Shelly's Cookie Jar

Shelly's Cookie Jar Bakery CO-OP operating inside of Blessed Bee Cupcakes. I've been baking since I was 5...I asked for my first stand mixer when I was 12. When other kids were reading comic books I was reading cookbooks.

Owning a bakery has been my life long dream and it finally came true! We offer bars, brownies, cookies and happy memories. :)

Check out our online menu or come on in to see what we have in the store that day. We are a co-op bakery with Blessed Bee Cupcakes and Ashley's Decadent you will find cupcakes, decorated cut-out sugar cookies and cheesecakes as well on a weekly basis.

Operating as usual


This is our last week for retail! We are open our normal hours on Thursday and Friday from 12-6 and Saturday from 10-2.

I will be completely closed the week of December 23rd to enjoy the holidays with my family.

I will be taking special orders only through January 17th...if you still have a Gift Certificate please stop in this week or give me a call at 920-266-9650 to place an order for January. I believe there are still two or three of those gift certificates out there!

Bars and Brownies can be ordered in quantites of 6 or more. I ask that cookies be ordered in minimum quantities of 2 dozen or more.

It is with mixed emotions that I tell you all I will be closed permanently after January 17th. Make no mistake about it...this bakery has been a success thanks to all of my loyal customers! You have all been so amazing and supportive and I have made some wonderful new friends while baking for you! :)

Mr. Cookie Jar and I have decided we want to concentrate on growing our family and that is where my heart, energy and all of my efforts need to be right now. We are so excited to start this new chapter and hopefully by this time next year there will be a baby cookie in our lives! ;)

"Sometimes Me Think, "What is Friend?" and then me say, Friend is someone to share the last cookie with." - Cookie Monster


This Week's Flavors!

Malted Milk Ball Brownies...a favorite!

Snowball Cookies...a soft buttery pecan cookie that melts in your mouth!

Chocolate Chip Cookies...these are always warm and fresh from the oven early in the day!

Sour Cream Sugar Cookies...topped with frosting and sprinkles-all the taste of a thick and soft sugar cut-out cookie but in a pretty little drop cookie form.

Butterscotch Walnut Bars...soft, chewy and full of butterscotch goodness!


This Week's Flavors!

Milk Dud Brownies

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Sugar Cookie Bars

Andes Mint Cookies

Cinnamon Roll Cookies


We have homemade popcorn balls in the shop! They are only $2 each!

Pick some up during retail hours or call/text/send a Facebook message to order yours for Christmas!!!



Happy Thanksgiving!

We are closed Today and Tomorrow for the holiday. We will reopen for small business Saturday the 30th from 10-2.

I am thankful for each and everyone of you. You are the reason that I am able to make my dream come true!

Have a great turkey day!


This week's flavors!

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Italian Wedding Cookies...a delicous and delicate pecan cookie rolled in powder sugar. I ate 5 yesterday!

Peanut Butter Blossoms...the kid in me needed these this week. :-)

Pecan Pie Bars

Andes Mountain Brownies


We will be starting our winter hours this week. That means we will not be open on Wednesday.

We are open Thursday and Friday 12-6 and Saturday from 10-2.

Thanks everyone!


I can't believe it's Friday night and I haven't posted my flavors all week! That's just how busy we've been!

We had a great evening at Waters School tonight to help them do some fundraising!

Tomorrow we will be at Harley Davidson in Fond du Lac for a ladies day out even-come one down and check it out!

This week's flavors are:

Chocolate Chip Cookies


Vanilla Bean Sugar Cookies

Malted Milk Ball Brownies

and...Homemade Kit Kat Bars-back by request!

We are open 10-2 tomorrow. Stop on down and see us!


I understand we missed someone yesterday with having to be closed for a few hours. I am sincerely sorry we inconvenienced you. My understanding is Ashley came in very close to 4:30 so you must have just missed each other!

In order to show you how truly sorry I am please stop in this week for $10 worth of anything you like in the shop completely on me!

All you have to do is let me know what kind of receipt you left your note on to claim some free yummy goodies. Hope to see you soon!


It's Classics Week! This week's flavors are:

Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies

Ultimate Fudge Brownies

S'More Bars

Peanut Butter Reeses Pieces Cookies...these are so rich and full of peanut butter...I think I could eat a dozen in one sitting!

Oatmeal Raisin Cookies


We had a last minute opportunity to research some new products today! Due to this we will have limited hours and a limited selection today.

Things will be back to normal tomorrow however-S'More bars are on the schedule for this week-I know these are a HUGE favorite!!!

We are very sorry for this inconvenience-please feel free to contact me if you need anything at all.


Thank You, Joanne for you order celebrating Mike's 35th anniversary at Mid-States Aluminum

Thank You, Joanne for you order celebrating Mike's 35th anniversary at Mid-States Aluminum


I'm in the shop already so why jot open early? Come on down today and score $5 dozens on Chocolate Chip Cookies, Snickerdoodles, and Made From Scratch CAKE BATTER cookies!

Don't want to go out in the rain? We deliver!

Call/text 920-266-9650!!!

Timeline photos

Timeline photos

Saturday, November 30th is Small Business Saturday. Shop local in downtown Fond du Lac for the holidays. What small businesses in downtown are you most excited to shop at for the holidays?


This week's specials!

Homemade Samoa Bars...just like the cookie thise fabulous Girl Scouts sell...but in bar form! A rich shortbread crust, topped with caramel and toasted coconut and finished off with a chocolate drizzle.

Snickerdoodles...a soft and delicious cinnamon sugar cookie.

Shelly's Famous Chocolate Chip Cookies

Cake Batter Cookies...a homemade version of cake batter in cookie form. Buttery and licking the bowl!

Peanut Butter Stuffed Fudge signature fudge brownie stuffed to the brim with chocolate chips, chocolate chunks, and peanut butter cups!


$5 dozens on Cookies and B3G1 Free on bars and brownie pies until we close at 3!!!!! Get your treats now for your Halloween parties tonight! I can even deliver after close! :-)

Call or text 920-266-9650

Ashley insisted on taking my picture this morning...I know the kids don't start until 1:30 but I'm just too excited!  I ...

Ashley insisted on taking my picture this morning...I know the kids don't start until 1:30 but I'm just too excited! I had to dress up already!

Don't we all need a cookie?  ;-)

Don't we all need a cookie? ;-)

Happy Saturday! :)


It's Trick or Treat Day! It's Trick or Treat Day! It's Trick or Treat Day! :)

I really love seeing all of the kids have fun in their costumes while trick or treating...can't wait to see you all come down to the shop today! Downtown Trick or Treat from 1:30-3!

We've been selling out early every day so come on down this morning and get some last minute treats for your Halloween Parties this weekend. We are open 10-3 today!

Cookie dozens are only $6...and we have plenty of Cookie Dough Bars, and Brownie Pies to go around. Stop down early!

Monster Sugar Cookies

Monster Sugar Cookies

Cookie Dough Bars!

Cookie Dough Bars!

Brownie Pies

Brownie Pies


This week's specials!

Mini Brownie Pies...these brownies are more than twice the size of my normal brownies (and anyone who comes in the shop knows te are already HUGE)...they are filled with two different kinds of chocolate and then topped with mini chocolate chips, mini candy bars AND drizzled in chocoalte syrup! WARNING: This is not for the faint of heart...only true chocolate devotees are encouraged to take on this'll need a fork!

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Bars...yep, you read that right...cookie dough bars (eggless of course)!!! And then topped with a layer of chocolate. ;)

Peanut Butter Cup Bars...just like the candy but in bar form...gotta love some peanut butter!

Caramel Ginger Snaps...your classic soft ginger snap cookie filled with caramel!

Shelly's Famous Chocolate Chip Cookies...better buy a dozen, like the potato chips you can't eat just one!

Also Monster Eye Sugar Cookies! Just in time for Halloween! I took my classic vanilla bean sugar cookie and turned it into a one-eyed monster. :)

Come on downtown this Saturday for Trick or Treat!    We'll be passing out candy to all of the little ghouls and goblins...

Come on downtown this Saturday for Trick or Treat! We'll be passing out candy to all of the little ghouls and goblins!

Monster March is only a little over a week away! Kids and adults in costume are invited to trick-or-treat on Main Street in downtown. Make sure to stop at Main Street Plaza for music, games, and a special Farmers Market!

Happy Birthday Grace!  Enjoy your jumbo cookie!  :-)

Happy Birthday Grace! Enjoy your jumbo cookie! :-)

Homemade Butterfinger Bars!

Homemade Butterfinger Bars!

Cupcake Shop Mascot!!!  :-)

Cupcake Shop Mascot!!! :-)

Fresh Banana Walnut Muffins...still warm!  Perfect for a snack on a cold fall day!

Fresh Banana Walnut Muffins...still warm! Perfect for a snack on a cold fall day!

Happy Birthday Tim Bertram!  :-)

Happy Birthday Tim Bertram! :-)


This Week's Specials!

Homemade Butterfinger Bars...I'm really running with the candy bar theme for me some Butterfingers!

Pumpkin Caramel Cookies...a super soft pumpkin cookie with a homemade caramel frosting.

Candy Surprise Stuffed Cookies...these are stuffed with all of your favorite candies! Today I have Kit-Kat stuffed, then Snickers, Reeses Peanut Butter Cups and Milky Way! The cookies are then drizzled in chocolate!

Chocolate Chip Cookies...a regular favorite!

Cheesecake Swirl Brownies...I haven't made these in a couple of months since Ashley started making her delicious cheesecakes! However so many of you asked for them I decided to make them this week!

And mini loaves of Banana Walnut Bread...I'll have them fresh in the shop this afternoon!


You guys talked me into it!

This week's specials are still running!

$5 dozens on cookies and Buy 5 Get 1 FREE on the homemade Twix Bars and Buckeye Brownies!!!

Get here early...we will sell out fast!


Today's Special: Buy 5 Get 1 FREE on brownies and bars!

We have Homemade Twix Bars and Buckeye Brownies in the shop today!!!

Also...I'm trying out a recipe for Homemade Butterfingers...come on in the shop and see what I come up with...I'm really enjoying this candy bar theme for the month of October!

Buckeye dense it's almost a fudge bar!  Who doesn't love peanut butter and chocolate???

Buckeye dense it's almost a fudge bar! Who doesn't love peanut butter and chocolate???


$5 dozens on cookies today!!!! Choose from Pumpkin Pudding Snickerdoodles, Chewy Chocolate Chip, or Iced Oatmeal!


29 N Main St
Fond Du Lac, WI


(920) 266-9650


Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Shelly's Cookie Jar posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Shelly's Cookie Jar:


Nearby bakeries

Other Bakeries in Fond du Lac

Show All