Sugar on the shelf

Sugar on the shelf Faith-led & woman-owned 🙏💖

Custom desserts, themed decor, and party planning 🎈🎀
Helping you celebrate life’s sweetest moments ✨💛 Link in the bio.

I am a 37 year old mom of 2 with a love for Jesus, books and baking. I will be baking up tasty treats several times a week that can be purchased day of. Be sure to check out my baked good porch pop 2 days a week with a variety of baked goods for sale. You can also pre order baked goods for any special event! I specialize in gourmet cupcakes, cookies, gourmet cakes, macarons and more!! :)

You can also watch me on youtube, bake up tasty book inspired treats while I review my latest reads!

When you’re throwing a toddler rave birthday party, a regular cake just won’t do! 🎧🎂✨Of course, the cake had to be a DJ ...
06/01/2026

When you’re throwing a toddler rave birthday party, a regular cake just won’t do! 🎧🎂✨

Of course, the cake had to be a DJ turntable, and Elmo obviously had to be the DJ! ❤️🎶 From the turntables to the details, this cake was so much fun to create for one of my favorite little dudes as he celebrated turning 2 years old.

Who else thinks Elmo absolutely nailed his DJ debut? 😎🎵

Come see me today at The Bookstore from 11:00 AM - 2:00 PM for the Block of Authors Event! 📚✨Come support talented local...
05/30/2026

Come see me today at The Bookstore from 11:00 AM - 2:00 PM for the Block of Authors Event! 📚✨

Come support talented local authors, shop from other amazing local vendors, and enjoy a fun community event.

I’ll have some of my delicious homemade cookies available, and trust me—you won’t want to miss them! 🍪❤️

Stop by, say hello, and support local businesses and creators. Hope to see you there!

05/21/2026

Why choose between cake and cookies when you can have BOTH? 🍪🎂✨

Two of my favorite desserts combined into one delicious creation! Soft, rich cake layered with all the cookie goodness we love = the ultimate sweet treat 😍

Perfect for birthdays, celebrations, or honestly… just because. 💕 Who else would devour a cake-cookie combo?! 🙋‍♀️

Tomorrow I’ll have BOTH gluten free chocolate chip cookies 🍪 and regular chocolate chip cookies available for purchase!F...
05/12/2026

Tomorrow I’ll have BOTH gluten free chocolate chip cookies 🍪 and regular chocolate chip cookies available for purchase!

Fresh baked, soft, and delicious 😍

Comment below to get yours before they run out!!

Regular
6 cookies for $8
12 cookies for $15

Gluten free
6 cookies for $13
12 cookies for $20

Book lovers, mark your calendars for May 30th from 11-2 because I’ll be back at the bookstore for their Block of Authors...
05/12/2026

Book lovers, mark your calendars for May 30th from 11-2 because I’ll be back at the bookstore for their Block of Authors event! 📚✨

There will be over 90 local authors, poetry readings, kids story time, book-related vendors, and of course… me with the sweets! 🍪💕

I’ll be dreaming up some fun book-themed cookies just for this event, so you definitely won’t want to miss it. Come browse, shop, support local authors, and grab a sweet treat while you’re there!

See you May 30th! 📖🧁

This Nutella Banana Bread is everything you want in a sweet treat—super moist, packed with rich banana flavor, and swirl...
05/06/2026

This Nutella Banana Bread is everything you want in a sweet treat—super moist, packed with rich banana flavor, and swirled with creamy Nutella in every bite 😍 The perfect mix of cozy and indulgent!

Whether you need a little pick-me-up, a treat with your coffee, or something to share (or not 😉), this one hits the spot every time.

Mother’s Day is right around the corner 💐✨If you’re thinking about treating a special mama in your life (or yourself 😉),...
04/30/2026

Mother’s Day is right around the corner 💐✨

If you’re thinking about treating a special mama in your life (or yourself 😉), now is the time to get those goodies ordered! Fresh baked treats, made with love, are always the sweetest way to celebrate.

Send me a message to get your order in 💌

Address

Appleton, WI
54911

Opening Hours

Monday 7am - 5pm
Tuesday 7am - 5pm
Wednesday 7am - 5pm
Thursday 7am - 5pm
Friday 7am - 5pm
Saturday 9am - 4pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sugar on the shelf posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category