Made by Sarah

Made by Sarah Hi i’m Sarah, I love baking sweet treats and decorating cakes. Custom orders welcome 🧁

Decided to do some last minute baking for the Clark Racing & Ayers Motorsports race party today! 🍰All of my best selling...
03/07/2026

Decided to do some last minute baking for the Clark Racing & Ayers Motorsports race party today! 🍰

All of my best selling mini cake flavors 😋 Stop by & grab one with a dinner purchase 😊

Loving the color swirl cupcakes! This was my last order for a bit as we prepare for baby girls arrival soon 😄
02/22/2026

Loving the color swirl cupcakes! This was my last order for a bit as we prepare for baby girls arrival soon 😄

5 dozen pumpkin cupcakes with cinnamon cc frosting for Paige’s baby shower 😋
01/11/2026

5 dozen pumpkin cupcakes with cinnamon cc frosting for Paige’s baby shower 😋

Trivia Time!!For a chance to win a FREE box of assorted cookies, you must be following / like my page, and then answer t...
12/21/2025

Trivia Time!!
For a chance to win a FREE box of assorted cookies, you must be following / like my page, and then answer the following 3 questions… Whoever answers them all right, or has the most correct answers first- wins, keep in mind you must pick the cookies up TODAY between 1-8pm if you win! ☺️

What was the very first cookie flavor I baked today?
A. Sugar Cookie
B. Snickerdoodle
C. Ginger Crinkles
D. Peanut Butter Blossoms

How many cups of butter did I use today?
A. 10 cups
B. 12 cups
C. 14 cups
D. 16 cups

How many cookies did I bake in total today?
A. 468
B. 500
C. 504
D. 482

12/21/2025

Hi everyone! 🎄
If you purchased a variety pack Christmas cookie box, they will be ready for pickup tomorrow between 1:00 PM and 8:00 PM.

Please message me to let me know what time you plan to stop by so I can make sure I’m around for pickup. Thank you all so much again for your orders and support—I can’t wait for you to enjoy them! 🍪

I have 5 more boxes available, let me know if you’re interested!
12/12/2025

I have 5 more boxes available, let me know if you’re interested!

Christmas Cookie Packs! 🎄

I’m offering 15 Christmas cookie packs this year!

Each pack includes 6 flavors and a total of 24 cookies for $20.

✨ Only 15 packs available — once they’re gone, they’re gone!
If you’d like to claim one, please comment below to reserve your spot.

All orders will be ready for pickup on December 21st. Payment is due by December 18th 🎅🏼🍪

Pie Please 🥧🤤
11/27/2025

Pie Please 🥧🤤

Happy Thanksgiving everyone! ☺️🦃
11/27/2025

Happy Thanksgiving everyone! ☺️🦃

Christmas Cookie Packs! 🎄 I’m offering 15 Christmas cookie packs this year!Each pack includes 6 flavors and a total of 2...
11/25/2025

Christmas Cookie Packs! 🎄

I’m offering 15 Christmas cookie packs this year!

Each pack includes 6 flavors and a total of 24 cookies for $20.

✨ Only 15 packs available — once they’re gone, they’re gone!
If you’d like to claim one, please comment below to reserve your spot.

All orders will be ready for pickup on December 21st. Payment is due by December 18th 🎅🏼🍪

Trivia Time!!For a chance to win a FREE box of assorted cookies, you must be following / like my page, and then answer t...
11/22/2025

Trivia Time!!
For a chance to win a FREE box of assorted cookies, you must be following / like my page, and then answer the following 3 questions… Whoever answers them all right, or has the most correct answers first- wins, keep in mind you must pick the cookies up by Sunday if you win! 😊🍪

HINT: I made a total of 302 cookies!

1. How many cups of flour did it take to make all of the cookies in the picture below?
A. 19 cups
B. 25 cups
C. 28 cups

2. How many hours did I spend baking and putting boxes together for all of these cookies?
A. 13 hours
B. 12 hours
C. 14 hours

3. How many times did I burn my fingers while baking cookies today?
A. Three
B. Five
C. Once

Address

Dundee, NY

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Made by Sarah posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share

Category