Mae's Custom Cakes

Mae's Custom Cakes I bake custom cakes and cupcakes for any occasion. BIRTHDAYS, ANNIVERSARY'S, GRADUATION, BABY SHOWERS, BRIDAL SHOWERS, WEDDINGS. Owner: Amanda Waggoner

When ordering a cake please let me know the following:
Size (how many your serving)
Flavors. We can do half and half. Decorations. Design. What it should say on top! The day and time you need to pick up the cake! PERSONAL CHECKS ACCEPTED ONLY 2 WEEKS BEFORE CAKE PICK UP. MY PRODUCTS ARE HOME PRODUCED AND PROCESSED, AND THE PRODUCTION AREA HAS NOT BEEN INSPECTED BY THE STATE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH.

Operating as usual

Latest cake! Simple chocolate with chocolate frosting. 😊

Latest cake! Simple chocolate with chocolate frosting. 😊


As we get closer to Christmas season more of you are putting up all your trees.🌲 We would like to help you decorate them! We are going to start taking orders for salt dough ornaments. We bake them you decorate them! 👍 Great way to spend a little more quality time as a family and add a special touch with ornaments only you will have!! ❤️👨‍👩‍👧‍👦


I think it’s about time for a contest! So if you share my page then comment done on this post I will enter your name in a drawing for a free dozen cupcakes! Drawing will take place when we reach 600 likes! Only 31 away from the drawing!! Share away!!


Our November schedule is filling up pretty quickly. So don’t forget if your needing an order placed to get with me as soon as possible! Have a great day everyone!


Hello everyone! It’s been awhile but just making it known we are back at it and ready to take orders! Excited to get back in the kitchen baking lovely creations for everyone! 😊


It's wedding day!!


It's getting into Graduation🎓 and Wedding💍 season. I have been getting orders already. Please make sure to book ahead to assure your spot! 1st wedding of the year is April 2nd. So excited and can't wait! 😊


We are now fully booked for Feburary. Inquire for March soon. I'm filling up fast.


Oven is preheated, apron on, music playing, and my caking is in session! Vanilla, Strawberry, banana, and chocolate cakes in the works today!! :)


Good Morning everyone! Just a little heads up.....Facebook hasn't been notifying me when I get messages. I do my best at checking them regularly. I can also be reached via my personal page. Amanda Waggoner. Thank You!


2 cakes in the works this week! Gonna be a Paw Patrol and Star Wars week here! Last chance to submit an order for Valentine's Day is Wednesday!!


I am just sharing my calendar for February. I am fully booked the 1st weekend in February. I can fit 1 maybe 2 more orders for Valentine's Day. The third weekend I have 1spot available as well. I tend to fill up quickly so please consider placing no less than 2 weeks out.

Amanda :)



Allison Woolley is the winner of the cupcake bouquet! Thank You everyone for participating!


Today is the last day to be entered in the contest. Share my page and you are entered to win a cupcake bouquet!!! :)


22 likes away from 500!!! Thank You everyone! :)


31 new likes in the last 2 days! Thank you everyone for your shares!! :)


This post is not meant for anyone in particular. I've had several inquiries on this lately so I figured pinning to my page people can see it without me restating over and over. Here is why cakes cost what they cost.

Difference between a "Walmart" cake and custom cake.

This seems to be a question I receive a lot when quoting cakes for people. There are a ton of differences other than just price.

Store bakeries can charge less because the cakes they decorate, yes not bake, are baked in mass quantities and frozen and shipped to stores. Those cakes and cupcakes sit in a freezer until ordered then pulled out and decorated. The cake is filled with preservatives to keep it lasting a long time. They are decorated with icing from giant tubs that is brought into the store as well. These stores also pay multiple decorators to do the work. I'm not saying anything bad about these cake artist. They do a wonderful job as well.

Now a custom cake from a bakery. These cakes are actually baked to order. Nothing is frozen and thawed out. All icings and fondants are usually made from scratch as well. The cakes we make we put our full efforts, love, and attention in to make them absolutely perfect. We don't have multiple decorators, one, maybe two tops. Some of these cakes take up to 10+ hours of time to complete. So when adding a the total for a customer we add it ingredients, time, and skill level of our work. This is our way of making a living.

So please the next time you want to order a cake from us, remember all the time it takes to make one "simple" looking cake. Do not argue or talk us down on a price. We are not here to take all your money, we are here to give you the best cake we can and to keep our business running!


All us bakers out there :)


My daughter is selling Girl Scout cookies. If your interested message me your order. $4 a box money due upon delivery.


I only started booking for Valentine's Day yesterday, but I am already filling up. Make sure to assure your on my calendar to book quickly. Thank You to all my wonderful customers! :)


Our Special Valentine's Day Menu is uploaded. To find our menus, scroll down on Timeline to About section. There is a clickable link that will say menu. It will bring it up! Booking for Valentine's Day starting now. Unless otherwise stated in future I will except orders until Feb 11th. Order before we are booked! :)


Update for us. We are relocating. We will now be based out of North Vernon Indiana. Thank You to the loyal customers we had up here.


❤❤❤❤❤41 days until Valentines day....looking for sweet ideas for your special someone??? Keep an eye out on my page special Valentines Day offers will be posted tonight!!❤❤❤❤❤


New menu with prices is now posted. Im back and in the full swing of things. Need any type of cake, cupcakes, cake pops, marshmallow pops, chocolate bars, or anything let me know!


County Road
Columbus, IN




Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mae's Custom Cakes posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Mae's Custom Cakes:


Nearby bakeries

Other Bakeries in Columbus

Show All