5 Ponies Cookie Co.

5 Ponies Cookie Co. Cottage bakery specializing in custom cookies and cookie cakes.
(1)

✨🤸‍♀️ Tumbling Into Three! 🤸‍♂️✨We had so much fun creating this sweet custom cookie set to celebrate Cooper Leigh turni...
06/04/2026

✨🤸‍♀️ Tumbling Into Three! 🤸‍♂️✨

We had so much fun creating this sweet custom cookie set to celebrate Cooper Leigh turning THREE! 💕💜💙

From handstands and cartwheels to colorful birthday details, these cookies were the perfect way to honor a little gymnast’s big day. 🎉

Thank you for letting 5 Ponies Cookie Co. be part of your special celebration! 🩷

🎂 Need cookies for an upcoming birthday party?
📩 Send us a message to get your custom order started!

‼️Last Call for 5 Ponies Merch ‼️NEW MERCH PRESALE will be open through this Friday June 5th Our Comfort Color Colorblas...
06/01/2026

‼️Last Call for 5 Ponies Merch ‼️

NEW MERCH PRESALE will be open through this Friday June 5th

Our Comfort Color Colorblast Tees are here and we are OBSESSED 🤍🐴🍪. We had SO MANY compliments on the ones we got for cookie crew friends that we decided to offer all our cookie friends the chance to have their own! 😍

Available in:
🌸 Hibiscus (Adult Only)
🤎 Umber (Youth & Adult)

Sizes:
• Youth Small–XL — $25
• Adult Small–3XL — $30

These tees are soft, comfy, and perfect for everyday wear!
Preorder yours now before the presale closes! 💕

Don’t miss out on the celebration! Cookies and Lemonade are a 100/10 combination 🤭. Come celebrate T&T Lemomades 1 year ...
05/30/2026

Don’t miss out on the celebration! Cookies and Lemonade are a 100/10 combination 🤭. Come celebrate T&T Lemomades 1 year Birthday in downtown Hartsville till 8 pm!

🦆💚 Little ducks, antlers, and all the hunting vibes for baby on the way!These custom baby shower cookies are giving the ...
05/29/2026

🦆💚 Little ducks, antlers, and all the hunting vibes for baby on the way!

These custom baby shower cookies are giving the perfect mix of rustic charm and sweet southern style. Which design is your favorite — the ducks, deer, or the sage green baby plaques? 🤎✨

Now booking custom orders for baby showers, birthdays, and all your special events!

🧸🩵 The sweetest baby blues and bears to celebrate a baby boy on the way 🩵🧸From little bears, to rattles, to the baby blu...
05/25/2026

🧸🩵 The sweetest baby blues and bears to celebrate a baby boy on the way 🩵🧸

From little bears, to rattles, to the baby blues this set was perfect to celebrate with the parents who can bearly wait to meet their little boy🩵.

Message us to book your custom cookie sets!
📍 .

💙🔫 Boy or Girl? 🌹🩷Guns or Roses… what will baby be? ✨We loved creating this adorable gender reveal cookie set featuring ...
05/22/2026

💙🔫 Boy or Girl? 🌹🩷

Guns or Roses… what will baby be? ✨
We loved creating this adorable gender reveal cookie set featuring sweet pink roses, crossed pistols, and all the sweet or rowdy baby shower vibes 🤠

Perfect for your reveal table, dessert bar, or favors! 🍪💗

Message 5 Ponies Cookie Co. to book your gender reveal treats!

Support not 1, not 2, not 3, but actually FOUR small businesses in one stop 😍. Sounds like a win to me! Shop the cutest ...
05/22/2026

Support not 1, not 2, not 3, but actually FOUR small businesses in one stop 😍. Sounds like a win to me! Shop the cutest fits from Blue Roan + Co. ( she even had a couple fits for the curvy ladies, last week and I grabbed one 😍), lemonade from T&T lemonade, of course the perfect sweet treat from yours truly 🍪, AND you can browse the beautiful home decor of R&M On Main. Go see these sweet hard working ladies and brighten up your gloomy Friday!

✨ COOKIE OF THE WEEK ✨These sold out so fast last week at Hartsvilles Downtown Sound event, I figure they’d be perfect f...
05/18/2026

✨ COOKIE OF THE WEEK ✨

These sold out so fast last week at Hartsvilles Downtown Sound event, I figure they’d be perfect for this week’s cookie of the week!

Say hello to our Oatmeal Cream Pie! It is loaded with soft, chewy oatmeal cookies and a thick layer of fluffy vanilla cream filling that tastes like the snack you begged for as a kid… only way better ✨

4 for $20
6 for $30

Available this week only at 5 Ponies Cookie Co 🐴
Go ahead — spoil your inner child one cookie at a time.

Did y’all think I forgot?? 😏 ANOTHER surprise for the Downtown Sound event tonight will be….🍫🥜 COOKIE OF THE WEEK 🥜🍫Intr...
05/14/2026

Did y’all think I forgot?? 😏 ANOTHER surprise for the Downtown Sound event tonight will be….

🍫🥜 COOKIE OF THE WEEK 🥜🍫
Introducing the Snickers Explosion Cookie 🤯

A soft, loaded cookie packed with peanuts and chocolate chips, topped with creamy caramel, rich chocolate fudge, and chunks of Snickers on top! 🍪✨

This one is messy, gooey, crunchy, and completely over-the-top in the best way 😍

📅 Likited supply tonight, you can still order some for a Saturday pick up!
📍Pre-order now before they’re gone!

4 for $46
6 for $24
12 for $40

Address

Hartsville, TN
37074

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when 5 Ponies Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category