Carmella's Custom Bakery

02/09/2026

Is it ever NOT pumpkin season?! 😍

Pumpkin Cinnamon Cookies with Cream Cheese Frosting 🍪

11/30/2025

Hi everyone!
I wanted to let you know that I will be unable to offer holiday cookie trays this year due to an upcoming surgery. In the meantime, I’m pleased to recommend a talented local baker, Baker's Sweet Treats, who can assist with your holiday baking needs for this season. Thank you for your continued support and understanding. 🎄🎅🤶

10/09/2025

This was my largest single order of sugar cookies yet 😅

09/22/2025

Some of this weekends order 🎉🎂

07/26/2025

Today's order themes were a bit different from each other 😂🎄🥊

07/16/2025

2 options for Back to School cookie sets 👩‍🏫🎒🚸 As a former teacher, I can vouch that teachers would love a set to get through the first week 😅

$8 per set

Orders due by August 12
Pickups start August 18

07/15/2025

I've posted a lot less lately, but I've still been busy over here!

I will be taking limited orders while I begin some new educational endeavors personally, so if you're planning to do something crazy (baby shower, bridal shower, wedding) -- get your order in early to secure your spot!

I'll still have Halloween, Thanksgiving, and Christmas sets along with Christmas trays.

Maybe even a back to school set 🫣

12/31/2024

I'm not saying I had favorite students... but I wouldn't take a baby shower cookie order for just anyone for the days right after Christmas 😅❤️

Thankful for this new life! 🙌

12/13/2024

Thanks for all the love this year! I have more orders that I should probably handle, so that's all for now folks. I'll post extra trays for pickup on the 24th if I have any! 🎄🎁🍪

If you ordered, I'll be in touch this weekend about pickup days, times, and $$.

12/07/2024

🎅 *still taking pre-orders* 🍪

Delivery dates::
SALEM- Saturday, Dec 21
EL / CALCUTTA - Sunday, Dec 22
LISBON- Sunday, Dec 22
COLUMBIANA- Monday, Dec 23

Pickups in EP are free anytime! Orders are pickup only on December 24 since I'll be getting ready for our party🎄

12/07/2024

I got a new display box for my cookies 😍 Merry Christmas to me 🎄🎁

12/04/2024

Excited to be baking for this event! 🎉❤️ I'll have single serve items and take home trays to save for the holidays (or not.. I won't judge)🎄
Indigo Family Theater

The countdown to holiday magic has begun! Only 3 days until “An Impromptu Christmas Carol“ hits the stage in Columbiana, Ohio. Don’t miss out! Get your tickets today. Tickets are also available at the door.

⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️

https://indigo.ludus.com/index.php?show_id=200462839