Baked By Beth

06/03/2026

✨ Same Cookies. New Look. ✨

Introducing the new Baked By Beth packaging!

Because custom cookies deserve a beautiful first impression. 💕

From the moment you receive your order, every detail is designed to make your experience a little sweeter.

Handcrafted cookies. Beautiful presentation. Made with heart.

06/01/2026

Another week full of colors! Can you guess the themes of this week?

05/31/2026

Hi, I’m Beth! 👋💕

For those of you who are new here, I thought it was time for a proper introduction.

By day, I’m a full-time Realtor helping families find their perfect place to call home. By night (and most weekends 😊), you’ll find me covered in icing, bringing custom cookie creations to life.

Baked By Beth started as a creative outlet and quickly turned into something so much bigger. What began with a love for baking has become a way for me to be part of some of life’s sweetest moments—baby showers, birthdays, graduations, weddings, retirements, and everything in between.

A few things you should know about me:

🍪 I believe every celebration deserves cookies.
☕ Coffee is basically a baking ingredient.
💕 Family is my why.
✨ Creativity fuels my soul.
🏡 I love serving my Mid-Missouri community.

Most importantly, I am incredibly grateful for each and every person who supports this little business. Whether you’ve ordered cookies, shared a post, referred a friend, or simply cheered me on from the sidelines… thank you.

I’m so happy you’re here. ❤️

Tell me—how long have you been following Baked By Beth, and what’s been your favorite set?

05/30/2026

💙👖 Blue Jean Baby 👖💙

Some themes just have a way of stealing my heart, and this one was no exception!

This custom Blue Jean Baby cookie set was created to celebrate the upcoming arrival of Baby Jungmeyer and was paired with the most adorable coordinating cake. From tiny overalls and baby clotheslines to rattles, denim details, and sweet baby blue accents, every piece was designed to bring this charming baby shower theme to life.

A huge shoutout to The Tiny Cake House for collaborating on this order and creating the absolutely incredible cake! The combination of custom cookies and a beautifully themed cake made for the sweetest dessert display. 🧸🍼

Working alongside talented local bakers to help create memorable celebrations is one of my favorite parts of what I do.

Congratulations to the growing family, and thank you for allowing us to be a small part of such a special day! 💙

05/30/2026

RX: Retirement

Directions:
☀️ Sleep in when needed
✈️ Travel often
👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Spend time with loved ones
😎 Enjoy every minute

Refills: Unlimited

Congratulations to Tammy on her well-deserved retirement! Thank you for trusting me to help celebrate such a special milestone with cookies that are just what the doctor ordered.

And yes… these are the only pills I’m qualified to prescribe. 😉

05/28/2026

Graduation season is in full swing over here at Baked By Beth 🎓✨
And let me tell you…these cookie calendars are starting to look a little scarier than finals week 😅

If you’re thinking about ordering custom graduation cookies for your favorite senior, now is the time to get on the schedule! Dates are filling up QUICKLY, and I’d hate for you to miss out on celebrating your graduate with something sweet and personalized.

From school colors and mascots to future college themes and custom designs, I love bringing each graduate’s story to life one cookie at a time 💙

Order here before spots are gone:
https://bakesy.shop/b/baked-by-beth-2

05/25/2026

✨ Once again, Kennedy absolutely understood the assignment with this theme! 👑💖

This “Four Ever A Princess” set for sweet Lottie Jean might just be one of my favorite birthday themes yet! From the royal dresses to the soft princess colors and all the little details in between…these cookies were SO much fun to bring to life. ✨

And can we give a special shoutout to Kennedy for always coming up with the CUTEST cookie themes?! Seriously…she never misses. 👏💕

Happy 4th Birthday, Princess Lottie Jean! 👑🩷

05/24/2026

POV: your kitchen turns into a paint studio when 18 dozen cookies are on deck for next weekend 🎨🍪

The color lineup is officially locked in and the mixers have been WORKING overtime 😂 Between the blues, neutrals, and that pop of terracotta…these sets are about to be good!

Now comes the fun part:
✨ outlining
✨ flooding
✨ details
✨ caffeine
✨ questioning my life choices around dozen #12

Stay tuned because these orders are going to be a fun one 👀

05/21/2026

💖💖💖

Behind every custom order is a cookie baker doing their best to create something beautiful for you and your family. 👩‍🍳 ♥️

05/16/2026

🤣🤣🤣 Just give me all the details 🙏🙏🙏