Clicky

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Colleyville, Texas bakes hand-made pies fresh, daily. We are the taste of Southern tradition!
(140)

Delivery available via Uber EATS and Door Dash. At Buttermilk Sky, it is our mission to connect the past and present through the Southern tradition of scratch-made pie. Whether you prefer the traditional full size pie, a delicious mini-pie, or you're an ice cream fan and love our heavenly Cloud 9, we hope that it’s sweet, wholesome goodness takes you back to some of your fondest memories. Online Ordering: https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/

Payment Options:   Amex Cash Discover Mastercard Visa

Operating as usual

Paradise in the palm of your hand 🌞Pickup a Key Lime Pie today Tag someone who needs a vacation 👇
06/05/2023

Paradise in the palm of your hand 🌞
Pickup a Key Lime Pie today
Tag someone who needs a vacation 👇

Sweet as… well… (strawberry) pie 🥧Stop by and try our seasonal Strawberry Pie 🍓 Available now through 6/10Tag the sweete...
06/02/2023

Sweet as… well… (strawberry) pie 🥧
Stop by and try our seasonal Strawberry Pie 🍓
Available now through 6/10
Tag the sweetest person in your life 👇

06/01/2023
Nanny's Pecan pie.mp4

Grandma won’t let you go hungry 👵
And neither will we 🥧
Grab a taste of Nanny’s Pecan Pie. This southern classic is available in 9” and 4” sizes.
Tag classic pie lover 👇

05/26/2023

Red, white, and blue never looked so tasty 🇺🇸
Kickstart summer with something sweet!
Tag everyone joining your weekend festivities below👇

Sweeter by the dozen 😋Stop by and pick up a dozen of our 2” pies today. Tag someone who needs something sweet 👇
05/25/2023

Sweeter by the dozen 😋
Stop by and pick up a dozen of our 2” pies today.
Tag someone who needs something sweet 👇

The simplest things in life are the sweetest 😋Get our Southern Custard Pie shipped straight from our kitchen to yours. O...
05/22/2023

The simplest things in life are the sweetest 😋
Get our Southern Custard Pie shipped straight from our kitchen to yours.
Order now at link in bio.

05/19/2023

Our new Cloud 9’s are bananas 🍌
Stop by and try one today.
Tag someone who drives you bananas 👇

The weekend forecast? Cloudy with a chance of delicious ☁️🤤Order two dozen of our Cloud Cookies at link in bio 🍪
05/17/2023

The weekend forecast? Cloudy with a chance of delicious ☁️🤤

Order two dozen of our Cloud Cookies at link in bio 🍪

Gooey 🫠 Chewy 🤤 Delicious 😋 Celebrate National Chocolate Chip Day with our Chewy Chocolate Chip Pie 🍫Order now at link i...
05/15/2023

Gooey 🫠 Chewy 🤤 Delicious 😋

Celebrate National Chocolate Chip Day with our Chewy Chocolate Chip Pie 🍫

Order now at link in bio.

You don’t need a special occasion to enjoy a classic apple pie 🥧 But they made one anyways 😋Celebrate National Apple Pie...
05/13/2023

You don’t need a special occasion to enjoy a classic apple pie 🥧 But they made one anyways 😋

Celebrate National Apple Pie Day with us 🍏

Order now at link in bio.

Looking forward to our time on the Huckabee Show and making Granny’s Apple Pie for National Apple Pie Day tomorrow! 🍏
05/12/2023

Looking forward to our time on the Huckabee Show and making Granny’s Apple Pie for National Apple Pie Day tomorrow! 🍏

Nothing says ‘Thank You Mom’ like our sweet treats 🥧Celebrate Mother’s Day this weekend with some Buttermilk Sky.Order n...
05/12/2023

Nothing says ‘Thank You Mom’ like our sweet treats 🥧

Celebrate Mother’s Day this weekend with some Buttermilk Sky.

Order now at link in bio.

05/11/2023

They put in the work 🎓 Now it’s time they taste the reward 🥧
Add some Buttermilk Sky to your graduation spread.
Tag your graduate 👇

Rich 😋 Creamy🍦 With a hint of paradise 🌴Celebrate Coconut Cream Pie Day by picking up one of your own 🥥
05/08/2023

Rich 😋 Creamy🍦 With a hint of paradise 🌴

Celebrate Coconut Cream Pie Day by picking up one of your own 🥥

Pie or cookies, you can't go wrong! Don't forget about a pie for Mom.
05/08/2023

Pie or cookies, you can't go wrong! Don't forget about a pie for Mom.

What happens when you tell AI about our Seasonal Strawberry Cloud 9? ✨🍓Something magical 🍓✨Swipe to see the Cloud 9 in r...
05/04/2023

What happens when you tell AI about our Seasonal Strawberry Cloud 9? ✨🍓Something magical 🍓✨
Swipe to see the Cloud 9 in real life 👉

05/02/2023

Small package 📦 Big flavor 🤤

Tag someone who needs to refill their cookie jar 👇

Peanut Butter 🤝 Chocolate 🤝 Oreo CrustThree great tastes. One classic pie 🥧Chocolate or peanut butter? Comment your choi...
04/28/2023

Peanut Butter 🤝 Chocolate 🤝 Oreo Crust
Three great tastes. One classic pie 🥧
Chocolate or peanut butter? Comment your choice 👇

04/26/2023

🍫📣 Calling all chocoholics 📣🍫
Stop by and try our indulgent Chocolate Cream Pies today 🥧
Tag a chocoholic to let them know👇

🍓 Our fresh pick 🍓Introducing our Seasonal Strawberry Pie.🧈 Buttery, crumbly shortbread crust 🥧 Sweet, juicy strawberry ...
04/24/2023

🍓 Our fresh pick 🍓
Introducing our Seasonal Strawberry Pie.
🧈 Buttery, crumbly shortbread crust
🥧 Sweet, juicy strawberry filling
🧁 Light, fluffy cream cheese whip
Tag someone who loves all things strawberry 👇

Strawberry is here! We fill our shortbread crust with plenty of strawberries that have set up perfectly into a sweet hom...
04/24/2023

Strawberry is here! We fill our shortbread crust with plenty of strawberries that have set up perfectly into a sweet homemade filling. We top it off with a generous portion of our cream cheese whipped cream topping. Try it in a Cloud 9 or thumbprint cookies.
https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3

Rich. Creamy. Silky smooth.We’re going crazy for coconut 🤪🥥Stop by and try our Coconut Cream Pie today. Available in 9” ...
04/21/2023

Rich. Creamy. Silky smooth.
We’re going crazy for coconut 🤪🥥
Stop by and try our Coconut Cream Pie today. Available in 9” and 4” sizes.
Tag a coconut lover 👇

Stop by and pick up your favorite munchies 🤤Double tap if you’re baking today 💚
04/20/2023

Stop by and pick up your favorite munchies 🤤
Double tap if you’re baking today 💚

Why do we love the I-40 Pie? Because it piles on the flavor 🥧Tag someone who needs to step up their dessert game 👇
04/14/2023

Why do we love the I-40 Pie? Because it piles on the flavor 🥧
Tag someone who needs to step up their dessert game 👇

Add a little sunshine to your day with this refreshing blend of tangy citrus and sweet creamy filling in our buttery gra...
04/14/2023

Add a little sunshine to your day with this refreshing blend of tangy citrus and sweet creamy filling in our buttery graham cracker crust topped with whipped cream cheese!
Saturday, April 22nd is the last day for Lemon Icebox pie...make sure you order today!
https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3

Address

4712 Colleyville Boulevard , #160
Colleyville, TX
76034

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 7pm
Tuesday 10am - 7pm
Wednesday 10am - 7pm
Thursday 10am - 7pm
Friday 10am - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 8pm

Telephone

(817) 581-7437

Website

Products

9” Pies, 4” Pies, 4” Pies(stack of 4), 4” Pies (dozen tote), thumbprint cookies (single or by the dozen), cloud cookies (two dozen), cloud 9, coffee packages and t-shirts!

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop:

Videos

Named for Interstate 40, this pie connects people and hearts. It's a twist on pecan pie and our best-seller. We fill the bottom of our signature shortbread crust with pecans and shredded coconut, pour on velvety pecan pie filling, top it off with chocolate chips, and then they're ready to be baked to perfection. Watch to see all stages!

July is National Ice Cream Month AND National Blueberry Month. How about Blueberry Pie ala mode? Order Online: https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/

The only thing yummier than our Caramel Turtle Pie is our Caramel Turtle Pie with Ice Cream! Order your own Caramel Turtle Pie today! https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/

July is National Ice Cream Month AND National Blueberry Month. How about Blueberry Pie ala mode? https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3

Father's Day is coming - to a house near you.

Y’all, we got a new sign and we’re so excited!! #SharePieShareLove #PieSign #FreshSignFreshPies #NeighborhoodPieShop

Makin' Thumbprint Cookies
Makin' Thumbprint Cookies

Have you had our thumbprint cookies? We're baking them fresh just for you!

Shortbread Leaves
Shortbread Leaves

Dropping sugar like it's rain from heaven!

I-40
I-40

Stress cannot exist in the presence of a pie. Come get yours and your stress will melt away. #SharePieShareLove #DFW #Colleyville

Thumbprint icing
Thumbprint icing

Icing Mondays. I love my job. It smells good. #thumbprintcookie #icingmovie #makesmells #yum #cookiebite #dessert #buttermilkskypie

Southern Buttermilk Pie
Southern Buttermilk Pie

Handmade Mini Pies. Wanna bite? #dessert #food #desserts #buttermilkskypie #piepic #lovepie #instagood #instafood #sweet #delish #foods #delicious #tasty #eat #eating #hungry #foodpics #sweettooth

Monday Morning
Monday Morning

We are putting out the pies this Monday morning. They are going fast! #pie #tagafriend #piesforthewin #coffeelovespie #desserts #cleanplateclub #southernpies #piecrust #yesplease #foodlove #yummy #foodie #craving

Coconut Cream
Coconut Cream

Freshly baked pies every day. It's Monday. Where are you? #smellovision #video #makepies #lovepies #desserts #piesforthewin #reviewus

Thumbprint Cookies
Thumbprint Cookies

These soft, melt-in-your-mouth cookies are the perfect sweet indulgence when you just want a bite. #boomerang #buttermilkskypie #famouscookies #cookiemovie #sweet

Shortcuts

Category

Nearby bakeries

Other Bakeries in Colleyville

Show All

Comments

Due to the GENEROUS support of our wonderful Bransford families during Laps for Learning, the BES PTA was able to purchase:

🥧 72 mini pies and thumbprint cookies from Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

☕️ Coffee from Einstein Bros. Bagels

and Swiss Miss k-cup pods for ALL of our amazing staff! 🤍💙❤️

Have a safe & Happy Thanksgiving, y’all! 🍂
Hi, I am with Town Hall.
We are preparing a Welcome Kit for new residents that are moving into your community.
Our Welcome Kit can only feature one Bakery and I would like to discuss your being the exclusive Bakery for your communities’ new residents.
I would like to schedule a time when you are expecting me so that I may drop off a sample of our "Welcome Kit" and explain the program in greater detail.
Please message me or for immediate assistance, feel free to call or text me on my cell which is listed below.
Thanks.
Medley Regan
817-706-5851
Thank you to all of our incredible non profits who were featured at today’s October Luncheon and Non-Profit Showcase! Thank you Jason Ridley Agency - and DeWayne Smart/Smart Realty Texas Realtor for sponsoring this great event! Thank you to John Fletcher for donating $1,000 to donor winner Catholic Charities Diocese of Fort Worth, Inc.!!! Thank you Jasonand DeWayne for gifting another $1,000 to drawing winner GRACE Grapevine!!! WHAT A DAY!!!!

Thank you Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop and MOOYAH Burgers, Fries & Shakes for the cookies and lunch! Thank you Crown of Life Lutheran Church for hosting us so well!!
We are so excited for this new chapter for Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop!
Possibly our new favorite in colleyville thank yall
Hope for great success for your family
[email protected]
We heard that Sheila, the new owner of Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop was passing out samples in the school car line! Love the kindness she is spreading today! Sheila you are DINO-MITE! ❤🦖👏👏👏



Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop City of Colleyville Government Colleyville Eats and More Colleyville Eats
Pie It Forward

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop has named their special Pie It Forward flavor for July is PEACH benefitting Teen Life!

Teen Life equips, encourages, and empowers teenagers to face life's challenges through Social Groups on school campuses. Teen Life serves Middle School students, High School students, and student-aged parents in need of social-emotional support.

Help Buttermilk Sky Pie give back to the community while enjoying this month’s special pie. Order yours using the link below:

https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3/?mode=fulfillment
We cannot wait to see you tomorrow!
Thank you so much to our Sponsors!
Co Title
Texas Health and Jason Ridley Agency - Independent Insurance Agent

Spotlight Sponsors:
City of Colleyville
Allen Wealth Advisors
Atmos Energy
Coca-Cola Southwest Beverages
Community Impact Grapevine / Colleyville / Southlake
Community Waste Disposal
PROCO Roofing and Construction
Frost Bank
Market Street
Oncor Electric Delivery
DeWayne Smart/Smart Realty Texas Realtor
Texas Health Harris Methodist Hospital Southlake, Texas
Texas Oncology

In-Kind Sponsors

All About Recognition
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
Colleyville Florist
Haltom's Jewelers
Minuteman Press

THANK YOU!!!!!
Give The Gift Of YUM!

Don’t arrive empty-handed. Give the gift everyone LOVES . . . PIE!

Order yours below from the Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop:

https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3
Thank you for all that you do for our local Veterans! The month of November we can't thank you enough for working with Texas Veterans Outdoors and each one of the local Veterans that they support.
You asked where the dessert was coming from, and you waited long enough ....If you registered for the luncheon today, (you still have time) you not only will have the best from Loveria Caffe ...you will also have the best from the best pie shop around, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop !!!
Go, like their page!!!


https://business.colleyvillechamber.org/events/details/2020-august-monthly-luncheon-21767
Join us today as we visit Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop to take in their rare Peach Pie! Each Peach Pie sold between now and Mid-August goes to support Veterans!!!
x

Other Bakeries in Colleyville (show all)

Quid Pro Dough Bakery C.Marie's Sweets Cold Stone Creamery 23736 Just Dessert MOcookiesplease Wanderful Pastries Argentina's Sweet & Salty Bakery 3rd Shift Cookie Co. ME's Gluten Free Bake Shop Moonlight Cakes Shipley Do-Nuts Local Humble Pies