Clicky

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Colleyville, Texas bakes hand-made pies fresh, daily. We are the taste of Southern tradition! Delivery available via Uber EATS and Door Dash.

At Buttermilk Sky, it is our mission to connect the past and present through the Southern tradition of scratch-made pie. Whether you prefer the traditional slice of a pie, one of our delicious mini-pies, or you're an ice cream fan and love our heavenly Cloud 9, we hope that its sweet, wholesome goodness takes you back to some of your fondest memories. Online Ordering: https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/

Payment Options:   Amex Cash Discover Mastercard Visa

Operating as usual

Want to own a pie shop? Maybe like us, you have been inspired by a grandmother, an aunt or your mom, whose love of bakin...
05/02/2022

Want to own a pie shop?
Maybe like us, you have been inspired by a grandmother, an aunt or your mom, whose love of baking has been handed down through the generations. As you learn more about the Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop franchise opportunity you will recognize that we offer a remarkable career experience, as well as a life-enriching one. Learn More: link in bio.

Photo: @chelseaplaceapts

A year of pie...oh my! One of our favorite ways to celebrate the ones we love is through the gift of pie! This card is r...
04/29/2022

A year of pie...oh my!

One of our favorite ways to celebrate the ones we love is through the gift of pie!

This card is redeemable for (1) 9" or 4" pie for each month of the year. Perfect gift for the pie-lover in your life! Shop online or visit the pie shop near you.

Trending! Looking for ways to make your wedding unique? Try offering your guests a pie bar with all your Buttermilk Sky ...
04/27/2022

Trending! Looking for ways to make your wedding unique? Try offering your guests a pie bar with all your Buttermilk Sky Pie favorites. Let them eat pie! (Isn't that how the saying goes?!).

Photo: @chasingluxphoto

Send to the first person you thought of... :)
04/25/2022

Send to the first person you thought of... :)

This Southern favorite is only available for a few more days. Calling all Lemon Ice Box fans... grab them while you stil...
04/22/2022

This Southern favorite is only available for a few more days. Calling all Lemon Ice Box fans... grab them while you still can.

If you were wondering, you never need a reason to celebrate with a warm slice of pie. The pie is reason enough. Drop a ❤...
04/20/2022

If you were wondering, you never need a reason to celebrate with a warm slice of pie. The pie is reason enough. Drop a ❤️ if you agree.

The perfect party companion! Our Swizzle Sticks are sweet as pie.
04/18/2022

The perfect party companion! Our Swizzle Sticks are sweet as pie.

Tag someone who would love this to be in their Easter basket.We have gift certificates available... in case you can't fi...
04/15/2022

Tag someone who would love this to be in their Easter basket.

We have gift certificates available... in case you can't fit the whole pie in the basket ;) Swing by one of our locations to grab one or a variety of other Easter basket fillers.

Easter is this weekend! Be sure to scoop up your favorite festive sweets before Sunday.
04/13/2022

Easter is this weekend! Be sure to scoop up your favorite festive sweets before Sunday.

Certain foods and smells bring memories rushing back to us, reminding our hearts and souls of precious moments with the ...
04/11/2022

Certain foods and smells bring memories rushing back to us, reminding our hearts and souls of precious moments with the ones we love the most. So, it's time to vote:
What fruit pie wins? Raspberry, Blueberry or Apple?

What's up doc? Just this amazing lemon icebox pie. That's all.  Happy National Doctors Day! You deserve a treat!#treatyo...
03/30/2022

What's up doc? Just this amazing lemon icebox pie. That's all. Happy National Doctors Day! You deserve a treat!
#treatyourself #thankyou

Chocolate pie slow-cooked the right way.  No instant pudding here y'all!
03/28/2022

Chocolate pie slow-cooked the right way. No instant pudding here y'all!

Prom date hack? #pie
03/25/2022

Prom date hack? #pie

Cloud Cookies ☁️ Powdered pillows of perfection!#cookietime #cloudcookies
03/23/2022

Cloud Cookies ☁️ Powdered pillows of perfection!
#cookietime #cloudcookies

Our cream pies are cool, light and delicious. Time for a treat!
03/21/2022

Our cream pies are cool, light and delicious. Time for a treat!

It's almost Spring! #thankgoodness Spring, Lemon Icebox Pie and Fruit Tea.Sweet!
03/18/2022

It's almost Spring! #thankgoodness

Spring, Lemon Icebox Pie and Fruit Tea.
Sweet!

Happy St. Patrick's Day! ☘️ Celebrate with a cool slice of our Key Lime pie or Green colored Thumbprint Cookies!Check ou...
03/17/2022

Happy St. Patrick's Day! ☘️ Celebrate with a cool slice of our Key Lime pie or Green colored Thumbprint Cookies!
Check out the shop for pie server availability.

Avoid the pinch. Keep cookies on hand at all times! ☘️ #SharePieShareLove #Gift #GiftIdeas #ShopLocal
03/16/2022

Avoid the pinch. Keep cookies on hand at all times! ☘️
#SharePieShareLove #Gift #GiftIdeas #ShopLocal

This Spring, have FUN with your pies! Southern Custard is the perfect canvas for any creative spins to create a brand ne...
03/15/2022

This Spring, have FUN with your pies! Southern Custard is the perfect canvas for any creative spins to create a brand new dessert! Today, we're suggesting you add your own raspberry jam and fresh raspberries to the top. This creamy, fruity combo will be the highlight of your week!

Happy Pi Day! Gather ROUND for Pi at Buttermilk Sky! Check with your favorite shop for local specials and celebrations!#...
03/14/2022

Happy Pi Day! Gather ROUND for Pi at Buttermilk Sky! Check with your favorite shop for local specials and celebrations!

#piday

It's March 11th, so you know what that means.. PI DAY (3.14) is right around the corner! We're all gearing up to make su...
03/11/2022

It's March 11th, so you know what that means.. PI DAY (3.14) is right around the corner! We're all gearing up to make sure you have your PI DAY favorites! Check your local shop for deals and preorders available in your area.
#piday

St. Patrick's Day is coming! For a limited time, stop by and pick up some green thumbprint cookies 🍀
03/09/2022

St. Patrick's Day is coming! For a limited time, stop by and pick up some green thumbprint cookies 🍀

Let's talk about lemon…pies, cookies, cloud 9? Yessiree!
03/07/2022

Let's talk about lemon…pies, cookies, cloud 9? Yessiree!

Happy Employee Appreciation Day! We love all BSP Employees and appreciate everyone's hard work to help our bakeries run!
03/04/2022

Happy Employee Appreciation Day! We love all BSP Employees and appreciate everyone's hard work to help our bakeries run!

Babies are the best blessing! Let us help you celebrate your new arrival 👶
03/02/2022

Babies are the best blessing! Let us help you celebrate your new arrival 👶

Is there a better way to celebrate Peanut Butter Lovers Day than with our Peanut Butter Cream Pie? Featuring peanut butt...
03/01/2022

Is there a better way to celebrate Peanut Butter Lovers Day than with our Peanut Butter Cream Pie? Featuring peanut butter and cream cheese sweetened and whipped into a rich filling, set into an Oreo cookie crust. This pie is the perfect way to get your peanut butter fix 😋
#peanutbutter

It's Lemon Season! 🍋 Lemon Ice Box and Lemon Thumbprints are back!
02/28/2022

It's Lemon Season! 🍋 Lemon Ice Box and Lemon Thumbprints are back!

Last Call for Cherry Pie before it is gone until next year! This one is an all-time favorite Seasonal flavor and you don...
02/25/2022

Last Call for Cherry Pie before it is gone until next year! This one is an all-time favorite Seasonal flavor and you don't want to miss it! Grab a couple - one for you and one for a friend. #sharepiesharelove

02/25/2022

We will open at noon on Friday, February 25th. Please be safe out there on the roads!

02/24/2022

Due to inclement weather, we will be closed today. We should be able to resume our normal hours tomorrow, weather permitting.

02/23/2022

Named for Interstate 40, this pie connects people and hearts. It's a twist on pecan pie and our best-seller. We fill the bottom of our signature shortbread crust with pecans and shredded coconut, pour on velvety pecan pie filling, top it off with chocolate chips, and then they're ready to be baked to perfection. Watch to see all stages!

Our Pie Carrier holds a dozen 4-inch pies.  You will be a HERO when you arrive at the office with these in hand. 🥧
02/21/2022

Our Pie Carrier holds a dozen 4-inch pies. You will be a HERO when you arrive at the office with these in hand. 🥧

Our homemade Chocolate Ganache is the perfect blend of melted chocolate and cream, making it the most delicious topping ...
02/18/2022

Our homemade Chocolate Ganache is the perfect blend of melted chocolate and cream, making it the most delicious topping around 😋

Address

4712 Colleyville Blvd., #160
Colleyville, TX
76034

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 7pm
Tuesday 10am - 7pm
Wednesday 10am - 7pm
Thursday 10am - 7pm
Friday 10am - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 8pm

Telephone

(817) 581-7437

Products

9” Pies, 4” Pies, 4” Pies(box of 4), 4” Pies (Box of 12), cookies (single or by the dozen), cloud 9, coffee packages and t-shirts!

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop:

Videos

Category

Nearby bakeries


Other Bakeries in Colleyville

Show All

Comments

Due to the GENEROUS support of our wonderful Bransford families during Laps for Learning, the BES PTA was able to purchase: 🥧 72 mini pies and thumbprint cookies from Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop ☕️ Coffee from Einstein Bros. Bagels and Swiss Miss k-cup pods for ALL of our amazing staff! 🤍💙❤️ Have a safe & Happy Thanksgiving, y’all! 🍂
Hi, I am with Town Hall. We are preparing a Welcome Kit for new residents that are moving into your community. Our Welcome Kit can only feature one Bakery and I would like to discuss your being the exclusive Bakery for your communities’ new residents. I would like to schedule a time when you are expecting me so that I may drop off a sample of our "Welcome Kit" and explain the program in greater detail. Please message me or for immediate assistance, feel free to call or text me on my cell which is listed below. Thanks. Medley Regan 817-706-5851
Thank you to all of our incredible non profits who were featured at today’s October Luncheon and Non-Profit Showcase! Thank you Jason Ridley Agency - and DeWayne Smart/Smart Realty Texas Realtor for sponsoring this great event! Thank you to John Fletcher for donating $1,000 to donor winner Catholic Charities Diocese of Fort Worth, Inc.!!! Thank you Jasonand DeWayne for gifting another $1,000 to drawing winner GRACE Grapevine!!! WHAT A DAY!!!! Thank you Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop and MOOYAH Burgers, Fries & Shakes for the cookies and lunch! Thank you Crown of Life Lutheran Church for hosting us so well!!
We are so excited for this new chapter for Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop! #chamberofcommerce #growingbusiness #buildingcommunity
Possibly our new favorite in colleyville thank yall Hope for great success for your family [email protected]
We heard that Sheila, the new owner of Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop was passing out samples in the school car line! Love the kindness she is spreading today! Sheila you are DINO-MITE! ❤🦖👏👏👏 #dinodeeds #harrietandmillie #millieandharriet #wranglerbetty #tinyarmsbighearts #kindness #pie #dinoslovepie #carline #loveourlocalbusinesses Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop City of Colleyville Government Colleyville Eats and More Colleyville Eats
Pie It Forward Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop has named their special Pie It Forward flavor for July is PEACH benefitting Teen Life! Teen Life equips, encourages, and empowers teenagers to face life's challenges through Social Groups on school campuses. Teen Life serves Middle School students, High School students, and student-aged parents in need of social-emotional support. Help Buttermilk Sky Pie give back to the community while enjoying this month’s special pie. Order yours using the link below: https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3/?mode=fulfillment
We cannot wait to see you tomorrow! Thank you so much to our Sponsors! Co Title Texas Health and Jason Ridley Agency - Independent Insurance Agent Spotlight Sponsors: City of Colleyville Allen Wealth Advisors Atmos Energy Coca-Cola Southwest Beverages Community Impact Grapevine / Colleyville / Southlake Community Waste Disposal PROCO Roofing and Construction Frost Bank Market Street Oncor Electric Delivery DeWayne Smart/Smart Realty Texas Realtor Texas Health Harris Methodist Hospital Southlake, Texas Texas Oncology In-Kind Sponsors All About Recognition Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Colleyville Florist Haltom's Jewelers Minuteman Press THANK YOU!!!!!
Give The Gift Of YUM! Don’t arrive empty-handed. Give the gift everyone LOVES . . . PIE! Order yours below from the Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop: https://www.toasttab.com/buttermilk-sky-pie-colleyville/v3
Thank you for all that you do for our local Veterans! The month of November we can't thank you enough for working with Texas Veterans Outdoors and each one of the local Veterans that they support.
You asked where the dessert was coming from, and you waited long enough ....If you registered for the luncheon today, (you still have time) you not only will have the best #lasagna from Loveria Caffe ...you will also have the best #pie from the best pie shop around, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop !!! Go, like their page!!! #LikeAndShare #ReviewAndCare https://business.colleyvillechamber.org/events/details/2020-august-monthly-luncheon-21767
Join us today as we visit Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop to take in their rare Peach Pie! Each Peach Pie sold between now and Mid-August goes to support Veterans!!!