Plot Twist Cookie Co.

Plot Twist Cookie Co. Providing custom sugar cookies for any occasion! Local pickup only | PM to order!

Disclaimer: All products are produced in a home kitchen not subject to public health inspection that may also process common food allergens

First baby shower set of 2026! 🌸🪻🌷Be on the lookout for my Easter presale coming within the next week or so!🤞🏼 ...
03/15/2026

First baby shower set of 2026! 🌸🪻🌷

Be on the lookout for my Easter presale coming within the next week or so!🤞🏼

sugarcookieart cookieart cookie cookies royalicing decoratedsugarcookies royalicingcookies plottwistcookies
cookiedecorating partycookies cookieinspo customcookies cookieideas icingcookies

Plot twist… we’re officially ONE 🎉What started as a crazy idea one year ago turned into a whole lotta cookies! After a l...
01/28/2026

Plot twist… we’re officially ONE 🎉
What started as a crazy idea one year ago turned into a whole lotta cookies! After a little post-holiday breather, we’re back with the same creativity, passion, and heart — plus a refreshed logo, brand-new menu, and updated FAQ.

As always, thank you for every order, like, share, and kind word. Quite literally could not do this without you!♥️

🎄🍪Holiday Cookies are here! 🍪🎄Perfect for gifting, parties, or a treat for yourself! All cookies will be available for p...
12/16/2025

🎄🍪Holiday Cookies are here! 🍪🎄

Perfect for gifting, parties, or a treat for yourself! All cookies will be available for pickup next week!

Individual cookies: $4 (+$1 for any customizations)
1 dzn regular: $35
Minis: packs of 4 for $6 or 1 dzn for $18

DM me to place your order!

Had to celebrate a sweet coworker with a sweet cookie cake!! So happy with how this turned out😍
12/15/2025

Had to celebrate a sweet coworker with a sweet cookie cake!! So happy with how this turned out😍

🌟🎄 Holiday Cookie Alert! 🎄🌟A slight delay in posting Christmas cookies but have no fear, they are here! Some assorted mi...
12/12/2025

🌟🎄 Holiday Cookie Alert! 🎄🌟

A slight delay in posting Christmas cookies but have no fear, they are here! Some assorted minis done for 12 Days of Cookie Countdown calendar, still some availability left for $30. Available for pickup today or tomorrow!

Ps: Regular holiday cookies will be posted by the end of this weekend! Thank you again for everyone support in this venture of mine 🥹

Had to double post for my last Halloween themed set as Christmas starts tomorrow in this house! Thank you again to every...
10/31/2025

Had to double post for my last Halloween themed set as Christmas starts tomorrow in this house! Thank you again to everyone who has ordered a set from me, your support means the world 🥹

Thanksgiving themed sets will be available, designs/set will be posted in the next week or so and order will be available for pickup Thanksgiving week! Note: I will only be accepting a limited number of custom orders for the next two months as my focus will be on presales! ☺️

Absolutely obsessed with how this turned out!! Such a fun throwback for a Halloween/birthday!
10/31/2025

Absolutely obsessed with how this turned out!! Such a fun throwback for a Halloween/birthday!

👻🎃HAPPY HALLOWEEK!🎃👻Grateful to be so busy this week! Stay tuned for some fun sets coming up this week 🤩
10/27/2025

👻🎃HAPPY HALLOWEEK!🎃👻

Grateful to be so busy this week! Stay tuned for some fun sets coming up this week 🤩

Tested my time management skills and creativity to make a fun lil set for the Billie Eilish concert! PS— don’t forget to...
10/18/2025

Tested my time management skills and creativity to make a fun lil set for the Billie Eilish concert!

PS— don’t forget to order your Halloween cookies before it’s too late, link in bio!!



🎃👻 THE WAIT IS OVER… THIS IS HALLOWEEN! 👻🎃You’ve been asking, and the Plot Twist you’ve been waiting for has finally arr...
10/15/2025

🎃👻 THE WAIT IS OVER… THIS IS HALLOWEEN! 👻🎃

You’ve been asking, and the Plot Twist you’ve been waiting for has finally arrived — Halloween cookies are here! 🕸️

Ditch the store-bought candy and treat your little monsters to something homemade, spooky, and sweet. 🍪✨

🕷️ Regulars (3–4”) — $4 each / $20 half dozen
🕷️ Minis (1–2”) — $6 (4-pack), $8 (6-cookie bag), $20/dozen
🕷️ 9” Cookie cake w/ minis — $30
💀 Custom options available for an extra fee!

🎃 ORDERS CLOSED
All orders must be placed before October 23, and will be ready for pickup on October 30 — just in time for the big night.

Address

Greensboro, NC

Telephone

+19083992234

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Plot Twist Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Plot Twist Cookie Co.:

Shortcuts

Share

Category