5 Ponies Cookie Co.

5 Ponies Cookie Co. Cottage bakery specializing in custom cookies and cookie cakes.
(1)

We just made a cookie and cake pop restock at Hartsville Foodland !! Your cookie line up is….🍪 Chocolate Chip🍁Maple Brow...
10/06/2026

We just made a cookie and cake pop restock at Hartsville Foodland !!

Your cookie line up is….
🍪 Chocolate Chip
🍁Maple Brown Sugar
🐎 Pony Express
🤎Brownie Batter Bliss

Cake Pop flavors are…
🍭Vanilla
🍭Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

✨🍪 Cookie(S) of the week 🍪✨You read that right!! This week there are TWO new cookie flavors 🥳. One packed with flavors a...
10/06/2026

✨🍪 Cookie(S) of the week 🍪✨

You read that right!! This week there are TWO new cookie flavors 🥳. One packed with flavors and the other is bringing all the cozy fall vibes!

‼️Hartsville Foodland has a handful of each flavor, just delivered! ‼️

🤠 The Pony Express 🐎🍪

This cookie is packed and delivering all the flavors! A soft, chewy cookie loaded with chocolate chips, M&M’s, Reese’s, Snickers, and crunchy pretzels, all finished with a rich, melted chocolate bottom.

It’s sweet, salty, chocolatey, crunchy, and loaded with ALL the good stuff! 🤎🍫🥨

🍁🤎 MAPLE BROWN SUGAR 🤎🍁

Sweet, cozy, and packed with fall flavor! 🍪✨

A soft, chewy maple brown sugar cookie topped with creamy maple icing and finished with a sprinkle of brown sugar to bring you fall in cookie form 😍.

📣 You can mix & match your flavors this week!

2 for $8
4 for $16
6 for $24
8 for $32

Orders will be open through Thursday evening, message to get your sweets stocked for the weekend.

👀✨ SOMETHING BIG IS COMING FOR 5 PONIES COOKIE CO! 🐴🍪💗We’ve been working behind the scenes on something BIG, exciting, a...
10/03/2026

👀✨ SOMETHING BIG IS COMING FOR 5 PONIES COOKIE CO! 🐴🍪💗

We’ve been working behind the scenes on something BIG, exciting, and we can’t wait to share it with y’all! 🤩

We’re not spilling the sprinklesJUST yet… 🤫

But trust us—you’re gonna want to be here for this one! 🩷

✨ STAY TUNED! ✨

The Hartsville Auction Barn will have 5 Ponies cookies tonight! Go by, check out the deals and grab a sweet treat while ...
09/26/2026

The Hartsville Auction Barn will have 5 Ponies cookies tonight! Go by, check out the deals and grab a sweet treat while you’re there!

🌹🍪 VISIT THE SHOPS AT BLUE ROAN TODAY 🍪🌹Make sure you stop by Yellow Rose Antiques & Collectibles at The Shops at Blue R...
09/26/2026

🌹🍪 VISIT THE SHOPS AT BLUE ROAN TODAY 🍪🌹

Make sure you stop by Yellow Rose Antiques & Collectibles at The Shops at Blue Roan today and other new shops set up! 🛍️✨

And while you’re browsing all the goodies, grab yourself a sweet treat from 5 Ponies Cookie Co! 🤎🍪

✨ Shop local
✨ Find something unique
✨ Treat yourself to a cookie!

📍 Yellow Rose Antiques & Collectibles — The Shops at Blue Roan
🗓️ TODAY!

Come shop, stroll & snack! 🐴🍪🌹

✨🥂 Cheers to forever! 💍🤍These elegant wedding cookies were made for a beautiful celebration, featuring custom details, c...
09/25/2026

✨🥂 Cheers to forever! 💍🤍

These elegant wedding cookies were made for a beautiful celebration, featuring custom details, ch*****ne glasses, wedding rings, and you just can’t go wrong with a classic white and gold. ✨

A sweet little touch for a sweet beginning to forever! 💕💍

Thank you for choosing 5 Ponies Cookie Co. to be part of your special day! 🤍

📩 Need custom cookies for your wedding, shower, or special event? Send us a message to get started! 🐴🍪

🎃🍂 COOKIE OF THE WEEK — FALL EDITION! 🍂🎃Say hello to THE PUMPKIN PATCH! 🎃🍪A soft, chewy fall cookie loaded with deliciou...
09/23/2026

🎃🍂 COOKIE OF THE WEEK — FALL EDITION! 🍂🎃

Say hello to THE PUMPKIN PATCH! 🎃🍪

A soft, chewy fall cookie loaded with delicious goodness, white chocolate & pumpkin spice baking chips, drizzled with sweet pumpkin spice goodness and topped with the cutest little pumpkin chocolate! 🧡

It’s giving pumpkin patch, crisp fall days & ALL the cozy vibes! 🍁🤎

4 for $16
6 for $24
8 for $32

Message 5 Ponies Cookie Co to pre-order yours! 🧡

💗💙 A Little Sweet Surprise! 💙💗Gender reveal cake pops are the perfect way to celebrate a boy or girl! 🍼✨These adorable l...
09/21/2026

💗💙 A Little Sweet Surprise! 💙💗

Gender reveal cake pops are the perfect way to celebrate a boy or girl! 🍼✨

These adorable little treats are made extra special for sharing the big news with family and friends! 🎀

Thank you for letting 5 Ponies Cookie Co. be part of such a sweet moment! 🤍

🎀 Pink or Blue… what will baby be? 💙💗

🏈🥳 Football and Birthdays 🥳🏈These custom football cookies brought some Bulldog spirit to the celebration! 🐶🍪From jerseys...
09/17/2026

🏈🥳 Football and Birthdays 🥳🏈

These custom football cookies brought some Bulldog spirit to the celebration! 🐶🍪

From jerseys and footballs to team slogans and custom designs, these cookies are the perfect treat for game days, birthdays, tailgates, or any football fan!

✨ Custom cookies made just for your special event!
📩 Message 5 Ponies Cookie Co. to order your own custom set!

🚀🍪 COOKIE OF THE WEEK: THE ROCKET 🍪🚀In honor of our sweet boy Rocket that we said “see you later” to last week. Rocket w...
09/16/2026

🚀🍪 COOKIE OF THE WEEK: THE ROCKET 🍪🚀

In honor of our sweet boy Rocket that we said “see you later” to last week. Rocket was one of our 5 Ponies ambassadors and while he is no longer with us, his legacy will live on through the 5 Ponies brand 🤍. So this week’s red velvet cookie is for our red pony, until we meet again sweet Rock.

Red velvet meets chocolate heaven! ❤️🍫

Our Rocket is packed with cream cheese chocolate chip pieces, topped with a smooth white chocolate ganache icing, and finished with mini chocolate chips for the perfect chocolatey crunch!

✨ Rich. Creamy. Chocolatey. Out-of-this-world. ✨
Who needs one (or two 😉)? 🍪❤️

Address

Hartsville, TN
37074

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when 5 Ponies Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category