Clicky

Paradise Sugar Shoppe

Paradise Sugar Shoppe My name is Shelby and I run a fully licensed online bakery located in Hilton NY. My passion is to create amazing edible art for all of your occasions!

All of my baked goods are made completely from scratch. I hand roll and hand ice all of my sugar cookies so that you have the most beautiful and delicious cookies ever! I am a perfectionist and take extreme pride in my work so you will not be disappointed! Please email me at [email protected] for your custom quote. A minimum order will be 2 dozen for full size or 4 dozen minis. Any qua

All of my baked goods are made completely from scratch. I hand roll and hand ice all of my sugar cookies so that you have the most beautiful and delicious cookies ever! I am a perfectionist and take extreme pride in my work so you will not be disappointed! Please email me at [email protected] for your custom quote. A minimum order will be 2 dozen for full size or 4 dozen minis. Any qua

Operating as usual

K-pop band love! #BTS #btsarmy #kpop #paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugarcookies #decoratedcooki...
03/08/2022

K-pop band love! #BTS #btsarmy #kpop #paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugarcookies #decoratedcookies #roc #ny #rocny #roceats #rocfoodies #rochesterfoodies #rochesterfood #rochesterny #rochesternybakery #rocfood #bestcookiesever #customcookies #royalicing #cookies #cookieart #cookiesofinstagram

@simplysweetbykay and I are so egg-cited to announce that we will be egging houses this Easter!! How magical would it be...
03/07/2022

@simplysweetbykay and I are so egg-cited to announce that we will be egging houses this Easter!!

How magical would it be to have your kiddos wake up to a yard full of candy filled eggs Easter morning?! And, it’s the GOOD candy, too!
If you need NUT FREE, just let us know! ☺️

🐰 We will be hopping around the Hilton area, scattering your front yards the night before Easter.

🍪 Additional $4 per cookie if needed

🌧 If it happens to rain, we will leave everything at your door

✨ If you live outside of Hilton, you can pick your order up for $5 off!✨

🐣 Sign up by April 8th by messaging either of us!

#eggmyyard #easter2022 #paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugarcookies #decoratedcookies #roc #ny #rocny #roceats #rocfoodies #rochesterfoodies #rochesterfood #rochesterny #rochesternybakery #rocfood #bestcookiesever #customcookies #royalicing #cookies #cookieart #cookiesofinstagram

That’s it….I’m having a second wedding! All these super cute themes! Themes weren’t a thing 20 years ago let alone decor...
03/06/2022

That’s it….I’m having a second wedding! All these super cute themes! Themes weren’t a thing 20 years ago let alone decorated cookies 🤣
But I LOVE this theme of #travelingfrommisstomrs #bridalshower #bridetobe #weddingcookies #bridalshowercookies #paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugarcookies #decoratedcookies #roc #ny #rocny #roceats #rocfoodies #rochesterfoodies #rochesterfood #rochesterny #rochesternybakery #rocfood #bestcookiesever #customcookies #royalicing #cookies #cookieart #cookiesofinstagram

Since my Easter class is sold out at Blue Barn.....I have added ANOTHER CLASS at a new location!Join me to learn how to ...
03/05/2022

Since my Easter class is sold out at Blue Barn.....I have added ANOTHER CLASS at a new location!

Join me to learn how to decorate some fun Easter themed cookies! You will receive 10 cookies, all frosting colors and embellishments needed, practice sheet, a decorating tool and tips and tricks to make baking the perfect sugar cookie. This class is great for all ages and there is no experience necessary!

We will go over basic techniques such as piping, flooding and wet on wet.

Location: 420 Curtis Rd, Hilton NY 14468

Date: Thursday April 7

Time: 6:30pm - 8:00pm

Tickets: $42
**Please comment below or DM me with your email and number of tickets. An invoice will be sent to you, and once that is paid, your seat is reserved!

**COOKIES MAY DIFFER SLIGHTLY FROM PICTURE**

Simply Sweet by Kay and I are so egg-cited to announce that we will be egging houses this Easter!! How magical would it ...
03/03/2022

Simply Sweet by Kay and I are so egg-cited to announce that we will be egging houses this Easter!!

How magical would it be to have your kiddos wake up to a yard full of candy filled eggs Easter morning?! And, it’s the GOOD candy, too! If u would like NUT FREE, just let us know! ☺️

🐰 We will be hopping around the Hilton area, scattering your front yards the night before Easter.

🍪 Additional $4 per cookie if needed

🌧 If it happens to rain, we will leave everything at your door

✨if you live outside of Hilton, you can pick up your order for $5 off! ✨

🐣 Sign up by April 8th by messaging either of us!

One of my FAVE sets ever!! 💕 #babyshowercookies #babyshower #paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugar...
02/27/2022

One of my FAVE sets ever!! 💕 #babyshowercookies #babyshower #paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugarcookies #decoratedcookies #roc #ny #rocny #roceats #rocfoodies #rochesterfoodies #rochesterfood #rochesterny #rochesternybakery #rocfood #bestcookiesever #customcookies #royalicing #cookies #cookieart #cookiesofinstagram

Wedding season will be here before we know it! 💕💕💕 #weddingseason #weddingcookies #bridalshowercookies #paradisesugarsho...
02/26/2022

Wedding season will be here before we know it! 💕💕💕 #weddingseason #weddingcookies #bridalshowercookies #paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugarcookies #decoratedcookies #roc #ny #rocny #roceats #rocfoodies #rochesterfoodies #rochesterfood #rochesterny #rochesternybakery #rocfood #bestcookiesever #customcookies #royalicing #cookies #cookieart #cookiesofinstagram

I’m obsessed w the Leprechaun Bait! 😍☘️ St Paddy’s day Pre-sale is live!Orders must be placed by March 4 for March 16 pi...
02/24/2022

I’m obsessed w the Leprechaun Bait! 😍☘️ St Paddy’s day Pre-sale is live!

Orders must be placed by March 4 for March 16 pick up.

*Leprechaun Bait $8
*Mini cards $3.50 each
*large shamrocks w sprinkles…
Box of 6 - $24
Box of 12-$45

For those of you that don’t know, I slipped down my basement stairs a few weeks ago and broke my shoulder. 😱 As I fell, ...
02/24/2022

For those of you that don’t know, I slipped down my basement stairs a few weeks ago and broke my shoulder. 😱

As I fell, I hit a paint can that spilled all over me and all the way down the stairs.

I cried and cried and cried some more…..not just bc of the pain, but bc I was unsure as to how I would continue my business for the time being. This girl, this girl right here…..my baby girl. Well, technically she is an adult now but we won’t talk about that 😩
She has helped me beyond anything I could imagine. She bakes, makes frosting, washed dishes, packages cookies, packs boxes and carts my broke ass around. Without her, I could not teach my classes and do any of what I have been able to do!

I didn’t post this for any other reason than to give her the biggest shout out ever and bc I don’t know what I would do wothout her! 💕💕💕 @rileylettaa

I absolutely love this theme! Black Girl Magic to welcome Brielle into the world! #babyshower #blackgirlmagic #paradises...
02/19/2022

I absolutely love this theme! Black Girl Magic to welcome Brielle into the world! #babyshower #blackgirlmagic #paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugarcookies #decoratedcookies #roc #ny #rocny #roceats #rocfoodies #rochesterfoodies #rochesterfood #rochesterny #rochesternybakery #rocfood #bestcookiesever #customcookies #royalicing #cookies #cookieart #cookiesofinstagram

Hilton hockey ❤️🖤❤️🖤 #hockeyislife  #hockeycookies #paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugarcookies #...
02/16/2022

Hilton hockey ❤️🖤❤️🖤 #hockeyislife #hockeycookies #paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugarcookies #decoratedcookies #roc #ny #rocny #roceats #rocfoodies #rochesterfoodies #rochesterfood #rochesterny #rochesternybakery #rocfood #bestcookiesever #customcookies #royalicing #cookies #cookieart #cookiesofinstagram

Happy Valentine’s Day friends! I hope your day is filled with love and kindness! 💕💕💕 #happyvalentinesday
02/14/2022

Happy Valentine’s Day friends! I hope your day is filled with love and kindness! 💕💕💕 #happyvalentinesday

02/14/2022

🏈🏈WINNERS!!🏈🏈

1st - Bob Bourg
Half- Amy Mascadri
3rd - Dyan Valle
Final - Amy mascadri

Jill McPhee and Andrea Fullerton are the winners of the random drawings and will each get $10 toward Easter pre-sale!!

Congrats and THANK YOU!!💕💕

Here it is!! Who will be the winners tomorrow??!! 🏈🏈🏈 GOOD LUCK! PRIZES 🏈1st quarter- 2 dozen full size cookies 🏈Halftim...
02/13/2022

Here it is!! Who will be the winners tomorrow??!! 🏈🏈🏈

GOOD LUCK!

PRIZES
🏈1st quarter- 2 dozen full size cookies
🏈Halftime- 2 dozen full size cookies
🏈3rd quarter- 2 dozen full size cookies
🏆 Final score- 2 dozen full size cookies and 2 dz minis

✨Winners may choose date and theme with at least 2 weeks notice within 2022.

✨Additional winners will be randomly chosen for small giveaways throughout the game!

Locals only please
All square purchases are final and will be on a first come first served basis.
If there is an overwhelming response I may open a second board!

Invoices will be sent via email.

Watercolor galaxy birthday! #galaxycookies #paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugarcookies #decorate...
02/12/2022

Watercolor galaxy birthday! #galaxycookies #paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugarcookies #decoratedcookies #roc #ny #rocny #roceats #rocfoodies #rochesterfoodies #rochesterfood #rochesterny #rochesternybakery #rocfood #bestcookiesever #customcookies #royalicing #cookies #cookieart #cookiesofinstagram

02/12/2022

💕Valentines pick up is today from 10-5. 💕

Cookies are Inside bc I am also having a fundraiser pick up at my house too for the class of 2022. So please ring the door bell.

18 Judd Ln Hilton.

I have a few extras..1 bear $121 Baseball cards $3 each 3 gem cards $3 each 1 unicorn $3 5 How sweet it is to be taught ...
02/11/2022

I have a few extras..

1 bear $12
1 Baseball cards $3 each
3 gem cards $3 each
1 unicorn $3
5 How sweet it is to be taught by you (or it can just say Happy Valentine’s Day)

Pick up 10-5 today and tomorrow

Venmo @shelby-letta

🏈UPDATE…BOARD IS FULL! Thank u! 🏈2 squares left for this weekends big game!!!
02/08/2022

🏈UPDATE…BOARD IS FULL! Thank u! 🏈

2 squares left for this weekends big game!!!

✨Super Bowl Squares✨

UPDATE … SOLD OUT

2 squares left!!! WIN SOME COOKIES ❤️

$6 per square

All names and numbers will be randomly placed using an online generator.

PRIZES
🏈1st quarter- 2 dozen full size cookies
🏈Halftime- 2 dozen full size cookies
🏈3rd quarter- 2 dozen full size cookies
🏆 Final score- 2 dozen full size cookies and 2 dz minis

✨Winners may choose date and theme with at least 2 weeks notice within 2022.

✨Additional winners will be randomly chosen for small giveaways throughout the game!

Locals only please
All square purchases are final and will be on a first come first served basis.
If there is an overwhelming response I may open a second board!

Invoices will be sent via email.

Finally posting some cookie class fun from last week at @bluebarncidery !!There is a little availability left for my Feb...
01/31/2022

Finally posting some cookie class fun from last week at @bluebarncidery !!There is a little availability left for my February 24th class! Head over to my FB page to get your tickets! #cookiedecorating #cookiedecoratingclass

Game night!!! #hiltongirlsbasketball #hiltoncadets #basketballcookies #paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcook...
01/28/2022

Game night!!! #hiltongirlsbasketball #hiltoncadets #basketballcookies #paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugarcookies #decoratedcookies #roc #ny #rocny #roceats #rocfoodies #rochesterfoodies #rochesterfood #rochesterny #rochesternybakery #rocfood #bestcookiesever #customcookies #royalicing #cookies #cookieart #cookiesofinstagram

8 squares left!! Scoop ’em up!
01/28/2022

8 squares left!! Scoop ’em up!

✨Super Bowl Squares✨

UPDATE … SOLD OUT

2 squares left!!! WIN SOME COOKIES ❤️

$6 per square

All names and numbers will be randomly placed using an online generator.

PRIZES
🏈1st quarter- 2 dozen full size cookies
🏈Halftime- 2 dozen full size cookies
🏈3rd quarter- 2 dozen full size cookies
🏆 Final score- 2 dozen full size cookies and 2 dz minis

✨Winners may choose date and theme with at least 2 weeks notice within 2022.

✨Additional winners will be randomly chosen for small giveaways throughout the game!

Locals only please
All square purchases are final and will be on a first come first served basis.
If there is an overwhelming response I may open a second board!

Invoices will be sent via email.

QVC!! #Paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugarcookies #decoratedcookies #roc #ny #rocny #roceats #ro...
01/24/2022

QVC!! #Paradisesugarshoppe #buzzfeedfood #royalicingcookies #sugarcookies #decoratedcookies #roc #ny #rocny #roceats #rocfoodies #rochesterfoodies #rochesterfood #rochesterny #rochesternybakery #rocfood #bestcookiesever #customcookies #royalicing #cookies #cookieart #cookiesofinstagram

Address

Hilton, NY

Telephone

5854330105

Products

Custom decorated sugar cookies and chocolate chip cookie cakes

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Paradise Sugar Shoppe posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Paradise Sugar Shoppe:

Videos

Category

Our Story

All of my baked goods are made completely from scratch. I hand roll and hand ice all of my sugar cookies so that you have the most beautiful and delicious cookies ever! I am a perfectionist and take extreme pride in my work so you will not be disappointed! *WE ARE NOT A NUT FREE KITCHEN* Please email me at [email protected] for your custom quote. A minimum order of 1 dozen is required for all custom cookie orders. Cookie prices range depending on the size and detail of the cookies. A typical full size dozen with 3 designs is $59/dz. Mini cookies are $20-$22/dz with a minimum of 3 dozen. A lead time of at least 3 weeks is required but please feel free to ask if you need your order sooner. All orders are picked up or shipped to my customers. I can ship anywhere within the United States.

Nearby bakeries


Other Bakeries in Hilton

Show All

Comments

Thank you for the fun class tonight!!! Paradise Sugar Shoppe!!!
Enjoy the winter a little more with the help of some cookies! Join us and Paradise Sugar Shoppe for this Winter Cookie Decorating Class (virtually with a cookie kit) on February 25. For more information, or to register, visit: https://hiltonny.myrec.com/info/activities/program_details.aspx?ProgramID=29993
Virtual Cookie Decorating!!! Join us and Paradise Sugar Shoppe in February and/or March as you try your hand at a simple cookie decorating class on zoom. A well put-together cookie kit will be provided and will need to be picked up. Come and explore how easy this class is and show your artistic side. Try your hand at this simple cookie decorating class on zoom. A well put-together cookie kit will be provided and will need to be picked up. Come and explore how easy this class is and show your artistic side. For more information or to register, visit https://hiltonny.myrec.com/info/activities/program_details.aspx?ProgramID=29993
My daughter took Shelby's Zoom class. I think these are pretty impressive for an 8 year old who has never picked up a piping bag before.
Here are the cookies I decorated tonight thru the Hilton Parma Rec class. Thanks, Shelby. Great class
Two Sessions of Virtual Cookie Decorating - Halloween/Fall Cookies (includes Halloween and Fall Designs) are coming up on 10/17 (a.m.) and 10/21 (p.m.). SHARE this post by 10/14 at noon for a chance to win FREE registration!!! When you share, be sure to change sharing privacy settings to "public" and tag Paradise Sugar Shoppe in order to be visible and eligible for the drawing. The winner will be drawn that day and get to choose their desired class date. If you know you wish to participate, please register prior to the drawing. We will reimburse the winner if they are already registered. Join Paradise Sugar Shoppe for this fun virtual class and create some beautifully delicious creations. Kits are provided.
Check out some of the photos from our recent Virtual Cookie Decorating class that was held on June 4th with Paradise Sugar Shoppe! The Zoom instruction format went great and the cookies came out beautifully!
Our virtual Cookie Decorating Class (comes with supply kits) is happening on Thursday June 4! Join Paradise Sugar Shoppe for this fun virtual class and create some beautifully delicious creations. Register by June 2 at https://hiltonny.myrec.com/info/activities/program_details.aspx?ProgramID=29993
Paradise Sugar Shoppe. For the cookie class do we get to bring home 12 cookies.
Thank you so much for these cookies!!! They were the hit of the dessert table at our New Year’s Eve party!!
Thank you so much for the awesome cookies!! The kids loved them and they were perfect!!!
We had a fabulous evening last night to kick off our annual Holiday Trunk Show event ✨🥂 Big thanks to all who join us in the celebrations including Root Catering for the hors d’oeuvre, Paradise Sugar Shoppe for the cookies, Dan King Band for the tunes, Bavarian Nut Company for the glazed nuts and of course Santa 🎅🏼 Join us today and Saturday to enjoy special savings on all your favorite designers!