With Wonder Cake House

Home
United States
Indianapolis, IN
With Wonder Cake House

Luxury Cakes, Pastries & Desserts

Online Ordering Available or Find us at the Carmel Market every Saturday!

05/22/2026

✨️ Crema al Pistacchio

Available exclusively for the month of May.
Find us every Saturday

05/19/2026

🌸 The Indiana Peony Festival felt like something out of a dream. Pretty blooms, kind faces, long lines for sweets, and a booth full of moments we'll hold onto for a long time.

We sold out earlier than expected, spent the day seeing so many familiar faces (and meeting new ones too), and were surrounded by the sweetest booth neighbors imaginable. Truly one of those weekends that reminds me why I started With Wonder in the first place. ✨️

I left feeling incredibly grateful — and already inspired for next year. More pastries, more details, and even more little moments of wonder to share with you all.

Thank you for showing up, supporting small business, and making this weekend feel so special. Until next peony season 💕

A heartfelt thank you to and the kind staff & volunteers for welcoming us back for another beautiful weekend.

05/14/2026

🌷 Indiana Peony Festival 2026

Stop by our booth on Maple Ave — no. 617
We'll see you there!! ✨️

04/30/2026

✨️ Duo De Chocolat

A refined take on the beloved brookie — our Duo de Chocolat brings together a marbled blend of a brown butter chocolate chip cookie and our classic fudge brownie. Delicately crisp on top giving way to a soft base that melts with every bite.

Coming to a market near you.

01/31/2026

✨️ Cranberry Almond

A quiet favorite that surprises in the best way.
This buttery shortbread is delicately crisp, richly tender, and generously folded with tart cranberries and toasted almond slices.

It’s the kind of cookie you don’t expect to love… until you do.

What started as an understated offering has quietly become a hidden treasure — discovered, shared, and requested again by those in the know.

11/17/2025

✨ Thanksgiving Pre-Orders Are Now Open ✨

Bring home a little wonder this holiday season. Our curated Thanksgiving menu is filled with cozy, nostalgic flavors—made to gather and share!

This year’s offerings include three signature cakes: our bestselling German Chocolate, the irresistible Butter Pecan, and our warmly spiced Pumpkin Chai. We’re also offering fudgy brownie trays, assorted cookie trays, and a mixed box featuring both cookies and brownies for the perfect all-around treat.

Whether you’re hosting, gifting, or simply treating the table you'll find these treats the perfect addition to your holiday.

Reserve your favorites early—limited quantities available.

Choose to pickup at the Carmel Farmer's Market this Saturday or from our kitchen on Nov. 24th or 25th.

Use Link Below. 🧡🍂
https://www.hotplate.com/withwondercakehouse

10/29/2025

✨️ With Wonder was born from the belief that sweetness should feel like a story — one that takes you back while moving you forward.

Our desserts are crafted to bridge the comfort of nostalgia with the grace of modern luxury — soft light, golden crumbs, and the kind of flavors that remind you to pause, smile, and savor.

10/27/2025

✨️ Some things are simply meant to be together — rich chocolate fudge meets creamy vanilla cheesecake in this decadent swirl of comfort.

Each bite balances deep cocoa, velvety tang, and that melt-in-your-mouth sweetness that feels both familiar and irresistible.

Our cheesecake brownie is rich, fudgy, and softly tangy — the kind of sweetness that lingers after the last bite. A little slice of comfort that never lasts long at the market.

10/23/2025

✨️ All the magic of a campfire, baked into a slice — tender chocolate cake, graham cracker crumble, and clouds of marshmallow buttercream. Sweet nostalgia, elevated for grown-up cravings.

What started as a homage to the campfire classic has now become one of our most loved cakes.

Shop online or meet us at the market.

10/22/2025

✨️ Introducing our newest morning ritual - A nod to the Swedish style cinnamon roll, with a With Wonder twist - Our Classic Cunnabus

Soft dough delicately layered with warm spices, baked to golden perfection, and finished in a light glaze - made for cozy mornings as they mark the beginning of our new breakfast pastry collection - stay tuned.

Now available every Saturday.

#

Address

Indianapolis, IN

Website

https://msha.ke/withwonder

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when With Wonder Cake House posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to With Wonder Cake House:

Shortcuts

Want your business to be the top-listed Bakery in Indianapolis?