The Sugar Cookie Fairy

The Sugar Cookie Fairy Local cottage baker baking up luxury custom cookies in Felton, CA! Hi, I'm Polly! A local Felton, CA mom of 2, and baking enthusiast.

Contact The Sugar Cookie Fairy for custom sugar cookies, cakes, and cupcakes – I’d love to whip up something delicious for your next event - birthdays, showers, and gift boxes! I create custom sugar cookies by hand from start to finish. I also create delicious custom cakes and cupcakes. I started my business during the pandemic in 2020, and fell in love with the art of sugar cookie decorating (and now cakes and cupcakes, too!). I'm open for custom orders, please email me to connect.

Rest in peace to the wonderful Catherine O’Hara ❤️ thank you for all the joy you gave to the world
02/11/2026

Rest in peace to the wonderful Catherine O’Hara ❤️ thank you for all the joy you gave to the world

Grab a slice before they’re gone 🍰 🍪
02/02/2025

Grab a slice before they’re gone 🍰 🍪

Taking a social media break, but you can now find my baked goods like cupcakes and layer cakes at in Scott’s Valley! ...
01/23/2025

Taking a social media break, but you can now find my baked goods like cupcakes and layer cakes at in Scott’s Valley!

Come celebrate Mother's Day with a fun cookie decorating class! Everyone welcome ages 5+! Hosted by Bruno's Bar and Gril...
05/01/2024

Come celebrate Mother's Day with a fun cookie decorating class! Everyone welcome ages 5+! Hosted by Bruno's Bar and Grill in Scott's Valley, you can register here:
https://form.jotform.com/240496952983169

Hey fabulous friends! 🌟 Time's ticking away faster than my oven preheating for these delightful treats! 🍪🏈 Whether you'r...
02/06/2024

Hey fabulous friends! 🌟 Time's ticking away faster than my oven preheating for these delightful treats! 🍪🏈 Whether you're scoring touchdowns in love or just cheering for your favorite team, I've got the perfect goodies for you!

Classroom minis, DIY kits for the littles (and littles at heart) and even floral buttercream cupcakes💐🧁 I'm diving into the baking bonanza tomorrow, so get those orders in by:

TOMORROW, noon, Tuesday the 6th! 🗓️

Order from a local mama baker, and let's make this Valentine's and Super Bowl combo the sweetest yet! 🥰🏆
https://form.jotform.com/240155950755156

Support a local small business, and pre-order your Valentine's and Super Bowl cookies today! https://www.thesugarcookief...
01/21/2024

Support a local small business, and pre-order your Valentine's and Super Bowl cookies today!

https://www.thesugarcookiefairy.com/shop

Thanks to you all, and stay warm on this rainy day!
*Lots more options available via the shop*

In my bestie era with this friendship bracelet Valentine cookie 💗 💎 💃
01/17/2024

In my bestie era with this friendship bracelet Valentine cookie 💗 💎 💃

Address

Felton, CA

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Sugar Cookie Fairy posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Sugar Cookie Fairy:

Shortcuts

Share

Category