Toni Makes Cakes & more

12/14/2025

Update- I have only 3 more available. Get your cookie boxes order in by December 15. Click the link to fill in the order form. https://forms.gle/At8XWA7zTNEKFCQU9

12/10/2025

Order your Christmas cookie box today. Deadline is Dec. 15. Click the link in the image for the order form.

12/06/2025

It’s time to order your cookie trays and gifts. Click the link to order. Limited quantities available. Order deadline is December 15. Pickup in Westerville.

https://forms.gle/vcNW6TDSGa46mymb7

09/12/2025

I haven’t posted in a while and have so many great photos to share so here’s the start of them.

12/25/2024

Merry Christmas everyone!

12/19/2024

Today is the last day to place your Christmas cookie box order (limited quantities available). Small boxes (up to 25 cookies) are $45, large boxes (up to 55 cookies) are $75. Cookies included:
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Soft Sugar Cookie Snowmen
Gingerbreadmen Faces
Oatmeal Creme Pies
Snowballs*
Italian Anise
Sugar Cookie Trees
Sugar Cookie Ornaments
Peanut Butter Blossoms*
Butter Cookies
Linzer Tart with Raspberry Jam
Pecan Pie Bars*
Eggnog Snowflakes*
Italian Flags*
*includes nuts
Order at www.tonimakescakes.com or fill out this form - https://forms.gle/LdDKkygypd4pAnSW7

bakery, bakery near me, cookies, holiday cookies, sugar cookies, chocolate chip cookies, cakes, cakes near me, birthday, anniversary, wedding, baby, baby shower, wedding shower, shower, office, party, graduation, communion, confirmation, family birthday, local cake, cake near me, homebaker, hot choc...

12/08/2024

Had a great turnout at my event yesterday but have some items left. Selling at a reduced price TODAY ONLY, Sunday, Dec. 8. These are first come-first served. I will only receive your order via private message and not through comments. Payment in full to secure order via Venmo. Pickup in Westerville today between 4-6 pm or Tuesday between 6-8 pm.
See photos for designs. Full list and prices below:

Snowflakes (eggnog) 6-piece - only 4 left - $10 each set
Christmas Lights (sugar) 3-piece - only 3 left - $3 each set
Chocolate Chip Chrunchers 4-pack - $4 each pack
Cookie Sticks (chocolate) 4-pack - $4 each pack
Italian 7-layer (almond) - only 3 left - $4 each pack

Individually packed cupcakes - $3 each
Dark chocolate caramel - 6 left
Cookies and cream - 5 left
White with raspberry- 10 left
Red velvet - 11 left
Funfetti - 10 left

Place an order at regular price at www.tonimakescakes.com.

11/23/2024

It’s time to order your cookies and cookie trays for Christmas! 🎅🏼 Visit www.tonimakescakes.com and click the link to fill out the form.

11/19/2024

Some fun cakes from the last couple of months. I love the ideas my customers bring me!