Pie on the table for the winner!

The San Antonio Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop kicked off day 1 of Grand Opening fun today with lines outside the shop before 7...
10/28/2022

The San Antonio Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop kicked off day 1 of Grand Opening fun today with lines outside the shop before 7 a.m.! More fun giveaways and pie eating contest tomorrow! Check out their page.

Need a party treat that will put smiles on faces? Our 2" party pies are the perfect size to serve kids (big and little) ...
10/28/2022

Need a party treat that will put smiles on faces? Our 2" party pies are the perfect size to serve kids (big and little) 😌 Available in pre-assorted dozens only.

Address

3135 People's Street, Suite 300
Johnson City, TN
37064

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 7pm
Tuesday 10am - 7pm
Wednesday 10am - 7pm
Thursday 10am - 7pm
Friday 10am - 7pm
Saturday 10am - 7pm

Telephone

(423) 491-8163

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop:

Videos

Category

Our Story

We are a down home pie shop with scratch made small and regular sized pies, ice cream and thumbprint cookies. We believe in using just a few natural ingredients and a little southern know how to create desserts that would make grandma proud!

Nearby bakeries


Other Bakeries in Johnson City

Show All

Comments

I don’t know about you all, but I could go for a delicious pie AND some thumbprint cookies from Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop right about now! This Saturday, you’ll find this deliciousness in the kitchen at Harvest Acres Farm. Come on out!
Rain 🌦or☀️Shine!
10-4
357 Harvest Lane
Limestone, TN
I don’t eat much but when I do… 99% of the time, I’m driving down the road shoving some type of dessert in my face! 🤦🏼‍♀️

Just living my best life 😂

P.S. Todays desert brought to you by Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
Here's a little sneak peek at our event raffle for Access the Groove tomorrow! Come out and join us! https://www.eventbrite.com/e/access-the-groove-a-benefit-concert-for-access-etsu-tickets-313923271957

We've got 25 donations from some generous and amazing local businesses including 12 Bones River, Access ETSU, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop, Cellarest Beer Project, Chick-fil-A, Darden Restaurants, Debra Fisher, DIYabled, EMOTE, Firestorm Books & Coffee, Fleetwood's Rock and Roll Chapel and Vintage Store, Greenman Brewery, The Grey Eagle, Harvest Records, Highland Brewery, Hillman Beer - Asheville/Biltmore Village, The Local Barber & Tap, mother | bread + wine, Madam Clutterbucket's Neurodiverse Universe, Push Skate Shop, Records in the RAD, Sunny Point Cafe, The Trashy Vegan, Vinnie's Neighborhood Italian, Visa Gift Card.

Big THANK YOU to all these folks for supporting!

Raffle tix are 1 for $2, 3 for $5, and 7 for $10. Getcha some!

Can't make it tomorrow, but still want to support? Consider a donation here: https://securelb.imodules.com/s/974/giving/interior.aspx?sid=974&gid=1&pgid=3733&cid=5350&bledit=1&dids=592



[image descriptions: 1-9 a series of photos listing a variety of raffle items ranging from brewery packages to books to restaurant gift cards to hoodies to pie to stained glass art pieces and more!]
Already looking forward to another set of fall weddings at Waterstone venue this year! Congrats again to Leah and Casey!

Dress: White Lace and Promises
Venue: Waterstone venue
Rentals: Celebrate Party Rentals
Photo: Kristy Vest Photography
Catering: Barberitos Johnson City
Pies: Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
Florals: Made By Hands Floral
Planner/Coordinator: Lynnsey Porter
Bartending: On the Rocks
Cake: The Bride
Makeup: Makeup by Grace Mears
Hair: Molly Jones
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop has a cool mug…curious who’s coffee they’re serving.

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
Y’all have until 8pm to come out and help Sandy Sloan Thomas!!! There’s pizza, pies from Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop , and pumpkin painting!!! All proceeds go to help Sandy!!!
Please join us in support of Noah and the local (& delicious!) Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop!

Thank you for dedicating your Pie it Forward Campaign to Childhood Cancer Awareness Month. We are so grateful for you help bringing attention to this cause.

We are so happy and GRATEFUL to our sweet patient, Lance R., for bringing our entire team "sweet treats" from Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop. We feel so blessed to have such thoughtful patients! We love the individual serving sizes. 🙂 🎉
Best of luck to our volunteer, Julia Gilmore. She is the 2021 Miss Teen Tennessee International competing this weekend for Miss Teen International. Julia brought some sweet treats today from Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop for our families to enjoy.
We are teaming up with Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop to do an awesome giveaway for Father’s Day! Jump over to their page and comment on the post to enter!
My son & I came in today for his birthday. He had an original buttermilk & I got a strawberry....which was sooo good!!!! I wish you still had banana one, maybe it will come back soon!! I wish I knew about free pie for birthday...he would have had 2 🤣
this April with Buttermilk Sky Pie Shops! Enjoy special flavors and support great local organizations.

🥧 Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Banana Cream sales are benefitting the Nave Autism Center at East Tennessee State University
🥧 Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Blackberry Custard sales are benefitting Reel Life International
🥧 Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop & Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Banana Cream sales are benefitting Tennessee Coalition to End Domestic and Sexual Violence
🥧 Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Lemon Meringue sales are benefitting The Logos Theatre
🥧 Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Chocolate Meringue sales are benefitting Poetry Community Christian School and the Senior Mission Team
Our Buttermilk Sky Pie contest winner is !!! You can pick up your pies at our Spring Market April 23-25!

Thanks to Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop for partnering with us and to all those who participated! This giveaway was certainly popular....we love our pies in the Model City!

Be watching our social pages for a new giveaway next week!




The I-40 Pie--So so Good!
https://www.32auctions.com/organizations/68834/auctions/86718/auction_items/2393664
Thank you, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop, for donating a pie a month for a year (!) to Kari's Heart Foundation's "Karing Through Covid" online auction! We appreciate you!
🌟GIVEAWAY TIME! 🌟

We are extra THANKFUL for your loyalty in the midst of these times so we are doing a giveaway for TWO lucky winners!

✅FREE Oil change at our shop
✅ TWO four inch pies of your choice from Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

RULES:
1.) In order to enter the giveaway you must make sure you have liked our page.
2.) Like this post.
3.) Share this post.
4.) Comment when done!

❤️🎉Winners will be announced November 24th! 🎉❤️

x

Other Bakeries in Johnson City (show all)

Cakes To Live By Ora Teahouse + Bakery Great American Cookies Petite Sweets Nothing Bundt Cakes Publix Super Market at Markets West at Franklin Stanleys Produce & Bakery JK Sweet Cakes Cravings Einstein Bros. Bagels Johnson City Bakery Lazy Lady Baking Company cakebuds bakery Einstein Bros. Bagels