Sugar On The Shelf- Home Bakery

Sugar On The Shelf- Home Bakery Faith-led & woman-owned 🙏💖

Custom desserts, themed decor, and party planning 🎈🎀
Helping you celebrate life’s sweetest moments ✨💛

💚🥒 WHO WENT ON A DATE WITH MY CRAZY CREATION?! 🍪💚If you came to the Light the Night Market this past Friday, I need to k...
08/31/2026

💚🥒 WHO WENT ON A DATE WITH MY CRAZY CREATION?! 🍪💚

If you came to the Light the Night Market this past Friday, I need to know… 👀

Did you take a chance and go on a blind date with my Dill Pickle Potato Chip Cookie?! 🥒🥔🍪

Because let’s be honest… this is NOT a cookie for everyone. 😂
You either LOVE IT ❤️ or HATE IT 💔 — there is absolutely NO in-between! 🤣

So tell me… how did your date go?! Was it true love? Did you want a second date? Or was this one a hard pass? 😂👇

And if you missed your chance… LOVE IS BACK THIS SATURDAY! 💕🍪

I’ll have a fresh lineup of Blind Date cookies waiting for you at the Appleton Farmers Market from 8:00 AM–12:30 PM!

You never know who you might meet… 😉💘
Come take a chance on a cookie! 🍪❤️

💕 WHAT A NIGHT! 🍪💕I just want to say a HUGE THANK YOU to everyone who came out to see me last night! 🥹❤️ Your support se...
08/29/2026

💕 WHAT A NIGHT! 🍪💕

I just want to say a HUGE THANK YOU to everyone who came out to see me last night! 🥹❤️ Your support seriously means more than you know!

And you guys… I COMPLETELY SOLD OUT OF THE BLIND DATE WITH A COOKIE! 😱🍪💘 Every single cookie date found someone willing to take a chance, and I couldn’t be more excited!

Now I need to know… 👀

💌 If you went on a Blind Date with a Cookie last night, how did it go?!
Was it love at first bite? 😍
A total mismatch? 😂
Or are you already planning the wedding? 💍🍪

Drop your cookie date review in the comments! ⬇️

And remember… there’s always a chance for a second date. 😉💕 Sometimes you just need a little time to decide if that cookie is the one. 😂

Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU for supporting my little cookie business and making these crazy ideas so much fun! I’m already dreaming up the next round of mystery dates… 👀🍪💘

💕🍪 WHO’S READY FOR A BLIND DATE?! 🍪💕Tonight’s the night! 🎉 Come see me at the Light the Night Market from 5–10 PM and ta...
08/28/2026

💕🍪 WHO’S READY FOR A BLIND DATE?! 🍪💕

Tonight’s the night! 🎉 Come see me at the Light the Night Market from 5–10 PM and take a chance on a BRAND NEW Blind Date with a Cookie! 😍💘

And this time… you have THREE different mystery dates to choose from! 👀

You won’t know exactly what you’re getting until you take that first bite. 🤫🍪 Will it be love at first bite… or a total mismatch?! 😂

💌 3 mystery cookie dates
💌 1 delicious surprise
💌 0 spoilers!

Come find your match tonight and see if your cookie date is The One! 💕🍪

📍 Light the Night Market
⏰ 5–10 PM
✨ Sugar on the Shelf

Who’s brave enough to swipe right on a cookie?! 💘

08/26/2026

🎪🍪 DID YOU GO ON THIS BLIND DATE?! 🍪🎪

If you were at the farmers market this past Saturday, you may have spotted one of our fun Blind Date with a Cookie flavors… the Circus Animal Cookie! 🎠💕

Did you take a chance and go on a blind date with this cookie?! 👀🍪 If you did, I NEED TO KNOW… what did you think?! 😍

And if you haven’t gone on a blind date yet… your chance is coming! 💘

📍 Come see me THIS FRIDAY at Appleton’s Light the Night Market from 5–10 PM for a WHOLE NEW lineup of Blind Date mystery flavors! 🎉

And let me tell you… 🤫
There’s ONE flavor so crazy, you won’t believe it’s a cookie! 🤯🍪

Will you take the chance? 💕
Swipe right on your next cookie crush! 💘🍪

🍂🍪 IT’S ALMOST FALL COOKIE SEASON! 🍪🍂Okay… I’ve officially started dreaming up my fall cookie lineup and I need YOUR hel...
08/25/2026

🍂🍪 IT’S ALMOST FALL COOKIE SEASON! 🍪🍂

Okay… I’ve officially started dreaming up my fall cookie lineup and I need YOUR help! 🎃🤎🍁

If you could turn ANY fall flavor into a cookie, what would it be?! 👀👇

🍎 Apple Pie
🎃 Pumpkin Spice
🍁 Maple
🥧 Pecan Pie
🍏 Caramel Apple
☕ Chai
🤎 Cinnamon Everything
✨ Or something totally WILD?!

I want to hear all your ideas! Drop your dream fall cookie flavor in the comments! ⬇️💭🍪

And who knows… 👀
YOUR idea might just make it onto the Sugar on the Shelf fall menu! 🥰🍂

Let’s make this the BEST fall cookie lineup yet! 🍪🎃🍁🤎

08/24/2026

Another week of BUSY market prep is underway! 🍪✨

This Friday is Appleton’s Light the Night Market and I’ll be there with ALL the delicious cookies! 🎉

And of course… you KNOW I will have the Blind Date with a Cookie! 💕🍪 This week, I’ll have ALL NEW FLAVORS for you to take a chance on. You won’t know exactly what you’re getting until you open it! 👀

📍 Appleton Light the Night Market
🗓️ This Friday
⏰ 5–10 PM

Come grab a cookie (or a few 😉), take a chance on a blind date, and come see what I’ve been baking up!

Who’s coming to see me?! 🍪❤️

08/22/2026

☀️🍪 MARKET DAY IS HERE! 🍪☀️

Come see me TODAY at the Appleton Farmers Market from 8:00–12:30! 🎉

I’ll be set up right in front of Toppers Pizza on College Ave, and I’ll have plenty of sweet treats waiting for you! 🍪❤️

Come grab your favorites, try something new, and maybe even take a Blind Date with a Cookie home with you! 👀💘

📍 In front of Toppers Pizza
⏰ 8:00 AM–12:30 PM
🍪 Sugar on the Shelf

Come say hi, grab a cookie (or four 😉), and make your Saturday a little sweeter! 🩷

Who wants to go on a BLIND DATE?! 💕🍪This Saturday, you’ll have 3 different chances to go on a blind date that might chan...
08/21/2026

Who wants to go on a BLIND DATE?! 💕🍪

This Saturday, you’ll have 3 different chances to go on a blind date that might change your taste buds forever! 😍

Come see me at the Appleton Farmers Market this Saturday from 8:00 AM–12:30 PM! 🎉

📍 I’ll be located right near Toppers Pizza on College Ave!

Will you take a chance on a mystery cookie? 👀🍪
You won’t know exactly what you’re getting until you take your blind date home and open it!

Come find your perfect cookie match! 💘🍪

🍪💕 Have you ever heard of a Blind Date with a Cookie? No?! Well, you’re about to! 😍Come experience your very own Blind D...
08/17/2026

🍪💕 Have you ever heard of a Blind Date with a Cookie?

No?! Well, you’re about to! 😍

Come experience your very own Blind Date with a Cookie this weekend at the Appleton Farmers Market! 🎉

I’ll have all your favorite cookies available, PLUS my Blind Date cookies! Each one comes packaged with its very own dating profile 💌—complete with little hints about the cookie’s personality and flavor.

But there’s a catch… 👀

You won’t know exactly what flavor you’re getting until you buy it and open it! 🤫🍪

Will it be your perfect match? 💕
Will it be a total surprise? 😆
There’s only one way to find out!

📍 Downtown Appleton Farmers Market
🗓️ This Saturday
⏰ 8:00 AM–12:30 PM

Come find your cookie match! 💘🍪

Sugar on the Shelf — where sometimes the best things in life are a little unexpected! 😉

Address

Appleton, WI
54911

Opening Hours

Monday 7am - 5pm
Tuesday 7am - 5pm
Wednesday 7am - 5pm
Thursday 7am - 5pm
Friday 7am - 5pm
Saturday 9am - 4pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sugar On The Shelf- Home Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category