12/21/2022
Cookies straight from Heaven☁️
Our Cloud Cookies are pecan shortbread cookies, lovingly handmade and finished with a generous amount of powdered sugar. Grab them by the dozen at your local shop!
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
- Home
- United States
- Colleyville, TX
- Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Colleyville, Texas bakes hand-made pies fresh, daily. We are the taste of Southern tradition!
Delivery available via Uber EATS and Door Dash. At Buttermilk Sky, it is our mission to connect the past and present through the Southern tradition of scratch-made pie. Whether you prefer the traditional slice of a pie, one of our delicious mini-pies, or you're an ice cream fan and love our heavenly Cloud 9, we hope that its sweet, wholesome goodness takes you back to some of your fondest memories. Online Ordering: https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/
Payment Options: Amex Cash Discover Mastercard Visa
Operating as usual
12/19/2022
"Good apple pies are a considerable part of our domestic happiness." ~ Jane Austen ❤️
Don't show up empty handed this holiday season... Give the gift of delicious pie.
12/16/2022
Become everyone's favorite houseguest in the blink of an eye... Simply arrive with Buttermilk Sky Pie! 🥧
* Check with your local shop for flavor availability. *
12/14/2022
Say hello to our Candy Cane Thumbprint Cookies and Candy Cane Cookie Cloud 9!
The season of candy cane is in full swing here at Buttermilk Sky Pie. Treat yourself to our Candy Cane Thumbprint Cookies or a Candy Cane Cloud 9 until December 31st.
12/12/2022
❤️ A little birdie told us that Santa prefers Thumbprint Cookies...
Plus, they're the perfect pop of color for your holiday season! Grab some at your local shop today.
12/09/2022
Indulge in peppermint goodness with our Candy Cane Thumbprint Cookies. These housemade shortbread cookies topped with crushed candy canes are pretty and delicious.
12/07/2022
A taste of the season in every bite...🎁 Our Candy Cane Cookie Cloud 9 combines our delicious holiday thumbprint cookies and a heaping scoop of ice cream blended to perfection. Don't miss out on this seasonal favorite!
12/05/2022
Share pie. Share love. Grab a dozen of our 4-inch pies & become the star of any holiday gathering. Visit our website to learn more about our mini pies.
12/02/2022
'Tis the season for gathering... That's why our pies are offered in 3 different sizes with flavors for any season! Grab goodies that are sure to please any crowd.
* Check with your local shop for flavor availability. *
11/30/2022
With less than one month until Christmas, it's officially the final countdown for shopping. Luckily, we've got you covered with the perfect gift for all ages. Give the gift of Pie for a Year. 🎄
11/28/2022
They're baacckk...❤️
Say hello to our Candy Cane Thumbprint Cookies. Available now until December 31st! Grab 'em while you can.
11/28/2022
They're baacckk...❤️
Say hello to our Candy Cane Thumbprint Cookies. Available now until December 31st! Grab 'em while you can.
11/26/2022
Great day to stop in for pie as you sit around the fireplace and sip some hot cocoa or coffee! We are open until 8PM
4712 Colleyville Blvd., #160
Colleyville, TX 76034
Colleyville Chamber of Commerce
11/25/2022
Our full menu is back, come in tonight after your busy day of Black Friday shopping! We are open until 8PM.
11/23/2022
We still have Pumpkin, Pecan and I-40 available for pick up. Walk-ins welcome, come see us at the tent outside. We close at 5 pm today!
11/23/2022
A toast to family traditions. Thanks for making us a part of yours!
11/23/2022
A toast to family traditions. Thanks for making us a part of yours!
11/21/2022
Come see us today at 4712 Colleyville Blvd., Ste. 160 Colleyville, TX 76034 today!
Thanksgiving orders for pickup 11/21-11/23 are available! Please choose from the Thanksgiving menu online
https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3/-b5a8-413e-b7b0-0611313b7a5cd086ba2f2-3feb-4113-b286-15464d3cbb0f
We will have imited 9” pie menu for 11/21-11/23
11/21/2022
🎃 LAST CALL FOR SPICED PUMPKIN 🎃
Get your Spiced Pumpkin fix this week before it's gone! The final day to enjoy this seasonal favorite (until 2023, of course) is November 26th. The season of Spiced Pumpkin may be coming to an end, but that means the season of Candy Canes has only just begun. Stay tuned.
11/21/2022
Forget to pre-order your pies for Thanksgiving Day? We will have walk in pies each day as supplies last. Monday and Tuesday 10-7 and Wednesday 10-5.
11/18/2022
Pro tip: Never show up empty handed. 📦
Hostess gifts are one area of gifting where it truly is the thought that counts. Bring a taste of southern tradition to your next event this holiday season.
11/18/2022
Pro tip: Never show up empty handed. 📦
Hostess gifts are one area of gifting where it truly is the thought that counts. Bring a taste of southern tradition to your next event this holiday season.
11/16/2022
Go back to the basics this Thanksgiving. Our Nanny's pecan pie is the one that put us on the map and speaks to tradition.
Share pie & share love this holiday season.
11/16/2022
Go back to the basics this Thanksgiving. Our Nanny's pecan pie is the one that put us on the map and speaks to tradition.
Share pie & share love this holiday season.
11/14/2022
We are thankful to be a part of your family traditions.
11/14/2022
We are thankful to be a part of your family traditions.
11/13/2022
Our chocolate cream pie is a menu favorite. Have you tried it yet?
11/11/2022
We only have pies for you. 👀 Check out this perfect mini pie spread photo from Instagram user !
🍏 Granny's Apple Pie
🎃 Spiced Pumpkin
🍫 Chewy Chocolate Chip
🥜 Nanny's Pecan
11/11/2022
We only have pies for you. 👀 Check out this perfect mini pie spread photo from !
🍏 Granny's Apple Pie
🎃 Spiced Pumpkin
🍫 Chewy Chocolate Chip
🥜 Nanny's Pecan
11/11/2022
On Veteran’s Day, and every day, we are THANKFUL to those who have served our country. ❤️🤍💙
11/10/2022
Visiting any little cutie pies for Thanksgiving? We’ve got the sweetest onesies! **check with your local shop for availability **
11/09/2022
Friendly reminder to pre-order your Thanksgiving pies! Order ahead, and we'll have your pies ready and waiting for you to pick them up.
Visit http://buttermilkskypie.com/order/ & pick your location to place your pick-up order.
11/09/2022
Friendly reminder to pre-order your Thanksgiving pies! Order ahead, and we'll have your pies ready and waiting for you to pick them up.
Visit http://buttermilkskypie.com/order/ & pick your location to place your pick-up order.
11/07/2022
Life is short. Take your morning coffee with a side of our Thumbprint Cookies. ☕️
11/07/2022
Life is short. Take your morning coffee with a side of our Thumbprint Cookies. ☕️
11/04/2022
Give the gift of pie this holiday season! Let our homemade desserts make gift-giving easy, memorable, and delicious with a gift card for your friends and family.
11/04/2022
Give the gift of pie this holiday season! Let our homemade desserts make gift-giving easy, memorable, and delicious with a gift card for your friends and family.
11/02/2022
On cloud 9 with our Cloud Cookies. ☁️ These pecan shortbread cookies are lovingly handmade and finished with a generous amount of powdered sugar. Packaged in a delicate layer of two dozen cookies per box, these treats are sure to please!
11/02/2022
On cloud 9 with our Cloud Cookies. ☁️ These pecan shortbread cookies are lovingly handmade and finished with a generous amount of powdered sugar. Packaged in a delicate layer of two dozen cookies per box, these treats are sure to please!
10/31/2022
No tricks over here, just treats! Here's to fun, festivities and FALL!🍁🥧
10/31/2022
No tricks over here, just treats! Here's to fun, festivities and FALL!🍁🥧
10/29/2022
Our NEW San Antonio pie shop hosted a Firefighter’s Pie eating contest as part of their Grand Opening celebration today. Stakes were high with a year of Pie on the table for the winner!
10/28/2022
The San Antonio Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop kicked off day 1 of Grand Opening fun today with lines outside the shop before 7 a.m.! More fun giveaways and pie eating contest tomorrow! Check out their page.
10/28/2022
Need a party treat that will put smiles on faces? Our 2" party pies are the perfect size to serve kids (big and little) 😌 Available in pre-assorted dozens only.
10/28/2022
Need a party treat that will put smiles on faces? Our 2" party pies are the perfect size to serve kids (big and little) 😊 Available in pre-assorted dozens only.
10/28/2022
Need a party treat that will put smiles on faces? Our 2" party pies are the perfect size to serve kids (big and little) 😊 Available in pre-assorted dozens only. Please pre-order online 24 hours in advance.
https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3/?mode=fulfillment
10/27/2022
Thanksgiving orders for pickup 11/21-11/23 are available! Please choose from the Thanksgiving menu online
https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3/-b5a8-413e-b7b0-0611313b7a5cd086ba2f2-3feb-4113-b286-15464d3cbb0f
We will have imited 9” pie menu for 11/21-11/23
10/26/2022
�Find your shop. Did you know that we have 19 (and counting) shops across 7 states? We invite you to join us in sharing the love of pie across the country. Bring the Taste of Southern Tradition to your community by opening your own Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop.
10/26/2022
�Find your shop. Did you know that we have 19 (and counting) shops across 7 states? We invite you to join us in sharing the love of pie across the country. Bring the Taste of Southern Tradition to your community by opening your own Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop.
10/24/2022
A batch made in heaven... Have you tried our Pumpkin Spice Thumbprint Cookies yet?
These delicious shortbread thumbprints topped with a dollop of pumpkin spice icing are definitely a seasonal favorite. Grab them while you can!
Address
4712 Colleyville Boulevard , #160
Colleyville, TX
76034
Opening Hours
| Monday | 10am - 7pm |
| Tuesday | 10am - 7pm |
| Wednesday | 10am - 7pm |
| Thursday | 10am - 7pm |
| Friday | 10am - 8pm |
| Saturday | 10am - 8pm |
Telephone
Products
9” Pies, 4” Pies, 4” Pies(box of 4), 4” Pies (Box of 12), cookies (single or by the dozen), cloud 9, coffee packages and t-shirts!
Alerts
Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Contact The Business
Send a message to Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop:
Videos
Named for Interstate 40, this pie connects people and hearts. It's a twist on pecan pie and our best-seller. We fill the bottom of our signature shortbread crust with pecans and shredded coconut, pour on velvety pecan pie filling, top it off with chocolate chips, and then they're ready to be baked to perfection. Watch to see all stages!
July is National Ice Cream Month AND National Blueberry Month. How about Blueberry Pie ala mode? Order Online: https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/
The only thing yummier than our Caramel Turtle Pie is our Caramel Turtle Pie with Ice Cream! Order your own Caramel Turtle Pie today! https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/
July is National Ice Cream Month AND National Blueberry Month. How about Blueberry Pie ala mode? https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3
Father's Day is coming - to a house near you.
Y’all, we got a new sign and we’re so excited!! #SharePieShareLove #PieSign #FreshSignFreshPies #NeighborhoodPieShop
Makin' Thumbprint Cookies
Have you had our thumbprint cookies? We're baking them fresh just for you!
Shortbread Leaves
Dropping sugar like it's rain from heaven!
I-40
Stress cannot exist in the presence of a pie. Come get yours and your stress will melt away. #SharePieShareLove #DFW #Colleyville
Thumbprint icing
Icing Mondays. I love my job. It smells good. #thumbprintcookie #icingmovie #makesmells #yum #cookiebite #dessert #buttermilkskypie
Southern Buttermilk Pie
Handmade Mini Pies. Wanna bite? #dessert #food #desserts #buttermilkskypie #piepic #lovepie #instagood #instafood #sweet #delish #foods #delicious #tasty #eat #eating #hungry #foodpics #sweettooth
Monday Morning
We are putting out the pies this Monday morning. They are going fast! #pie #tagafriend #piesforthewin #coffeelovespie #desserts #cleanplateclub #southernpies #piecrust #yesplease #foodlove #yummy #foodie #craving
Coconut Cream
Freshly baked pies every day. It's Monday. Where are you? #smellovision #video #makepies #lovepies #desserts #piesforthewin #reviewus
Thumbprint Cookies
These soft, melt-in-your-mouth cookies are the perfect sweet indulgence when you just want a bite. #boomerang #buttermilkskypie #famouscookies #cookiemovie #sweet
Shortcuts
Category
Nearby bakeries
-
Cheek-Sparger Road S
-
Colleyville Boulevard
-
Bremen, Hurst
-
Cumberland Drive, Hurst
-
Argentina's Sweet & Salty Bakery
Harwood Road/Suite B, Bedford -
Fair Oaks Boulevard, Euless
-
Frosted Garden Sugar Studio and Bakery
Fort Worth 76244 -
W Harwood Road, Hurst
-
Central Drive, Bedford
-
Circleview Drive S, Hurst
-
Fort Worth
-
Fort Worth 76036
-
Bedford 76021
-
Tanglewood Area, Fort Worth
Other Bakeries in Colleyville
-
Colleyville Boulevard -
Cheek-Sparger Road S
-
Shadow Ridge Drive
Comments
Due to the GENEROUS support of our wonderful Bransford families during Laps for Learning, the BES PTA was able to purchase:
🥧 72 mini pies and thumbprint cookies from Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
☕️ Coffee from Einstein Bros. Bagels
and Swiss Miss k-cup pods for ALL of our amazing staff! 🤍💙❤️
Have a safe & Happy Thanksgiving, y’all! 🍂
🥧 72 mini pies and thumbprint cookies from Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
☕️ Coffee from Einstein Bros. Bagels
and Swiss Miss k-cup pods for ALL of our amazing staff! 🤍💙❤️
Have a safe & Happy Thanksgiving, y’all! 🍂
Hi, I am with Town Hall.
We are preparing a Welcome Kit for new residents that are moving into your community.
Our Welcome Kit can only feature one Bakery and I would like to discuss your being the exclusive Bakery for your communities’ new residents.
I would like to schedule a time when you are expecting me so that I may drop off a sample of our "Welcome Kit" and explain the program in greater detail.
Please message me or for immediate assistance, feel free to call or text me on my cell which is listed below.
Thanks.
Medley Regan
817-706-5851
We are preparing a Welcome Kit for new residents that are moving into your community.
Our Welcome Kit can only feature one Bakery and I would like to discuss your being the exclusive Bakery for your communities’ new residents.
I would like to schedule a time when you are expecting me so that I may drop off a sample of our "Welcome Kit" and explain the program in greater detail.
Please message me or for immediate assistance, feel free to call or text me on my cell which is listed below.
Thanks.
Medley Regan
817-706-5851
Thank you to all of our incredible non profits who were featured at today’s October Luncheon and Non-Profit Showcase! Thank you Jason Ridley Agency - and DeWayne Smart/Smart Realty Texas Realtor for sponsoring this great event! Thank you to John Fletcher for donating $1,000 to donor winner Catholic Charities Diocese of Fort Worth, Inc.!!! Thank you Jasonand DeWayne for gifting another $1,000 to drawing winner GRACE Grapevine!!! WHAT A DAY!!!!
Thank you Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop and MOOYAH Burgers, Fries & Shakes for the cookies and lunch! Thank you Crown of Life Lutheran Church for hosting us so well!!
Thank you Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop and MOOYAH Burgers, Fries & Shakes for the cookies and lunch! Thank you Crown of Life Lutheran Church for hosting us so well!!
We are so excited for this new chapter for Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop!
Possibly our new favorite in colleyville thank yall
Hope for great success for your family
[email protected]
Hope for great success for your family
[email protected]
We heard that Sheila, the new owner of Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop was passing out samples in the school car line! Love the kindness she is spreading today! Sheila you are DINO-MITE! ❤🦖👏👏👏
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop City of Colleyville Government Colleyville Eats and More Colleyville Eats
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop City of Colleyville Government Colleyville Eats and More Colleyville Eats
Pie It Forward
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop has named their special Pie It Forward flavor for July is PEACH benefitting Teen Life!
Teen Life equips, encourages, and empowers teenagers to face life's challenges through Social Groups on school campuses. Teen Life serves Middle School students, High School students, and student-aged parents in need of social-emotional support.
Help Buttermilk Sky Pie give back to the community while enjoying this month’s special pie. Order yours using the link below:
https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3/?mode=fulfillment
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop has named their special Pie It Forward flavor for July is PEACH benefitting Teen Life!
Teen Life equips, encourages, and empowers teenagers to face life's challenges through Social Groups on school campuses. Teen Life serves Middle School students, High School students, and student-aged parents in need of social-emotional support.
Help Buttermilk Sky Pie give back to the community while enjoying this month’s special pie. Order yours using the link below:
https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3/?mode=fulfillment
We cannot wait to see you tomorrow!
Thank you so much to our Sponsors!
Co Title
Texas Health and Jason Ridley Agency - Independent Insurance Agent
Spotlight Sponsors:
City of Colleyville
Allen Wealth Advisors
Atmos Energy
Coca-Cola Southwest Beverages
Community Impact Grapevine / Colleyville / Southlake
Community Waste Disposal
PROCO Roofing and Construction
Frost Bank
Market Street
Oncor Electric Delivery
DeWayne Smart/Smart Realty Texas Realtor
Texas Health Harris Methodist Hospital Southlake, Texas
Texas Oncology
In-Kind Sponsors
All About Recognition
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
Colleyville Florist
Haltom's Jewelers
Minuteman Press
THANK YOU!!!!!
Thank you so much to our Sponsors!
Co Title
Texas Health and Jason Ridley Agency - Independent Insurance Agent
Spotlight Sponsors:
City of Colleyville
Allen Wealth Advisors
Atmos Energy
Coca-Cola Southwest Beverages
Community Impact Grapevine / Colleyville / Southlake
Community Waste Disposal
PROCO Roofing and Construction
Frost Bank
Market Street
Oncor Electric Delivery
DeWayne Smart/Smart Realty Texas Realtor
Texas Health Harris Methodist Hospital Southlake, Texas
Texas Oncology
In-Kind Sponsors
All About Recognition
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
Colleyville Florist
Haltom's Jewelers
Minuteman Press
THANK YOU!!!!!
Give The Gift Of YUM!
Don’t arrive empty-handed. Give the gift everyone LOVES . . . PIE!
Order yours below from the Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop:
https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3
Don’t arrive empty-handed. Give the gift everyone LOVES . . . PIE!
Order yours below from the Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop:
https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3
Thank you for all that you do for our local Veterans! The month of November we can't thank you enough for working with Texas Veterans Outdoors and each one of the local Veterans that they support.
You asked where the dessert was coming from, and you waited long enough ....If you registered for the luncheon today, (you still have time) you not only will have the best from Loveria Caffe ...you will also have the best from the best pie shop around, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop !!!
Go, like their page!!!
https://business.colleyvillechamber.org/events/details/2020-august-monthly-luncheon-21767
Go, like their page!!!
https://business.colleyvillechamber.org/events/details/2020-august-monthly-luncheon-21767
Join us today as we visit Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop to take in their rare Peach Pie! Each Peach Pie sold between now and Mid-August goes to support Veterans!!!