5 Ponies Cookie Co.

5 Ponies Cookie Co. Cottage bakery specializing in custom cookies and cookie cakes.
(1)

Congrats to our friends at 615 Boutique on 8 years!! We know y’all had a great event and thank you for allowing us to be...
09/01/2026

Congrats to our friends at 615 Boutique on 8 years!! We know y’all had a great event and thank you for allowing us to be a small part of it again this year!! Can’t wait for year 9s theme 🤭😉.

Happy Sunday! Our 500 cookie order was for the Grand Opening event of the new addition to the Hartsville TCAT campus!! ✨...
08/30/2026

Happy Sunday!

Our 500 cookie order was for the Grand Opening event of the new addition to the Hartsville TCAT campus!! ✨
We are incredibly thankful to have been a part of their event , and hope they had the best turn out!

A big thank you to our Lebanon bakery friend Sweet Thing Bakery for doing the edible printed images for the cookies, they looked amazing!

Happpy Saturday cookie peeps! We delivered 500 cookies this morning Hartsville! This is my biggest order yet by 100 cook...
08/29/2026

Happpy Saturday cookie peeps!

We delivered 500 cookies this morning Hartsville! This is my biggest order yet by 100 cookies. The last large order I did was for 400 cookies for the grand opening of the REI warehouse in Lebanon! 🤩

Anyone want to take a guess to where these were delivered to?! 🤓

✨💖 IN HONOR OF DOLLY 💖✨Our bestie Harts Fuel Nutrition is serving up this DELICIOUS (I had one yesterday) drink to honor...
08/26/2026

✨💖 IN HONOR OF DOLLY 💖✨

Our bestie Harts Fuel Nutrition is serving up this DELICIOUS (I had one yesterday) drink to honor the one and only Dolly Parton💕🤠

And here’s the sweetest part… 💗

EVERY DOLLY DRINK ORDERED THROUGH THE END OF AUGUST = $1 DONATED BY 5 PONIES COOKIE CO TO THE IMAGINATION LIBRARY! 📚✨

Grab your Dolly, sip something sparkly, and help us spread a little love and a LOT of imagination! 🦋💖

If you’re not in the Hartsville area and would still like to help us donate, feel free to reach out and I can send you my Venmo or Cashapp info!

🎀 Because in true Dolly fashion… we’re making the world a little sweeter! 🎀

Fresh cookies were dropped off Hartsville Foodland this morning 🍪✨🍪 Chocolate Chip🍫M&M🍌Banana Pudding 🤍 Soft & Chewy Sug...
08/21/2026

Fresh cookies were dropped off Hartsville Foodland this morning 🍪✨

🍪 Chocolate Chip
🍫M&M
🍌Banana Pudding
🤍 Soft & Chewy Sugar Cookie
🤎 Disco Delight

Come see us this evening at The Downtown Sound in Hartsville! Food, fun, and vendors. Along with The Scarecrow Band & Fr...
08/13/2026

Come see us this evening at The Downtown Sound in Hartsville! Food, fun, and vendors. Along with The Scarecrow Band & Friends for the music!

Don’t miss out 5p-8p, we’ve got a good variety lineup for the sweets!!

🎀🐮 OINK • BAA • MOO! 🐷🤠How CUTE is this sweet little farm-themed birthday set?! 💕Pink pigs, happy cows, little chicks, s...
08/12/2026

🎀🐮 OINK • BAA • MOO! 🐷🤠

How CUTE is this sweet little farm-themed birthday set?! 💕
Pink pigs, happy cows, little chicks, sweet bows & the cutest personalized cookies for Madi’s 2nd birthday! 🎂🎀

These custom cookies were almost TOO cute to eat! 🥹💗

Thank you for letting 5 Ponies Cookie Co. be part of Madi’s special day! 🐴🍪

📩 Need cookies for your next birthday, shower, or celebration? Message us to order your custom set!

🤠🍫 COOKIE OF THE WEEK: BUTTERFINGER BANDIT 🍫🤠A soft, chewy cookie loaded with crunchy Butterfinger pieces, topped with s...
08/10/2026

🤠🍫 COOKIE OF THE WEEK: BUTTERFINGER BANDIT 🍫🤠

A soft, chewy cookie loaded with crunchy Butterfinger pieces, topped with smooth chocolate and even MORE Butterfinger goodness. 😍

📩 Message 5 Ponies Cookie Co to pre-order yours for the perfect weekend treat!

4 for $16
6 for $24
8 for $32

🍪🤎

🤎🤍 Oh Baby🤎🤍A sweet neutral set to celebrate the arrival of baby Mathis earlier this summer 😍Loved creating these sweet ...
08/06/2026

🤎🤍 Oh Baby🤎🤍

A sweet neutral set to celebrate the arrival of baby Mathis earlier this summer 😍

Loved creating these sweet custom cookies to celebrate Baby Mathis! Thank you for trusting 5 Ponies Cookie Co. to be part of such a special day. 💕✨

Need cookies for your next baby shower, birthday, or special event? Send us a message to book your custom order! 🩷🍪

Surprise!!We will be joining the Hartsville-Trousdale Chamber of Commerce watch party tomorrow from 6p - 8p to see who w...
08/06/2026

Surprise!!

We will be joining the Hartsville-Trousdale Chamber of Commerce watch party tomorrow from 6p - 8p to see who wins at the polls and will bring all the sweets!

Our bestie Harts Fuel Nutrition will be there selling hydration drinks to keep everyone hydrated during the event, grab one you won’t disappointed!

Our friends T & T Lemonade will also be there serving Hartsville’s favorite lemonades! Uncle Red's BBQ will also be there serving up bbq (if they have their sourdough bbq grilled cheese it is 🤤🤌🏼). And what’s a watch party without music from Hartsville’s very own Taylor Harris?! Come join us for a good time!!

Address

Hartsville, TN
37074

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when 5 Ponies Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category